Who do you think is a better QB McNabb or Garcia?

United States
February 12, 2007 2:21pm CST
I know this may sound silly to some but, Garcia did a really good job. In some ways he played better then McNabb. Please be real. Who is the better QB?
2 people like this
5 responses
66jerseygirl
@66jerseygirl (3877)
• United States
13 Feb 07
Garcia definately!The Eagles were really sucking til McNabb hurt himself and they had to put Garcia in.I'm not very happy that McNabb's starting again next season.
2 people like this
kgwat70
@kgwat70 (13387)
• United States
3 Apr 07
I would have to disagree with you my dear friend as I still think McNabb is the better quarterback. Garcia had a good run but will not be able to keep it up in Tampa. McNabb is stronger and has a better arm and can run better. I do not like his choices sometimes but overall I think he is better than Garcia and will be back to form.
Peaches1122
@Peaches1122 (470)
• United States
12 Feb 07
McNabb is the better QB at this point. He is the better leader and athlete. Had he finished out the season at the same pace he started he would have made the Pro-Bowl.
1 person likes this
Kate06
@Kate06 (123)
• United States
12 Feb 07
I thought that Garcia did a great job for the Eagles when he had to step in for McNabb. It bothered me that all the media attention focused on what would become of Garcia next season and where he would be drafted. I thought he was playing good enoughthat perhaps the talk should have focused on where will McNabb be next season. They are both good quarterbacks just with different styles of play.
1 person likes this
HollywoodCole
@HollywoodCole (17)
• Saint Kitts And Nevis
13 Feb 07
In theory, this is a good question, but honestly...it's really not even a consideration. Garcia did excellent, but McNabb is in his prime. Garcia is at the tail end of his career. He probably would have called it quits if he didn't have the great streak with Philly. Garcia only did so well because Philly has the best pass blocking O-Line in the NFL. McNabb just does so much more, because he's able to stretch the field so much more to open the middle up for the underneath passes to L.J. Smith or Westbrook coming out of the backfield. I would love to see Garcia as the backup role in Philly once again, but I would not pay big bucks for him, though.
leese29
@leese29 (340)
• United States
23 Feb 07
I agree wiht you completely. Garcia did good but Mcnabb is still the better QB. Although if Garcia had taken them to the Superbowl and won, it would have been a whole different story. Then I think the answer may be different.
karendrum
@karendrum (1)
•
23 Apr 07
I feel like McNabb will never be able to make a full recovery and play at the same level he has in the past.