Potty Training...

United States
January 12, 2007 1:30pm CST
My son is 20 months old and he is a great kid. He goes to bed on time, puts himself to sleep most of the time, gets his own drinks out of the fridge, and plays great by himself. He is, what I call, the perfect child. Well, my husband and I found out that we are expecting baby number 2, and to decrease the stress of two children, I have started trying to potty train my son. He went to the bathroom for the first time today and he seemed very excited, but then disinterested the next time I tried getting him to use it. I know it won't happen over night, but I was wondering what techniques have other people used? Do they work? How old were your kids when they were potty trained? Is it too early for him to start? My sisters kids are 2 1/2 and aren't yet fully potty trained.
4 people like this
36 responses
@Elaeblue (144)
• United States
12 Jan 07
I think(I am a professional nanny) that he is the right age to start. But just remember that it takes a while to complete the process. Put the potty in front of the tv and let him sit for a while or give him a book to look at. After all many adults need a book,too. Make a really big deal about success. This will make him want to do it. Take off all jeans and other pants except pull ups and give him massive amounts of liquids so he gets lots of times to succeed. The more he succeeds the more he will understand. Make sure you tell him what you want him to do. Be prepared for accidents for probably the next year and be patient he wont need the pull ups soon. Also Congrats on your new one.
• United States
12 Jan 07
Haha, I brushed his hair today while he sat on the potty, cause that always keeps him still. He just sat there so good and finally went to the bathroom. I have been told that leaving the toilet in the living room or other places is not good because it gives them the wrong idea about the bathroom, but I think it is very hard to run back and forth all the time, especially since he doesn't know how to hold it. Do you know many people that do use the living room? I wouldn't mind, cause I think he would be able to concentrate better, but I guess I have never thought much about it since I put it in the bathroom.
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
13 Jan 07
Professional Nanny? If that is true, why are you giving such bad advice? Putting the potty infront of the TV? Are you crazy? That is just lazy and it doesn't teach the child anything. The potty is suppose to stay in the bathroom. The bathroom is for potty training. I do know a few mothers that have put the potty in the living room infront of the TV and of course the child will sit there still and watch TV, but that really isn't teaching him much. Children need to learn bathroom manners during potty training. They need to learn to go to the bathroom like everyone else. I mean if you put your child in daycare or have someone babysit your child he isn't going to be able to sit in the living room and watch TV and use the bathroom at the same time. Teach him manners. Potty training takes time. Now, a book is something to try, but actually putting a potty infront of a TV is just not teaching nothing and it's lazy.
@coolcatzz (1587)
• Canada
12 Jan 07
You know I considered my son the same way. The perfect child. So smart and he did everything. I tried training him at 24 months and I guess he just wasn't ready cause it didn't work. So I waited till he was 30 months. I took a week off work to get this done. He was basically trained in 2 days. He just did it on his own. So I guess the key is they'll do it when they are ready. I don't think it's a good idea to push them. Also for both my kids I got a piece of bristol board and I put it on the fridge. Everytime they went they got a sticker. They both were so excited. It worked for us!
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Jan 07
I never really thought about giving them a reward, but that is also a good idea! Thank you!
• United States
12 Jan 07
I might have to find something other than stickers because I am not sure he really cares for them at this point, but maybe a snack he likes, or a toy car. That could get expensive though! Haha. Maybe I will just stick to stickers on a board for now! :) He loves to look at things!
• United States
12 Jan 07
I agree. I think that's a great idea. I wish I had thought about that when I was potty training. I definately agree that they will go when they are ready. The thing that helped me is that they had older brothers that acted as models.
1 person likes this
@Ashida (1370)
• United States
12 Jan 07
My wife and I had a hard time potty training our son, but our daughter took to it within a few days. We just kept at it. We would set him on his potty and lavish him with praise when he used it. It took a month of so before he would use it on his own. I don't think 20 months is too early -- we have friends whose 18 month old girl is potty trained. In contrast our son was almmost three before he would go the day without any accidents.
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Jan 07
Well it is good to know that I am not alone. I did try teaching him earlier, but he would never sit, even if I tried reading him a book. I told my husband at the start of the new year I wanted to teach him, but my son has been sick the past few days, so I didn't want to push it. He was up and running around today and in a good mood, so I thought, what the heck, and he went right away! I was so proud! Thanks for the advice!
@kathy77 (7486)
• Australia
12 Jan 07
Oh you are very lucky to have such a wonderful child. It will take him a few times to get used to going to the toilet it is best if someone goes in their with him so he feels ok, it will take him a bit of time to get used to it. Most of my children were around the same age except for my youngest as she started very young she was not even 1 at the time, and no I do not believe it is too young for him to start. Oh maybe your sisters kids are a bit too lazy.
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Jan 07
Well my sister has twins, so I didn't know if maybe it was just hard, because she has a hard time devoting individual time to each of them, being a single parent. But I didn't know if it was supposed to take that long or not. I have been trying to show him the potty every time I go in there, and he seems to like it, but sometimes he wants to play with it, and that is what I don't like.
@amyh2637 (82)
• United States
12 Jan 07
Its never too early to introduce your kids to the potty. I started potty training my son as soon as he was able to walk around well on his own. At first it was like a game to him and he would only go when I took him. I watched his paterns and noticed that he was usually going number 2 while standing in front of the tv so any time I saw him standing in front of the tv (rather than sitting, lying or playing while watching) I would bring him his little potty and let him sit on it while he watched a movie. It took a long time to get it done that way but I started really early. The good thing is, my son has never (knock on wood) had an accident. He is four now and has been fully potty trained for about a year and a half. We never used training pants or plastic sheets. Just keep in mind that all kids are different and you can't really compare what one kid does to what another might do. Just give them time and remember to always be extra encouraging.
@medooley (1873)
• United States
13 Jan 07
We had our son watch me when he was first learning, but I did sit down. Then he wanted to go just like daddy. Even though he went a couple times there were still lapses where he didn't go potty for a long time. With our son we made it a big party everytime that he went. We got some party hats and blowers. When he would go we would all dance around and sing a potty song... "I went pee pee in the potty, pee pee in the potty." He also got a chocolate kiss when he would go, that seemed to work well for a while. The thing that finally did it for him we thing is that we put him in big boy underwear... Just like dads... And he could only wear them if he went to the bathroom in the potty and if he had an accident in them he wouldn't be able to wear them. Well once we did that it didn't take long at all! Potty training can be a very time consuming task. Just stick with it and eventually he will get it. We all know that he can do it!
1 person likes this
• United States
12 Jan 07
Well he loves to watch his dad go to the bathroom, so I thought this might confuse him at first as to why his dad was standing and he had to sit. But today he did a really good job, and we both clapped when he was done. He throws away his own trash and we always make a big deal out of it, and he gets excited and now does it without being asked, so I am hoping that is how it goes with the potty chair. My son makes funny noises and faces when he goes number 2, so I am hoping to be able to catch him most of the time as well. Thanks for the advice though! And that is awesome that your son took so quickly!
• United States
12 Jan 07
It's not too early. He's doing just fine. One of the tricks that I used with my son's and even with my daughters ( I have 2 of each all teenagers now and well beyond potty training thank god!) was to put the potty chair in front of the t.v. and then sit them on it and put in their favorite video or turn on their favorite television show. Then bring on the drinks!!! Every time your son goes potty make a HUGE DEAL out of him going potty. Make up a silly song and dance and even if you have too give him a penny that he can put in a special "potty jar" that he can save up to go buy something special at the store. Just make a big deal out of him going. The more you do that, the more he will want to go. Don't make such a big deal out of the accidents though. Those are going to happen. He's still a baby. You can even get him some big boy underpants with sponge bob or some other cartoon character on them that he likes and tell him that sponge bob doesn't like to be pottied on. Sometimes that works too. Or at least helps. Anyway. There are a few tips from a mom of 4 who survived so far to teenagehood. Now to see if I can survive the teen years!!! LOL
• United States
12 Jan 07
Thanks for your words of wisdom. I think I will be trying a lot of the suggestions I have got today. I really appreciate everything that you guys have told me, because I really think it will make things easier. He seems to catch on really quickly, so maybe if he doesn't catch on to the potty so quickly, he will catch on to the rewards and making a big deal out of things.
@cherhost (1072)
• United States
13 Jan 07
Hey let me know what worked for you... I have to start the potty training thing here soon too. I am just giving a bit more time since mine is 18 months. And the other reason why I am responding is to say CONGRATS on the new bun in the oven! Good Luck!
1 person likes this
@GardenGerty (160949)
• United States
13 Jan 07
It depends on how consistent YOU are willing to be, and his ability to coordinate his effort. I started about that age with each child, but I also know kids that have trouble even after they start to school :(, depending on how mature their bowel and bladder are. If the weather is cold it is harder for them to stay dry. I had the policy that once I started, I did not put them back in diapers. The exception for that was my son, because he wet so heavily when he slept. If we were going to church or anywhere else, I just took training pants, plastic pants, and extra clothes. Don't make it a power struggle. My son gave up sleeping in diapers after his sister was born when he saw how messy her poopy diapers were. I know I was not much help, my kids were just basically easy. I used a ring that sat on top of the regular toilet and carried it and extra underwear in a bag like a diaper bag. By his second birthday he was dry when he was awake. Good luck and congratulations on the second child.
• Israel
13 Jan 07
Its never too early to introduce your kids to the potty. I started potty training my son as soon as he was able to walk around well on his own. At first it was like a game to him and he would only go when I took him. I watched his paterns and noticed that he was usually going number 2 while standing in front of the tv so any time I saw him standing in front of the tv (rather than sitting, lying or playing while watching) I would bring him his little potty and let him sit on it while he watched a movie. It took a long time to get it done that way but I started really early. The good thing is, my son has never (knock on wood) had an accident. He is four now and has been fully potty trained for about a year and a half. We never used training pants or plastic sheets. Just keep in mind that all kids are different and you can't really compare what one kid does to what another might do. Just give them time and remember to always be extra encouraging.
• United States
13 Jan 07
First of all - does he stay dry when sleeping? If he has not developed bladder control, then I wouldn't push him. If he is able to stay dry all night, and during naps, then you can try potty training him. I use the timer technique with my daughter - I set the timer (portable cooking timer) from last time she peed, for about 45 minutes (depends if she is drinking a lot), as soon as the timer goes off, I say "It's potty time!", and put her on the potty. Now she's gotten used to it, so when she's playing by herself and the timer goes off, she yells "potty time!", and starts undressing herself. You should absolutely not put the potty in front of the TV- you want him to be aware of what he's doing. The easiest way to train, is to skip the diapers, and put on underwear (that you can let him pick in the store). He will soon realize that peeing in his pants, makes him feel wet, and he won't like it. And most important of all- praise him for peeing in the potty, tell him that it makes you sooo happy!!! Good luck!
1 person likes this
• Egypt
13 Jan 07
i love kids soo mutch have anice time with ur baby
1 person likes this
@lifeiseasy (2292)
• United States
13 Jan 07
I have a 2 yr old and she is the same way as your son. She comes to me and tells me that she is ready for bed, she basically did not want to use a potty chair, I had bought a potty chair that played music and a smaller seat for the reg. seat , she wouldn't use any of the above she just decided one day she wasg oing to use the big potty nad from then on she has with no problems. She was about 13 months but that is alittle young for most so don't get hung up on the ages of the kids. They will when the time comes. As for your sis's kids maybe she can start a little game with the kids and give them a star when they use the potty and show both( yours and hers) how they can earn one and maybe they will respond to that. Plus its fun to make games with the kids to love it so much. have fun .
• United States
13 Jan 07
My daughter was very easy to potty train, she was fully trained and stayed dry through the night by age 2 1/2. Both of my boys took a little longer. They were fully potty trained by age three. They didn't have as much interest as her, and I didn't push them. What worked well for me was the book "Once Upon a Potty." There is a girl version and a boy version and the book was really helpful with all three of my kids. It put the idea in their head, and they really liked me to read it to them several times a day. I have heard of people having success by doing things like throwing cheerios in the toilet and having their son "aim," things like that...but I always thought that was a little strange. Anyway, He isn't even two yet so I would just give him more time and not rush it. If you just found out about your pregnancy, you still have many months to help him learn. Congratulations on baby number two!
• United States
12 Jan 07
All of my kids were potty trained before they were 2 ...we played the lets go potty game..every 15 minutes I would sit them on the pot and read a quick story to them, so it was basically just catching them before they could use the diaper, we also used cloth diapers, they are much more likely to not want them wet..disposables hold so much, and they cant feel the wetness! also alot of kids regress when you have a second baby close to the same age, to avoid regression, I did NOT talk or coo at the new baby when I did a diaper change, but made a big deal of "potty time", that way the older child does not relate wet diapers to cooing, and loving time! All 7 of my kids are less that 11 months apart..best of luck@!
• United States
12 Jan 07
Wow thanks! That is definitely a good suggestion, I had never thought of that. I never really talked to my son like a baby, and I think that is part of why he acts so mature already. I definitely will make a big deal out of going to the potty, and that is a great suggestion for when the new baby comes along! I have tried to use cloth diapers, but it gets hard because my husband refuses and my son gets confused when we switch so much. Thanks for the advice!
• United States
13 Jan 07
My son (now 4 1/2) started at 20 month and was fully potty trained at 2 yr. My daughter (now 21 months) satred about 2 weeks ago and may also be trained by 2 yrs. She goes to the bathroom whenever we go. Se imitates us. It works kinda well.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Jan 07
It sounds like you have a remarkable son My son will be 3 on Monday god willing and one day I just said no more diapers went the K-mart and got him some underwear and those rubberpants by the way didnt work very well. I just kind of looked for when he started taking his own diapers off. That lets you know he doesnt like to be wet any longer. almost immediately after i started put in the underwear he started pottying on his on. but let me tell you he first grabbed a bucket not the potty and started pee-peeing for some reason that was his choice of preference he does go to the toilet to do the other thing. Hey the bucket works for him. Dont worry he will be there in no time.
1 person likes this
@jgeorge (132)
• India
13 Jan 07
its great to hear ur child is a fast learner.it should be noted that your care is needed by ur child all time even if u do expect another one.i personally as told by my mother had been taught to go to the bathroom alone while i was 1yrs,around my 26th month.she told the trick was that shee used to keep the bathroom tidy,colourful,and plesent odoured so that i would love to go in alone.making me play with the shadows of water in a mug occupied me so that i never felt her going out and after around 10 to 20 minutes shell come back to look at me.she told usually when i got bored i used to get out ,and so she taught how to wash up andeven bathe by myself when i was around 2.but still i recommend your son is too small to look after himself.love and care him well so that ur children will love u their whole life.
@adolesc11 (101)
• China
13 Jan 07
Your son is very lovely.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Jan 07
I don't think that its too early at all. Boys do take a litte more time to train than girls, but for the most part your son should go to the bathroom with his father since the have the same part and that will also help him learn. This might be a little weird but it also will help if you let him go without a diaper or pull up on while hes in the house. This is how I did my child because as long as they are wearing something they know they can do their business in they will.
@kabella50 (309)
• United States
13 Jan 07
most kids don't train until 3 years.I know many women will tell you stories of how their child trained at some unbelievable age,but I am 56 years old and have raised 5 girls and 2 nephews.They all trained the same.by three.Then some wet the bed and some didn't,but don't worry him much afterall he has been doing his business one way for 2 years and he had no idea that things would change.Let him go to the bathroom with your husn=band some time just to hang around, and he'll want to do what daddy does sooner or later.