dhoni vs karthik .....

i think dhoni is the between these two .of course ,karthik is also a good player .but he is not better than dhoni.dhoni have the capability of hitting any ball .i think karthik keeping is well .my opinion is karthik want to settle as a batsman in the indian team.

Ya as a wicket keeper Dhoni is better than Karthik..Also better batsman..No doubt for it.But Karthik is also doing well..I mean to say batting..So one can select him in a team as a batsman not as a wicketkeeper..

I think Dhoni is better than Karthik He is better batsman too

if u ask for keeping abilities, Karthik is better than Dhoni but as a batsman Dhoni is always better than Karthik especially in ODI's

well karthick has proved his point in the one dayers.....it is upto the selectors......but my choice would be to stay with dhoni.......

I agree with u . Not only me i think all of them agree with the same thing.

I think there is quite a battle is going on right now, this is good for Indian cricket, because of his big hitting Dhoni will get a chance over Kartheek, but Kartheek is technically very good than Dhoni

i think dhoni is a better wicket keeper than a batsman, karthik is a good batsman,karthik can have a place of kaif, dhoni should be there,

well i think in this situtation Dhoni is best...........kartik has to seek other person to replace......

I think there will be hard battle were happen on the match. that battle is good for Indian cricket in the future, because of dhoni big hitting will get a chance over Karthik, but from technically side, karthik more good than Dhoni. better for sure you watch the macth.

I like dhoni very much,I like dhoni because he plays well and a hard stroker,but karthik is also a good batsman to INDIA,But i like DHONI very much.

hai i like dhoni

actually karthik is now proving his capability of batting so he may be an useful player for the future india... but dhoni is a well settled player in our team and he is capable of hitting huge shots for our team and also a good keeper.. so i think both are needed for our team..

i think bot will find their place for wc but dhoni will be playing most of the matches and will be in final 11. karthik is as good a keeper or even better than dhoni but when it comes to hitting dhoni is the "best in the world". karthick is a good batsman too. dhoni is the best bastman n hitter

i think dhoni is better

My opion, Dhoni is best compare with karthik..

i think dhoni is better than karthik.even though karthik is improving,.

i like both . But mostly i like dhoni as he is firing for big hit

i think both are very necessary for our team.... both of dem are different in their styles...

ya i agree that dhoni is better as he can hit the ball hard...with bat too