The Geat Melting Pot Or Are We?
By teufelskind
@teufelskind (813)
United States
January 9, 2007 4:12pm CST
They say we as america are known as the melting pot because we have every type of race religion out there. If we are so acepting of others why do we make it so hard for people to get in to america? We are suppose to be so accepting of others and so forth but we sit there and turn people away people that want to live a better life. We as americans have had comfort our whole life why not share it with others and no I dont mean the whole Mexico border thing I mean everyone. I am american and in no way an I teying to bash america I am simply stating that we need to be more accepting. What are your veiws on the great melting pot?
3 responses
@SaraCate (184)
• Canada
10 Jan 07
Another analogy that has become common is the "tossed salad," and I like that one better.
Melting pot implies that people need to be so assimilated that we are all the same. If you put copper and tin in a pot, melt and blend, you get bronze - a uniform alloy. The *goal* of a melting pot is this kind of uniformity.
In a salad, on the other hand, all components retain their individuality. Carrots, lettuce and radish may all be in the same bowl, but they are still individual vegetables.
I think people exist who want the melting pot - who want that kind of uniformity and sameness. As I said in the beginning, I prefer the tossed salad metaphor - the carrots and the radishes may not play well together for a while, but they still have to live in the same bowl - and they have to work things out if life is to remain pleasant.
I think this analogy also illustrates greater acceptance for the rich variety of customs and cultures that make up "American" culture. I think sometimes we forget that *lots* of American culture is borrowed - maybe from Western Europe, but still borrowed!
~Sara
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
10 Jan 07
That is part of the immigration problem today. Immigrants MUST ASSIMILATE. They are no longer Mexicans in America, they are Americans and if they want to be a part of this country, they have to act like it.
I'm not saying strip their culture from them, but they HAVE to "melt".
@SaraCate (184)
• Canada
10 Jan 07
But what does "acting like it" mean? That a teen gril *must* have a 'sweet sixteen' and not a quinceanera or a bat mitzvah? That they *must* were jeans and t-shirts?
Or just that folks who come to the U.S. should learn English? (In which case, we should be obliged to speak *their* language when we're in *their* country...)
The fundamental problem with the melting pot analogy is that, carried out fully, it REQUIRES stripping (or casting off of) any culture other than a bland, homogenized, construct of "Americanism."
~Sara
@teufelskind (813)
• United States
19 Jan 07
yes but some, most just want a better life I am talking more about the people that have been here and had kids here that they tear away from the parents. I see what you are saying
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
10 Jan 07
Theres a pretty simple answer for this.
For the interests of America and the immigrants that move here, you cannot allow everyone to come into the country. Allowing anyone to run in would obviously ruin the country.
Is that fair?
@teufelskind (813)
• United States
10 Jan 07
yes I know that but we should make it not as hard. They could change it there is a difrence between leting others in and leting everyone in then there will be terrorist coming in and we would have anouther 9/11. I am just saying we make it to hard for people.