Is Abortion Ok?
By jlelite
@jlelite (33)
United States
October 7, 2006 4:59am CST
If a woman is raped, is it alright for her to get an abortion? I am undecided on this particular instance, but otherwise am completely AGAINST abortion!
38 responses
@soulsister_16 (738)
• Switzerland
1 Aug 07
I don't think it's alright. It is almost equivalent to murder!
1 person likes this
@mcduffie_sandy (87)
• United States
14 Oct 06
No,abortion is never okay,because the woman who chooses abortion have a better chance of causing herself to be killed,gain some kind of disease,end up never being able to have kids never again,and etc.that I don't know for sure about.But the other stuff,I heard about on the news and learned it from somebody else.It's better to have a baby,because it's a gift from God!!!Besides,anyway,if God didn't want us to have babies,He wouldn't have allowed us to be able to produce.And knowing that there are some people in the world who can't even reproduce or can't have children really does wish that they can be able to have babies!
@icantfindthespacebar (729)
• United States
14 Oct 06
You make valid points, but I hate to think that God would present the "gift" of a baby in the form of such a brutal act of torture as rape. Until you've been placed in the raped woman's position, you can never really know how you'll feel.
I do respect that you feel strongly about though. I think it's a very important thing to feel for.
@Tanya8 (1733)
• Canada
16 Oct 06
mcduffie sandy, Do you live in a country where abortion is illegal? The risks you mentioned can certainly happen if an abortion is performed by an untrained person in a non-sterile environment. But an abortion performed by a doctor in a clinic or hospital is much less risky than actual childbirth.
Also, although I sympathise with people who can't have children, there are already too many older children in the world who aren't getting adopted. Is it fair for couples to take advantage of a rape victim's circumstances so that they can have a newborn?
@icantfindthespacebar (729)
• United States
14 Oct 06
Just because a woman was raped, it is not the child's fault. Should they be punished? Though, it is a very ethical debate, as to when a child becomes a person in the womb.... I try not to think about it, because I can never come to a formed opinion one way or the other. I do know that I would never have an abortion, regardless of the situation or circumstances. Too much guilt attached.
@icantfindthespacebar (729)
• United States
14 Oct 06
I do believe in choices though. And I do believe that a perosn should not judge a woman for an action of her choice when it comes to a situation the judging person has never experienced. If a woman is brutally raped and can not stand the idea of carrying that child, a person can not judge her decision of aborting unless they are intimately familiar first-hand with the feelings she is experiencing. People that judge raped and tortured women for their decisions to abort can not intelligently back up their arguments, because they have no idea what they're talking about unless they've been in the position.
@icantfindthespacebar (729)
• United States
14 Oct 06
And I suppose it is also impossible for me to say as I did above that I would absolutely never regardless of the circumstances, because that's just it. I've never experienced the circumstances or been put in the position of having to choose. I don't think anybody else that has never experienced it can honestly say "absolutely not" either.
@sassybritches72 (494)
• United States
11 Oct 06
I think that if a woman is raped she has every right to have an abortion. there is the option for adoption but how well would a woman take care of herself and the unborn child if her growing belly is a constant reminder of what happened to her, in that case she may have no desire to take care of herself for the babies sake. there are also all the questions of what may be wrong with the child, the woman has no way of knowing if the rapist has any diseases or genetic problems. I feel that a woman that is raped is well within her rights to have an abortion and I can completely understand why she would want to.
@amarines13ytch (243)
• United States
19 Oct 06
If the rapist had any diseases it would be found out at the prenatal appointment, and there are ways to find out if anything is wrong with the unborn child. As stated above in one of the peoples comments, it's not our right to judge. Unless it's happened to you, you will never know. I myself could not do abortion. I do not believe in killing a child who still has a chance in this world. Yes it may be hard, yes every day would be a growing reminder of what happened, but I could never bring myself to abort. Whether the baby is at 4 weeks inside me or 8.. It's still a baby.. With a heart beat and a life. Other women may not be able to handle the presure, but the way I see it is.. You get raped, you will NEVER forget, you abort that baby and that's more thats going to hang over your head for the rest of your life. And yes there are millions of people who do not get the honors of bearing their own children and they are praying for the day someone will lay an infant child in their hands for them to hold, love, and cherish for the rest of their lifes here on earth. I think it's only right to give the child a chance. But, in the same manner like I said, some women are not strong enough to do that, and that is okay. There is nothing wrong in being weak in something so horrible as being raped. This was a good post, and I hope it continues to get good feedback.
@zubair439 (3183)
• India
14 Oct 06
Abortion is MURDER, under any circumstances. In these cases, I believe Adoption is a very good option. There are lots of couples in the world who want children, but for whatever reason, cannot have them. I believe the Lord allows things like this to happen, in order to test us, to see what we will do. Our life is a journey to determine our destination for the next one
@achilles7 (1276)
• India
18 Oct 06
I do not support abortion. The situation is something very different. She carrying a baby the she may not like at all and the birth against her wishes.In that situation it is the right of the women to decide to have anabotion or not.
@mcduffie_sandy (87)
• United States
19 Oct 06
Well,murder ain't the case to solve the problem.And thanks for responding.
@mcduffie_sandy (87)
• United States
18 Oct 06
Yes,I think it's fair for couples to adopt a newborn that's born out of rape from their natural mother.But it can be someone in you family willing to adopt your baby,if that's what you want.Or someone that you feel that are good parents,inspite of the fact they are not from your family memebers.But if you rather keep your baby that born out of rape,that's even cooler.At least you'll get the chance to know whether they are going tobecome somebody bigtime in life or average in life and still doing okay,you know.Besides,anyway,the baby will apart of you,just as much as it is a part of the father of him or of her.Sounds fair enough,Tanya?
@Kbriscall (191)
• United States
19 Oct 06
I say that I would never get an abortion, for me I don't believe in it. But being put in the position of Rape I do not know what my decision would be. I definately would not judge or look down upon a person for aborting a pregnancy that resulted from rape. I do and would judge a person who uses abortion as a form of birth control. I found out not to long ago that my sister had an abortion at the very same time that I miss carried twins, this really hurt me, because I wanted my babies, and to find out she threw away hers as I lost mine was unbelievable. I think about it all the time and have changed my opinion of her, especially since she later had a child by the same man and is still with him now, 8 years later.
@missybal (4490)
• United States
19 Oct 06
I believe it is okay if they are raped or if health problems show that she and the child would not survive the birth. With the rap thing could you imagine your child asking who's my daddy, and you can either tell the truth and it may really affect your child or be keeping this terrible secret all your life. Otherwise I am against because there are plenty of ways to prevent pregnancy and if you think Oh I can just get an abortion that is wrong. I know a woman who has had 3 and thinks it's no big deal. She was mad, because she was married got pregnant and her husband wouldn't let her get another abortion because he wanted his child. They are divorsed now and she has the kid and I don't know why because she hates him.
@shygirl_msgemini (15)
• Thailand
14 Oct 06
You know abortion is not the solution because even you abort the child it will never be erase what happen to you in the past or it cannot back the past because it waas already happen. I know it was hard for you but you must let the baby live,see the world. Don't you know that it was a gift from God and you will know how strong you are if you accept the baby. My point is abortion is not the solution if you don't like the baby after you give birth you can bring the baby in a charity much better. In there they can give your baby a good future. All you need to move on forgot what happen if you learn to accept the truth, I know it was so hard but you need to. That's not ok
@toonatoons (3737)
• Philippines
14 Oct 06
for me, it's never okay, no matter what the situation is. every child is a gift, a blessing, and they deserve to live. no one knows what the future holds for the unborn. who knows? he could be the next president, a great scientist, a beloved pope.
@sweet_lucy (27)
• Canada
14 Oct 06
I'm against abortion... for myself that is. If somebody else feels that they need to have that done, the scenerio given for example, who are we to say if they're doing the right thing. If that were to happen, and a decision was made to have an abortion, I wouldn't try to talkthe person out of it, but I would made sure that they knew the consequences of their actions... that they would never be able to change it.