People of Color/Women - Will Things or Can Things Be Equal?
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
United States
January 26, 2007 6:46pm CST
A few days ago someone started a discussion about Barak Obabma and was wondering if anyone thought it was possible for a man of color to actually make it to the White House (I wonder why they call it that?).
It was and is my opinion that if he opposes Hillary Clinton, they will both lose. I based this on my own belief that the Independent Party (again, purely my own view), usually takes away votes from the party that should be in control of the power.
After having to be off the computer for a few days due to some computer functionality problems, I have been stewing over whether this is really what I believed or not and I am now having some conflicting views that go back close to 30 years ago.
They go back to when I was one of West Virgina's first women underground coal miners. When a miner first gets hired they undergo a training period and must wear a red hard hat, so they will be easily identifiable by those that have had more experience. In addition, the "red hats", as they are known, are never allowed to work alone. They must always have at least one other person working with them.
In the area of WV that I lived in at the time there were not very many African American people; but there was one single black man working at the mine who was also a "red hat", as was I. He and I were on the same shift rotation and it became common practice for the supervisor to give the hardest and dirtiest job (such as shoveling coal dust in a 3' area from underneath a rolling conveyor belt up onto it) for the entire shift, to the "black man" and the "woman". Of course, we were never called nice words like the ones I just used in the previous sentence, it was more like the "n" and the "c". The supervisors were able to actually "use" us as movivators for the rest of the crew. If we did a not so good job he could say, "Oh, well, it was just (insert the words)!" If we did a good job he could say, "What's wrong with you men, are you going to let (insert the words once again) show you up?"
Now, what this has to do with the presidential election I don't know; but the question the other poster raised brought this buried memory back to me, and as I reflect, I see that not really that much has changed at all. Sadly ~Donna
2 people like this
17 responses
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
27 Jan 07
You know, I try to base my opinion of someone based on that individual, rather then a characteristic about them - female, person of color.
I would love to see a female in the while house, because I am a female (I am woman, hear me roar), but I would not vote for Hillary. When she stood by Bill, in spite of his antics with Monica, she set up women's rights by 50 years, she gave men permission to lose control.
I am not a person of color (does that mean I am transparent) but I would not hesitate to vote for one, if I felt they had the right criteria to be president.
Yes, there is still racism and sexism in America, but I would like to believe that with each day, it is decreasing and that some day it will not be a consideration when people judge others.
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
28 Jan 07
No, Deb, not being a person of color does not make you transparent - but by the same token, are band-aids that are marked "flesh-colored" really colored to match all flesh? ~Donna
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
29 Jan 07
And one more thing Deb, you are most certainly entitled to your opinion; and yes, I too was very disappointed and saddened at Hillary's choice to stay with a cheating husband at first. My gut reaction was the same as yours. But, is that not what I carried all of those signs back in the 60s and 70s for? Was it not so a woman could choose as she wanted to without someone telling her how to choose? I can remember that I quit carrying those signs because they became way too much of a burden when Helen Gurley Brown commented that "a woman who chose to stay at home and raise her children" was setting the movement back. To me, that comment set the movement back. "Choice" was the key word in my opinion; and again, in my opinion, "Choice" is what Hillary opted for. It may not have been my choice and it may not have been your choice; but it was the choice of another sister, and for that I must respect her decision. With that being said, is it not some sort of reverse discrimiation saying you would vote for a woman, but not for a "qualified woman" simply based on a choice she had made in her personal life? And using your last sentence, is it not just a bit judgemental using that as a reason to not vote for her?
I would totally understand it if you were to say, "I don't think she is qualified in Homeland Defense". "I don't think she is qualified in Budgeting, or any of the many other presidential duties. Alas, I do go on ~Donna
1 person likes this
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
27 Jan 07
I'd like to say that I'm fairly sure eventually we'll have a black (or any other nonwhite) president or a female president. Exactly how soon that will happen, we'll have to wait and see.
I get frustrated with people who claim that there is now no inequality. I get even more frustrated with the people that claim white males are now the ones that are treated unfairly.
I grew up in small-town Kentucky, and racism is most certainly still alive there. In fact, I've even seen black people be the only ones to get arrested for crimes that were committed by a group of people, both black and white.
As for the equality of women, we have it a lot better than we used to. We can vote, work outside the home, etc. That doesn't mean we have reached "equality" yet. We're still likely to make less money for the same work, be passed over for promotions, and be treated differently.
When true equality is going to exist, I don't know. But as long as there are people working towards it, I'm not willing to say that it will never happen.
3 people like this
@Celanith (2327)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I don't know if a black man or woman will be elected but see no reason they should not be if they qualify for the job. And I have seen some in my day that sure qualify better than our last and our current presidents.
but no there is not equality, there is still discrimination all over the place and it is just subtle. For one thing women and or even men who are stay at home care providers, domestic engineers or homemakers what ever you call them should have wages the same as everyone else. Women or men who choose to stay home and raise a family should get the same pay as a day care provider at least.
Instead society thinks we are worthless and lazy which is a big lie.
@destinycole (827)
•
27 Jan 07
Sadly I have to agree, I doubt there will ever be a black president in the USA or a prime minister in UK.
Do you know that makes me feel??? Angry that yesterdays prejudice cannot be buried, that a minority of people cannot look past the colour of someones skin to the soul of the man or woman.
Politically correct people say colour of skin does not matter but I have to argue that it does and that makes me heart sick.
I was brought up to believe that colour did not matter, nor did religion or the fact that Mum was a single parent and Dad had disappeared into the Ether.
Sadly many people do not feel this way and where not brought up to believe what I believe. God bless Martin Luther King, one day I would love to think his dream will be trully fulfilled.
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
29 Jan 07
Thank you destiny. Cheer up, sweet sister. We just need to keep the lines of communication flowing and keep talking about it - never letting people forget that we are all ONE, we are all of ONE, and we will all go back to ONE. ~Donna
1 person likes this
@Evacuee (1147)
•
27 Jan 07
I think it might have been me who asked the question about Barack Obama as I was most interested to know what the guys (both sexes) opinions were and if they ever thought he had a chance of the presidency.
Not teaching grandma to such eggs but I found on The White House website the following, and I cannot paste it!
At various times in history The White House has been known as the Presidents Palace, The Presidents House, and the Executive Mansion. President Theodore Roosevelt officially gave its current name in 1901.
I think that if a coloured person is capable of doing the job then he must be elected by the people the same as a woman president should be.
2 people like this
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
28 Jan 07
Thank you for your post Evacuee, and thank you for giving me the name I was looking for. Another poster said she had never seen an obese president; thus eluding to why I had not mentioned obesity in my discrimination issues; and I could not remember, was Theodore not rather rotund? Or are those facts only to be found in the Rotunda? Oh, dear, it's getting late and I'm getting a little slap happy! Again, thank you for your posting and the history information - it is appreciated. ~Donna
2 people like this
@equalizer (65)
• Philippines
27 Jan 07
Speaking of laws, rights and privileges I think people are equal but when it comes to attitudes, it will take a long long time, maybe another 2-3 generations before we see peoples attitudes change with regards to this issue. Blacks will always be what they are now.
2 people like this
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
28 Jan 07
The ONLY change that I have seen in my lifetime has been in the land of TV. I remember how African Americans were protrayed in the early 50s and it was not always in the best light. The only time they got top billing is if they were great entertainers: Sammy Davis, Jr., Ella Fitzgerald, etc.
Then along came the Bill Cosby Show and middle class white Americans thought, "Now isn't this decent of us, giving these (at this time colored was appropriate) colored people a show of their own". What in the world was that about? I wasn't all that old in my mid teens perhaps, but that show really angered me. How in the world could most black American families really relate to that program? I lived in a city where there were several projects and I saw how my friends lived (I didn't live much better; but I was fortunate in being an only child so my parents didn't have to support a large family). I didn't know any white families that had a Doctor Dad who stayed at home with his practice and a Mother Lawyer. To me, it was just Bill Cosby selling out (please feel free to disagree with me if you are an African American, you would most certainly have more insight on this topic than I).
At least now, we are seeing more than the 1 token black actor/actress on each TV program. You know, the one that never gets to have a relationship because that would the require hiring of 2 black actors. That is changing. We are now seeing more realistic characters with realistic lives. We are watching the African Americans as some of them gradually make their ways out of the areas they came from and succeed; as some of them stay in the areas of success they were born into and continue to succeed, and unfortunately, as some of them continue to live the only life they have ever know - to gang bang. Sometimes Spike Lee confuses the hell out of me; but I think he makes some major points and most of them are valid.
Now, it seems as though the media is trying to concentrate on how to explain that Asians, Hispanics, and Middle Easterners also live in America. How are they going to do this? Naturally I did not watch the movie Borac/Borak?; and neither do I intend to; but does there not have to come a time when the PUBLIC - and that means YOU and ME stand up and VOICE OUR OPINIONS! We must tell the media what we want to see.
I don't know about the rest of you; but when I see something on TV that I feel is racist, sexist, degrading, or in any way discriminatory, I automatically get onto the computer and write emails. I send them to the program producers, the advertizers, and the networks. A few grassroots efforts can go a long way.
Let's take the high road and make it a long way toward Human Rights and Dignity to everyone ~Donna
1 person likes this
@kodeshkodashim (925)
• United States
27 Jan 07
Thanxs for the cute wa, wa, wa, history lesson.I'm white and with a fine black woman that can do anything or go anywhere she wants in life.So ANYONE can go the the white house or anywhere else for that matter.OH forgot to mention I'm natve american too ,Get off my land.LOL.
@kodeshkodashim (925)
• United States
27 Jan 07
Oh and if your wondering why the white house is called that.....It's cuz the dam thang is painted white.DUH? Not the color of anyone's skin.Shoot White people are pink.Let's call it the pink house ...see how stupid that sounds? maybe not.
1 person likes this
@misskatonic (3723)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I was wondering when this thread would get its resident jerk.
I really wished I lived in the magical fantasy world you lived in. In a country where the KKK is allowed to burn their crosses and mail out their hate mail to anyone they like, and the Neo Nazi movement is alive and well and supported by a disturbing number of citizens, and there is still red line marketing and glass ceilings.... yeah. I can *definitely* see a black man or a woman being elected by the sexist, bigoted masses. Do me a favor and actually look around you.
Then maybe you can see beyond your seat of default privilege.
1 person likes this
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
27 Jan 07
You know kodesh, As far as my "cute" history lesson went, I told you about the POSITVE experience I had while working a white man's job! I neglected to tell you that I am 5'1" and at the time weighed in at about 98#. I neglected to tell you that the almost 2 years that I worked there I was held down and beaten several times "for taking a white man's job away from him" - as was my black brother. With me, it went a little farther. My black brother quit before is probabtionary period was up - he was too sickened by the entire scene to take any more (and there were other "man" jobs in the daylight that he could get hired at); I still needed to make enough money to feed my children that were getting no child support from their father.
Now, do you want to hear that at one time I was brutally raped by 5-7 (I lost count) of my Union Brothers, had all of my clothing taken off me except my hard hat with my lantern and my belt that contained the power cord to the lantern, the steel tag with my ID number, and my tools on it and sent back out of the mine with a big flannel shirt that one of the older men who found me wrapped around my body?
That was the most severe rape, but there were several 1:1 rapes that happened during my time there.
What are you going to say to that? Well, you may say I should have gotten out of the situation. What would you say if it had been your fine black woman and that was what she wanted to do with her life - just support her children - and not on welfare or by working two minimum wage jobs? Would you tell her to report it to her supervisor? Have you ever worked a union job? If you have, you know things like this are just not done.
Please don't wa, wa, me. I have lived it and I have Survived. You stand next to your shiny car and tell me a story that's real and now. I have supported Native American causes with as much gusto as I have African American causes.
It is not often that my heart turns cold, but frankly your post so hurts/disgusts/sickens me, that I actually feel sorry for the woman you are with.
You almost right about one thing. Even though our society will hold her down and push her back, she can at least try to do anything and go anywhere she wants to in life. My only question is, why would she choose to be with you?
This was the m
1 person likes this
@april444 (1341)
• United States
28 Jan 07
Honestly about now if a dog could run the office better than this stupid idot we have in office Id vote the dog. I just want this stupid war to stop! We need to rebuild our own land. Make sure every kid can go to college, clean up the streets and kill all the child molesters that prey on our children. Black , White , Hispanic , Asian if you can make a differnce for the comman man/woman you get the vote!
@vekyengineer (1079)
• India
28 Jan 07
color womens can also do equal jobs while comparing with normal peoples may be with some disadvatages. But peoples dont have any problems with them so according to me there is no difference.
2 people like this
@misskatonic (3723)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I've wondered that myself, quite often. I have middle class white men telling me all the time that there's equality. It's easy to claim there's equality when you're in a position of power. White male privilege does exist. It is inherent. Women suffer from inequality. Black people suffer from it. Asian, Hispanic and bi-racial people suffer from it. But the people who are at the top of the food chain don't see it.
We have come a long way, but we aren't there yet. And I don't know when we will be. How do you reshape hundreds of years of accepted social construct? How do you shift an ingrained social perception?
Here's a little story about me. When I was living in Seattle, I went through a very 'butch' phase. I have a naturally deep voice, roughened by smoking. I was practically passing as a man. And the way I was treated was far, far different than when I was feminine. I was always assumed to be a man. And men treated me like an equal, not a woman. There were no little pet names, no being careful what they said. It was a while different set of interactions.
I want to be treated as a person, not as a man or a woman.
I just don't know when that will happen, and I wish I did. I am a woman. I am treated as a woman. I am tired of it.
2 people like this
@irisheyes (4370)
• United States
28 Jan 07
Well donna, I think when a candidate is chosen, Hillary and Barak will no longer oppose each other. One will campaign hard for the other.
I personally just hope that Bill Clinton and the brilliant strategists that ran his campaign step in and help the Democratic candidate. If you recall, Al Gore was trying to distance himself from Bill and the gang when he ran (Big Mistake) and Clinton was recovering from heart surgery and wasn't used to the max by Kerry.
I really think just the fact that Hillary and Barak are considered viable candidates for the presidency means that a lot has changed. One thing that will be the same as it was for you in the mines is that this campaign will be the dirtiest of the dirty. A lot of good old boys will be crawling from under the rocks.
1 person likes this
@kathy77 (7486)
• Australia
27 Jan 07
Oh my goodness this is dreadful in regards to prejudice in America, I know that they used to be bad and I just do not understand America still holding onto this and maybe they do not understand themselves I mean the white people do you know something and that is this that they called the African American people coloured people but who really is the coloured people it is the white people if you can't work it out or know the answer message me and I will explain this to you as when I was told this how right it is, I am a married white woman married to a man who is a dark brown colour, and I do have 5 beautiful dark children.
2 people like this
@kitchenwitchoftupper (2290)
• United States
29 Jan 07
Who, exactly did you not get Ashu? I will try to be more specific. ~Donna
1 person likes this
@Capsicum (1444)
• United States
27 Jan 07
I don't think its fair to say that things have not changed ! A coal miner and a president are two very different things to compare . I think that bringing something of this nature up is asking for problems . Maybe you have not changed though people in general have . A good person for a job,friend,coworker or president makes no difference in what color you are at least this is what, I was taught growing up . What causes the problems is people making it a racial matter when its not.
I have never seen a obese president is that discrimination ? Your life is what you make of it nothing more ,nothing less makes no difference who you are.
@kennisha4eva (84)
• United States
27 Jan 07
probably not and i think that it is unfair for the government to emphasaize so much that all people are equal but then not treat them equal there has never been a black president and there probably wont be one during my lifetime
1 person likes this
@sunshinelady (7609)
• United States
24 Feb 07
When a remark like that is made it shows a persons ignorance and I have replied myself to people who make that comment to the effect that it isn't the color of a persons skin or their gender that should be considered in who we put in as president. But whether or not that person has the ability to handle being the president. But sad to say that in this country things are not so very different from years ago. The only difference is it is hidden differently.