The Judges
By snorton36
@snorton36 (19)
United States
February 14, 2007 10:47am CST
I would like to know everybody's opinion on the judges. I truly believe it is time for American idol to make a change. I am not sure what is wrong with Paula Abdul but she cannot judge. Randy has absolutely no backbone. As for Simon - well I like Simon. He is honest and straight foward. Can be very insulting most times and he does need to tone it down a bit but I think we need two new judges. Anyone have an opinion on this?
4 responses
@howard96h (11640)
• New York, New York
14 Feb 07
Very true. Paula appears to be out in left field. She's not with it. She's just there physically. I just read on mylot a few minutes ago that Michael Jackson will be appearing as a guest judge. Did you hear of this? What do you think?
@snorton36 (19)
• United States
15 Feb 07
No I have not heard that he would be on the show. That would be great because I miss seeing Michael Jackson in action. He truly has and I still believe has amazing talent pity he has a problem!
@Jshean20 (14348)
• Canada
16 Feb 07
Well I have to agree with you about liking Simon, that guy makes me laugh and he always seems to say (in different words) exactly what I'm thinking. He's very blunt and I will admit that he can go too far with his comments sometimes. Did you see during the audition tapes this year where he called that kid a bush baby and basically told him that he was funny looking and couldn't sing...I felt a bit bad for him. As for Randy and Paula, I'd be sad to see Paula go but not Randy.
@winds_jenn (40)
• United States
14 Feb 07
Paula seems like she is too high sometimes
Randy trys to make to many people happy
Simon I Love him. Very judgemental but truthful
@suebear (14)
• United States
15 Feb 07
I think Simon will always be Simon and everyone appreciates that well all most everyone. As for Randy he has gotten a little crude this season and its out of character for him and i think alot of viewers will loose respect for him for it. And Paula its time for a new judge she is on something or just is way to happy for most of the world and mostly what comes out of her mouth doesnt make sense or she repeats herself with every person who auditions.
