I have a question that is bothering me

United States
January 31, 2007 11:24pm CST
So why does EVERYONE keep saying that it isn't a good idea to breed animals (dogs, guinea pigs, cats, you name it ANIMALS). What if the person really wants to? What if to them it's NOT a bad idea, but they came on here asking advice, is it wrong to put them down for asking for it? Is it wrong to want to breed the animals you already have? I don't think so. I do also understand that there are TONS and TONS of animals out there that need good homes, but what if you don't trust the animals that are out there (for instance, they may be too old or have diseases or risks) and someone like me isn't up for any of that. Now before anyone gets all bent out of shape over this, I want you to know that I have 2 Doberman's, 4 cats (3 female and 1 male and they are all fixed), and currently have 6 guinea pigs (Yesterday I witnessed a miracle of life and it was so amazing, that I think it would be great to see more guinea pigs that are babies. My guinea pig when I bought her was supposed to be male and she turned out to be female and she had 3 babies, 1 passed on, but I still have the other 2. And I'm telling you, if my girl is up for it a little while later, you better believe that I will mix her in with my other 3 males and go from there.) Please don't be angry, I have my opinion, but I want others.
1 person likes this
21 responses
• United States
1 Feb 07
Why isn't it a good idea? Go to your local animal control and take a look around. Maybe then you'll get the idea. The average animal control keeps dogs for less than a week before euthanizing. Not every dog is lucky enough to go to the Humane Society, you know. It is estimated that 40% of the dogs that end up in shelters are purebred. Those were dogs somebody bred because they "just wanted to."
2 people like this
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
1 Feb 07
Honestly, I don't think it is a good idea for people to breed animals unless they can afford it, have a place to keep the animals, and there is a market to give away or sell what they breed. We have a house full of animals and the only ones that we may breed are our blue masked lovebirds, but that is 6 months off. I don't see anything wrong with doing that, but I don't want to breed them and then have to stop them from breeding because we can't afford it or there is no market/no one to give them to, that would just be cruel. I don't believe breeders should be put down because they want to breed their animals. I do believe that many people who think it is a good idea to breed, don't put enough thought into the entire process and then the animals suffer.
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Feb 07
I totally agree with what you have said. But there are TONS of people here on mylot saying DON'T DO IT! And that seriously makes me angry that they would state something like that. The person who is asking advice is getting it for the purpose of breeding, not trying to get the "don't do it" comment. I'm one of the biggest animal lovers around and if there isn't a market for guinea pigs (in my case) then I would keep them and raise them normally. My 2 new babies came as a shock yesterday, but they are so cute and loving that I would love to have some more. But again, it's my opinion. Thanks for commenting.
1 person likes this
• Italy
1 Feb 07
what is the really problem?
@tammyr (5946)
• Etowah, Tennessee
1 Feb 07
I agree that back yard breeding is not a good idea. By this I mean letting your inheat female run lose and just see what happens. I do not think that breeding registered, full blooded, good tempered, heathly pets is awful if it is well thought out and there is a market for the pups,kittens what ever. I also do not see a problem with breeding g. pigs to see the miricle of birth, if you plan to keep or give out the babies. These pets are often neglegted and end up unwanted as they require lots of cleaning, care and attention that most will not give. i believe each case should be thought about for a long minite and research the cost involed as well as weathere there is a market for the offspring. Mutts are usually the most common boarder at the shelters and all though some full blooded animals may end up there they are usually the first to get adopted( from my experience.) I have a doxie that we breed last year. She developed a false pregnancy, had everything but the pups. She went through it well , in fact better than we did! And will try again when she comes back in season. I have had about 6 people say they want one of her pups. I will have no trouble selling them, I even decided to raise the asking price because so many people wanted one of them. I am not doing it for the $$ (allthough that is nice too!) I was given the dog froma friend when the other sister they kept was run over, and passed. I am doing it to GIVE her a pup from the same blood line. The owner of the sire will also be GIVEN one of the pups and I will keep one. Any left will then be sold,If I can bear to part with one, and she even has more than or even three. I hope you have reserch g. pigs and there breeding habits. As I know a girl who started with one "male" as you did and now has cages all over her home on every horizontal serface each filled with what she hopes(!) is separated into male or female hamsters she has not counted but has about 75-100 !!! So please do be careful, so as not to get overwelmed!
1 person likes this
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
2 Feb 07
Hey Craftyqueen, I have been to the local SPCA, they are always over crowded. Our SPCA does not put healthy animals down. Unfortunately, they have to house animals outdoors, there are just too many of them. I can not see the point of people breeding more animals when there are so many that need homes, you may keep your guinea pigs, but what about your 6 puppies or 8 kittens, Also, many people breed animals and don't know what they are doing, it is not somethiing that can be learned from the internet. It takes experience and those same people expect to make money- they want home remedies for worms, they don't account for medical or the possible c-section, and unless your dogs are truely extra ordinary, they should not be breeding, bad breeding lead to medical problems and many pups are put down due to bad breeding.
1 person likes this
@willocfc (963)
• Australia
1 Feb 07
The problem is people are breeding animals just to try and make money, a dog has a litter and the owners get greedy and force the animals to have litter after litter for thier own greed and its not healthy for the animals. Another problem is that people think animals are cute when they are babies but forget that they grow up too, and thats where the problem of unwanted animals starts, if you want a dog go to a pound and adopt a dog that could really use a home
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Feb 07
How do you know you're going to be able to find good homes for all those baby animals? I think it's wrong to bring a baby into the world (human or animal) without knowing that you are going to be able to provide for it.
1 person likes this
• Canada
16 Feb 07
If it's a professional breeder that's a different story. What people are against are operations like puppy mills where the animals are left in bad conditions and not cared for, just for the sole purpose of creating more animals. Also, people need to get their own pets spayed an neutered to prevent babies that no one will be able to care for. Again, if it's a professional breeder that is a different story, if not, that's a problem.
• Philippines
2 Feb 07
That is life for animals...but we humans have different features unlike to animals...remember that we are above of them.....
@Calais (10893)
• Australia
1 Feb 07
I agree with you, It seems to be the automatic answer. If people want to breed than that is up to them, everyone understands that there is millions of animals in shelters. To breed though I think you have to go about it the right way for dogs and cats, become registered not a backyard breeder or puppy miller. research is the number one factor to become a breeder and asking questions is part of that, people should not be abused for asking. All good breeders had to start out somewhere. If no one becomes a breeder, how long will it be until the purebreeds die out. People have a choice and its up to them entirely, purebreed or mutt. Myself I have 2 purebreed dogs (Doberman and Australian Kelpie) and two purebreed cats (Russian Blue). But yes in the past all I owned were mixed breeds and mutts. I would only get a purebreed for now on and thats my choice. Yes I have sympathy for the ones in shelters, I have worked there but everyone has a choice and thats mine.
• United States
1 Feb 07
You know, everyone is probably really mad at my opinion and thought process, but here's my BIG problem, I WOULD ADOPT ALL THE ANIMALS IN THE SHELTERS AND THE HUMANE SOCIETIES! I wouldn't be able to help myself. Therefore I STAY AWAY! I can't handle that many animals in my home. I have what feels like a ton already, but I love each and everyone dearly. All of them are my children! PERIOD! Now if I'm looked at wrong because of this, so be it!
• United States
2 Feb 07
I'm not mad, I'm sad that you aren't seeing the real point in why so many of us are against backyard breeders. You say you would adopt all the animals if you could - but instead you turn around and add to the problem by making more animals. Let's say someone breeds their two dogs and have a little of 7 puppies. Those 7 puppies need a home, don't they? Those homes that are taking those 7 puppies COULD HAVE instead adopted 7 puppies that are instead going to be killed in a shelter because they do not have homes. I'm not sure how much clearer I can be in my replies to you so I'm going to back away from this discussion because all it does is make me sad that some people just don't "get it" and then turn around and claim to be animal lovers. Sure. Have a great day.
@kapoet (270)
• Indonesia
2 Feb 07
Oh.. that's is okay for me. You can keep your animal. Take care always and that's not a bad things. For me... Because I love dogs too...
• United States
2 Feb 07
I have nothing against breeding or buying from a breeder, because I understand that sometimes you find a particular type of animal that you like. I, however, highly encourage people to look at shelters and such first. But I think people are a little overboard condemning people for breeding.
@mbarryton (1872)
• United States
2 Feb 07
i say if you wanna breed there is nothing wrong with it
• United States
2 Feb 07
Thank you! You should see my two new bundles of joy! They are beautiful!
@lyndaj70 (293)
• United States
2 Feb 07
I have bred animals in the past, in fact sold the registered puppies to make the needed money to leave my husband. There's a lot more to it than the average person thinks, which I ended up learning the hard way, and as a result I don't know if I ever want the responsibility of bringing another animal in the world personally. ************ From a financial standpoint, if the animals aren't registered, there isn't really any money in it. If they are, there is your money involved in the expenses required to get them to saleable age. ************* Everyone has to make their own choices, and if you feel that you can make sure those animals will all have good homes and you can shoulder the expense and effort, then by all means go for it. Please don't take that for sarcasm because it's not. I'm not here to judge. I just know from experience that there is a lot of effort involved (especially if something goes wrong) and am in hopes that one counts the possible cost before jumping. Just my two cents. Good luck with everything!
• United States
2 Feb 07
No sarcasm taken! It's a good point. Thank you!
• India
1 Feb 07
although the no of people against it is high, i strongly feel that, there is nothing wrong in that....absolutely nothing!
• United States
2 Feb 07
Thank you! I'm so glad that someone sees my view. What some people don't understand is that I just had one of my animals give birth and one was seriously struggling for his life yesterday because his mom rejected him. She refused to allow him to nurse and so I stepped in and fed him warm 2% milk out of my fridge and this little guy was kicking with life this morning and he's still growing strong. So as for thinking that everyone who breeds isn't concerned with the mom's health as well as the babies, I'm not the type. I was hysterical when I thought I would lose this baby. But I haven't. Thank Goodness!
@Pmcbride (1081)
2 Feb 07
I know a lot of people who breed animals, mainly dogs but some otherkinds too. I don't have a problem with it as long as the breeder has the money and the time to take care of the animals, there are well enough stray animals in this world at the moment, but if the owner will take care of the bred animals i really don't see a problem with it, in fact it is quite nice to see someone who has the drive and conviction to make a choice about a particular breed or type of animal and wish to have more as long as the animals are taken care of then the best of luck to you and i hope you do well.
• India
1 Feb 07
I dont think any difference in breeding animals. I am not so attracted to animals and breeding is common for all human beings. So why should there be some fullstops to the animals let them also have that opportunity in their life.
• United States
1 Feb 07
As long as you know what you are doing, and can afford to breed the animals, then do it. This can be a profitable business, as long as you know the risks, and have the money for it. But if you are just breeding the animals, just to have more pets around, then I would advise against it.
• India
1 Feb 07
i dont think there i sanything bad in breeding them...rest dont have much knowledge...better consult an animal doctor
@Rittings (673)
1 Feb 07
All animals have a right to life. I love my dogs, and would love to breed rough collies and become a specialist collie breeder. It's my dream job, but I would only do it if I had the money in the first place to build good clean facilities. Nothing is harder to take than seeing dogs being kept in poor conditions...
@taramoon (740)
• Spain
1 Feb 07
I have 3 dogs ans 4 cats, they are all adopted from our local animal shelters, i believe that, people are better off donating money for these charities and help give the poor little souls a warm and loving home,i am not against breeders as long as they are fully registed and animal protection societies keep regular checks on the breeders, there are so many horror stories out there.