Enigma

@anoyzz (32)
Portugal
January 16, 2007 1:51pm CST
Here i give you all an enigma a friend told me and asked to solve it. I took some time to resolve it, but the answer is quite intelligent. Well, a guy starving to death enters a room, where there are two twin brothers, and a table with two similar baskets with food on it, one poisoned and the other not. One of the brothers always lies, and the other always speaks the truth. You don't know witch one is witch, and you don't know witch basket is poisoned. The question is: doing ONLY one question to ONLY one of the brothers, how would you determine witch basket can you eat from ? Don't cheat using google ! Think a little :P I'll give the answer if no one resolves it.
2 people like this
3 responses
• Portugal
17 Jan 07
Hmm, that's quite an enigma! The problem is the one question limit! It must be something that envolves asking both something, but beeing actually only asking to one, am i on the right way ? The question he does, has to be an yes/no question?
2 people like this
@anoyzz (32)
• Portugal
17 Jan 07
You are in deed on the right way! And it doesn't have to be an yes/no answer!
2 people like this
@gonzalu (216)
• Portugal
18 Jan 07
hmmmmmm..... At this time I would kill both bothers and eat them (I was really starving....) :) is this the right answer? :p
1 person likes this
@anoyzz (32)
• Portugal
19 Jan 07
HAHAHH... it's not the right answer, but it's shurely the best one :P
1 person likes this
@gonzalu (216)
• Portugal
20 Jan 07
:D thanks for your apreciation
@dopey22girl (3319)
• United States
9 Apr 07
Ok, I am going to do this without looking at the reponses previous to mine, as I just did with the last one I just did. Let's see...this is a really tricky one! At first, I would've said ask, "Are you the liar?" But obviously that wouldn't work because the liar could just say no. Hmm this is really difficult! Ooh..an answer just occured to me! Maybe ask them, what is 2 plus 2. Since the one brother always lies, he wouldn't answer 4, and then you would know. Am I right?