Separate Wicket keepers for One days and Test matches
@Sami_beau_ideal (158)
India
February 2, 2007 4:39am CST
Why not have separate wicket keepers for both forms of cricket ie
Dhoni as keeper in one dayers for his explosive bating
Karthick the keeper in tests for his better temprament.
What are your views on this arrangement? I am sure it would work in favour of the whole team.
1 person likes this
9 responses
@jaizdeep (397)
• India
4 Feb 07
Yeah i think we need specialists in every position whether it be an opening batsman or a spinner or a pace bowler,whether ut may be a middle order batsman or a wicket keeper
Introduction of DInesh karthik has been really good...I think heis the appropraite man for TEst matches while MAhendra singh dhoni is a master when it comes to the shorter version of the game
@swinder0161 (26)
• India
14 Mar 07
u mean that a regular batsman should be replaced for kartik or dhoni... we should have a keeper and a regular batsman... we cant rely on wc to fulfil the role of a batsman........ what do u say??????????
@Sami_beau_ideal (158)
• India
2 Feb 07
Finally someone for karthick, I thought this people had dhoni supporters only. Good to see ya.
@ravinderreddy (390)
• India
2 Feb 07
yes i think dhoni for one day cric and karthic for test cric..
@swinder0161 (26)
• India
14 Mar 07
ofcourse kartik for test and dhoni for odis....
no complicatipns in dis.. they both have been tested in both forms of the game and tey both proved themselves in the two formats of play.............
@arijitdreams (401)
• India
3 Feb 07
thats a grt idea....dhoni and kartik for the odi and tests respectively
@rajcools (18)
• India
14 Mar 07
karthick is a good batsman so may be he will work fine in tests...but dont underestimate dhoni's temperament he can play both ways aggressive and defensive so maybe its a 50 50 chance.... both can work in both forms of game.... the person that benefits from this is indian cricket team as it now has 2 quality keepers
