reading or watching tv?
By jessmtiu
@jessmtiu (251)
Philippines
January 24, 2007 8:54pm CST
What would you rather do-- read a book or watch the movie that was adapted from a book? There are so many movies nowadays that were adapted from books-- there's the harry potter series, the lord of the rings, etc. I personally like reading the books rather than watching the movies. The movies I feel have mutilated the books and the stories are not what they are initially meant to be. I think these movies are doing a grave injustice to the writers of these books.
12 people like this
114 responses
@arkana (48)
• Philippines
25 Jan 07
I like watching movies, and i like movies that you've mention. i think movies producer or directors didn't violated any rights of the writers. we know, before they make the movie they already consulted, ask permission to the writers, even for the changes on stories i gues ^_^. Well, maybe their reason is cost effects, budgets; coz in our mind imagination has no limits unlike in reality. Changing some points in stories is someway to make it most appealing to the viewers. And if not for the movies, i think these books we'll never be heard only those like you who love to read books. No hard feelings on my point of view. ~_^
2 people like this
@ashumit02 (818)
• United States
25 Jan 07
i like Reading whenever in nite and watching TV on certain programmes
1 person likes this
@Garameo (902)
• Germany
25 Jan 07
in the past i have read the book first and then i watched the movie. and i think in the past it was the best but then i´ve read the parfum and watched the movie 1 year later. it was not the same. i thought the movie was better than the book. it was a new particular expirience for me.
@xionous (439)
• Belgium
25 Jan 07
it differce from case to case. i have read some books those were awesome and later i have watched the movie based on that book and that movie sucks. but incase of harry potter the movie is definitely better i think. never the less lord of the rings is better then its paper version.
1 person likes this
@pamskie88 (72)
• Philippines
25 Jan 07
I would rather read the book thers much happenings in the book that were not included in the movies
@_charmed_ (10)
• Philippines
25 Jan 07
i love both i love to watch and i love to read books especially sydney sheldon stories..
@dopey22girl (3319)
• United States
25 Jan 07
I would rather read the book. In my experience, the book is always better than the movie.
1 person likes this
@diannebcrs (1549)
• Philippines
25 Jan 07
me too. take for instance dan brown's Da Vinci code. brilliant cast and production but it just fell short somehow. the book was far more spectacular than the movie.
@VanessaOwL (342)
• Brazil
25 Jan 07
both
but first I wacthed the movie and next I read the book
they both are fun so I do them ^^
The movie is exciting I can see the scenes in front myself and listing the characters voice. but on the book I can imagine the scenes happnes.
but if I don't like the movie i don't read the book...
2 people like this
@chimex4real2k2 (1853)
• Nigeria
25 Jan 07
i would prefer to watch the movie rather than read the book. watching the movie makes it feel that there is more reality to it
1 person likes this
@suchetan230044 (618)
• India
25 Jan 07
definite;ly it would bve watching tv for me.its both visual effect as well as hearing,greater impact than books.i dont think movies are doing injustice.its different from the way you interpreted the theme of the story in than books.thanks
1 person likes this
@Spid4r (176)
• India
25 Jan 07
It's always made me smile when people equate TV with intelligence. Sure there is some pretty dumb stuff on TV, but there are also many expertly crafted TV shows, such as Six Feet Under, The Shield, Studio 60 and a host of others. Definitely, cable gives a writer much more freedom on the subjects they can tackle and explore, but in recent years, there seems to be better plotted shows on network TV, problem is, they get cancelled before given the chance. .... But If you started reading books instead of watching TV,your vocabulary would definitely increase and your view of the world would morph as you read. Reading requires more concentration, I think, and is a much more personal, private experience. You and the author connect on some level and you are responsible for creating the images in your head based off what the author has crafted.
@pratikshah (87)
• India
25 Jan 07
I like watching tv.It is the best entertainment that we can get.It contains all the channels at the same place.....I used to watch discovery and sports channels.
I also like reading books.I like to readnovels but i prefer tvmore thn books.
1 person likes this
@EdwardF (431)
• United States
25 Jan 07
I'd rather see the movie. I don't like to read very much. I can watch the movie in 2 hours and reading takes me forever. I don't thik making a movie from a good book is doing an injustice to the writers. Look at the examples you gave. They were excellent movies.
@nguyenthanhbinh2008 (120)
• Vietnam
25 Jan 07
I like reading books than watching the movies. Cause of when I read book, I am able to imagine all pictures about the content of story. But when I watch the movies, I only see the picture that express the idea of film director. So it is quite different than what I had read.
1 person likes this
@pats6182 (4)
• India
25 Jan 07
It all depends, as everyones views it from an different angle,would differ from person to person.
But as for me i would still prefer going in for both, i would be neutral, i would not prefer goin in for one, as for me some would be better go for books while at some books would be drag n boring, not at the least intersting...... Cause picturization always would give a more clearer picture......
Besides how well were these writers known before their books were described in form of movies, werent these people all more famous.....
Look at Jk Rowling........have earned ,millions
@doingit4fun (917)
• United States
25 Jan 07
I like to read but recently I am watching movies made on the books. For example The Devill Wears Prada. I would have not thought about reading that novel but I watched the movie and enjoyed.
1 person likes this
@creavin007 (131)
• India
25 Jan 07
I like to watch Cartoon or comedy films which give relax
1 person likes this
@anyutza (138)
• Romania
25 Jan 07
I must admit that is easier for someone to watch the movie that was adapted from the book than reading it.But,if you really enjoy the movie I guess you would like to read the book also to see if the movie is the original ecranisation of the subject`s book
@lvap0628 (731)
• Philippines
25 Jan 07
in the case of harry potter and lord of the rings, i both read and watched the movies. i wanted to see how the directors interpreted the authors' vision especially with regards to the scenery and action.
for the others, i'd rather read the book because movies tend to shorten the story. sometimes i wait for scenes that i know i read in the book but i am disappointed when they are not used in the movies.
1 person likes this
@dhaliwalrosedeep (446)
• India
25 Jan 07
i like to watch movie loard of the rings
1 person likes this