why should we or should we not keep simon on blabbing?

Without simon, I wouldn't even be watching American Idol. It'd be full of phonies.

I firmly believe that for as long as the three can be together, we should keep it that way. As the saying goes..."if it aint broken, don't fix it" the three exemplifies chemistry and perfect harmony that is why the show is a phenomenal success. Keep Simon and we keep the show on a consistent success.

We should keep Simon babbling...he's what makes the show so much fun to watch in my opinion! He can be really harsh with his words and sometimes I think that he can tone it down a bit, but for the most part he is so accurate in what he is saying and totally blunt about it too, hehe.

I like Simon and to tell the truth, I think i wouldn't be watching American Idol if he wasn't one of the judges - he makes it worth watching - yes he can be rude but he's straight up and honest - you need someone hard like him on the show.