Santa Clause Right or Wrong

United States
February 4, 2007 7:29pm CST
You know at Christmas time my boss had a situation happen that got me to thinking whether Santa Clause should even come about. Let me tell you what happened and let me know what you think. My bosses daughter was very upset with her this year because she found out that there is no Santa Clause, ( I don't believe in a physical Santa but in the heart is where the concept of Santa is) But the whole reason Christmas came about was because of Christ coming into this world. Part of the word Christmas contains the word Christ. Anyway I don't believe that children should be fed the line about Santa. You better be good because Santa is watching you. My bosses daughter did not find out this from her mom but by kids at school. Now she feels very strongly that her mom lied to her. If you do the Santa, Easter Bunny thing when should you tell your child that there is none. My bosses daughter told her that she had been lied to all these years. She cried in the shower for a very long time. My boss was heartbroken. What do you all think?
1 person likes this
3 responses
• United States
5 Feb 07
Thats a toughy. I'm only a teenager so I can't give you the same advice as an adult would, but I can give you my point of view. Christmas time in a church is totally different from Christmas time at home. Church and Santa aren't related. End of story there. That's why I think it's ok for Santa to be "alive." Yes, it should be taught that Christmas is the day Jesus was born, and that is the real celebration. Santa is just another part, the festive part if you will. We all know Santa isn't physically real, but he makes your spirit happy during the holidays. Imagine Christmas without him. No dads' dressing up in costumes to suprise their kids, no cookies and milk for santa, no stockings from santa. It would be quite a bit dreary without him. And in a way, i think the fact that santa is "watching the kids" can be a good thing if used properly. some children (mostly younger, im sure) will want to be a good child so that santa will come and give them presents and not coal. I learned Santa wasn't real on my own. I was probably around 8 or 9 years old. Santa (my dad) came in and i saw the plastic eyebrows attached to the glasses. I wasn't disappointed because i was old enough to be mature about the situation. I really think parents have to wait longer than expected to tell their children that santa isnt real, and that they wanted their children to appreciate the spirit of santa. It can be a real shock to them when they're younger because santa is could almost seem like a hero to them. Some children, like your bosses daughter will take is harshly, that can't be helped. but i think santa should stay in our society.
• United States
5 Feb 07
Don't ever say you are just a teenager. You have some very sound and logical points to be taken. I like what you said and how you said it. You knew what you wanted to say and you knew how to put it in words on here. Thank you for your input and it had me sit up and take notice. What you said is very true. It would be a drab place without the man with the red suit and white beard. The only thing I am still not sure of is whether Santa should be used to control Children's behavior. You are a young women with a good head on her shoulder. Thank you for making a valid point.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Feb 07
Well thank you very much for that. I appreciate it. I think it is a risky thing to use Santa as a way to control a child's behavior. Each child is different, and I think it is up to the parents to figure out how to "use" Santa. it should be known that he watches if a child is good or bad, but it shouldn't be pressed upon as a way to control behavior. I think children are more independent than we realize, and they will take the ways of Santa how they want. When i was younger, i knew Santa watched us to make sure we were doing good, but it never scared me or made me change my actions.
2 people like this
• United States
5 Feb 07
Once again you have raised a valid point. The only thing I still adhere to is Santa should never be used to hold over a child's head to keep them in line. I have known some parents that right after Christmas they start with this you better be good or Santa won't bring you anything. Come on give it a break. I see you are a thinking young lady and knows how to bring her point across.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Feb 07
My mom her paster didn't teach his childern of santa he says that he tell them that this man is real he is there you just don't see him than when they find out they are hurt you try to tell them of christ he is there you just don't see him so they think you are lieing again to them he didn't tell any of his three that he was real I guess it's just up to the family I toldmy boy's there was but they also knew what it was for I told them when they were old enough that it was for kids that didn't have anyone so that way they could belive in something....
2 people like this
• United States
6 Feb 07
I don't think Santa should be taken out of the holiday. I think that parents should approach it in such a way that they do find out that they are not let down like my bosses daughter was. There has to be a good halfway place so that kids hearts are not broken.
• Canada
6 Feb 07
We tell our kids that there is a Santa, but we don't use it as a threat. Santa is a part of our culture, and I don't want my kids to be the odd ones out whos parents tell them its all a fake. When they start to ask, we will tell them the truth.... that Santa was a real person (St Nick) and that he really did give gifts to children ... and we all 'play the part' at Christmas time for fun.
• United States
6 Feb 07
That is what I like to hear. I believe in Santa as far as part of the holiday because he has been in the culture for quite some time. Yes, Santa was a real person and the giving of gifts started with him. It is a nice tradition and I am not against that. Just the holding of Santa over kids heads. Glad to hear that you don't do that. That is the only thing that I am against. Thanks for your response.