Why do textbooks cost so much more than regular books?
@hockeygal4ever (10021)
United States
February 6, 2007 12:36pm CST
My oldest daughter started some college classes and we had to buy books. I remember it being the same way when I was in college, the textbooks were a huge hunk of your expenses. What I can't figure out is WHY they are so costly. Now I'm talking, average sized books, actually these were small ones. Paperback, slightly larger than a paperback novel, nothing special. IF it were a reading book it would be going for $10 tops and even that would be a bit expensive. These books cost upwards of $55!!!!!! That's crazy!
What possible rationalization could they have for making similar books at literally 5x or more in price? Talk about price gouging! I'm certain it's based simply upon the fact that as a student you HAVE to have the book to participate in college so it's not like you're going to walk away without buying it. I think it's horrible though!
8 responses
@cjthedog64 (1552)
• United States
6 Feb 07
I agree that they cost so much because students have to have them. It is a factor though with the number of contributors and research that goes into a textbook. My biggest problem was when they'd change a couple of pictures or something silly and print a new edition. I had one book in college that by the time I graduated, they were on the 6th edition. I was using the 2nd, and it was virtually identical.
1 person likes this
@hockeygal4ever (10021)
• United States
6 Feb 07
OMG.. we just went through that. I found "used" versions of her philosophy books on the net... these books were at the college book store and online new for around $55 each. I found them used for under $5. So I ordered them, all excited that for once in my life I beat them at their own game. Wrong. They beat me again. She took them to class and the first words from the teacher were "and we can only use the latest editions, edition 4 of this book and 5 of this one". Nicole looked down.... we had edition 3 & 4. I KNOW there cannot be a huge difference.. but what can you do? So we ended up paying full price. I was livid! lol
@KrisNY (7590)
• United States
6 Feb 07
College books usually involve more than 1 person working with them to complete them. It takes several people to get the information, proof the information, finalize the information. These books are used to teach- so they have to be up to date and accurate. A paperback is nothing even close to a college book- They don't have to be scientific.
I do feel you though- Books are outrageous for classes.. Try checking online for them- You can pick them up alot cheaper than in the college bookstores. they mark them up too.
Yes kids need the books to be in the classes so they do price gouge. But think of all the people who get a chunk of profit.
@hockeygal4ever (10021)
• United States
6 Feb 07
In some cases it's true that there is more work put into them but think about it... I know for a fact that text books for regular schools are not as pricey. I've purchased them new and used so I can compare the pricing to what I've spent for her college books. And in many cases, like the books we recently purchased, they are truly not that "intricate" in detail. One is an English book that is basically the same as a novel. I wouldn't feel so ripped off if it was truly an intricate and well thought out book of information. But wow, these ones are literally so small and nothing too intriguing! lol
I guess I understand if they're truly filled with tons of information and such but I'm just really feeling like they're gouging the students because they can!
1 person likes this
@KrazyKlingon (5005)
• United States
19 Feb 07
First, authors of these textbooks do not get any more compensation for book sales than do authors of novels or biographies or autobiographies. The actual price gougers are the publishing companies.
I have had a hand in helping a few professors with writing textbooks, so I know what i'm talking about. However, with the prices that they charge, professors & teachers should be better compensated, being that it requires not just being able to clearly explain something in written text, & requires expertise in what the textbook is for.
A pair of former professors who had their book republished had their book sold at the college book store for $76. I helped revise a textbook after the previous company who stopped printing the book. When it came out using a new publisher, the book costed $76.00! (Pre-y2K prices) Despite the insistence of the two authors at having it published as a soft cover (or 'paperback, as you put it) the publisher published it as a hard cover. The previous publisher had it published as a soft cover for $53.00.
Another professor got the book together, but in the end, after realizing that he was not getting any more than an author would get for a novel, & at the ridiculous prices, he decided not to publish the book at all. Instead, he had the university package it at $9.00 at the college bookstore, exclusively for university students taking the course that would use the book. That $9 only was to cover for the materials (mainly the paper) for the university print shop.
Another pair of professors who had a book published decided that being that books sold at the college means that they don't get anything for students attending the college they work at means no compensation at all for books sold at that college bookstore, instead of making students in their classes pay those high textbook prices, they just had it mass-printed at the college print shop & just gave it to the students in their classes.
Not only is the publisher getting a lot of money per book, so are the local & state governments on the sales tax for these books. Anyway, if possible, used textbooks are approximately 67% to 75% cheaper than a brand new book. Plus, sometimes, the student who sold the book back (& got approximately 25% to 33% of the price that they paid for the book - brand new) occasionally leaves helpful notes in them. So to beat the greedy publishers, see if the textbooks that are needed is available used.
1 person likes this
@hockeygal4ever (10021)
• United States
6 Feb 07
Not true... a lot of them are simple text books, not a lot of scientific work in them. One in particular is an english book. I can understand if they're loaded with tons of stuff, but I'm talking very small sized and nothing too intricate! I'm sorry, but there's not nearly enough in them to warrant those types of prices. To be honest I would venture to guess that a typical author puts as much work as any text book writer would if they're a good writer, investigating things and learning about the basis of what they are writing about.
I still can't see the justification.
@shywolf (4514)
• United States
6 Feb 07
You're right that, from what I've heard from you and others, that the price of textbooks is ridiculously high. I think that the best thing you can do to cut costs on things like that is to find someone who has the books from the year before and see if you can get the used books from them at a cut rate. I think that I've had friends who have talked about doing something like that.
It is sad that they can inflate the prices of textbooks *so* much simply because a student cannot do without them :/
@sweetie88 (4556)
• Pakistan
19 Feb 07
I am unable to understand the difference between textbooks and regular books. I live in Pakistan and in Pakistan, we say textbooks to "books which r included in our school/college courses" but i think that they r opposite in urs case. I concluded from answers of urs question that regular books r course books of schools/colleges. Textbook r more expensive bcuz they r made by a lot of hard work of many people and seldom people buy them but on the other hand, everyone reads regular books and buy them but i studied Oxford Syllabus in my school and live in Pakistan and my books were very muchhhhhhh expensive.