Harry's dad led Snape to join Voldemort
By MntlWard
@MntlWard (878)
United States
February 15, 2007 11:11pm CST
Apparently Harry's dad was a jerk and a bully, to Snape at least. If it came time to choose sides, and I had to go with the guy who was always giving me a hard time and the dark wizard who hadn't yet done me any harm, I might be tempted to side with Tom Riddle, myself.
Of course, this is all based on what we know *now,* and things may be revealed about Harry's dad that put the history in a new light.
2 responses
@cajundharma (641)
• United States
16 Feb 07
I think it was important for Harry to realize that his father was not perfect. That he was human, including being an arrogant punk as a teenager. The world isn't always black and white, and it can be hard to tell the good guys from the bad guys. I feel Harry really has to learn this before he can wage war against Voldemort and decide who to trust and who to ally with. He needed to understand that even the deatheaters were human, and had feelings and motivations like everyone else. It was obvious that Dumbledore, while loathing the things Tom Riddle did, had compassion for the young boy that was shaped largely by circumstances into the adult he became. I think that Harry needs to learn to have that same compassion, and perhaps learn from his father's example and not let his considerable talents make him arrogant or unkind.
1 person likes this
@joy358 (491)
• Philippines
23 Feb 07
I don't think so. Nobody should be held accountable for our actions but ourselves, so we can't blame James for how Snape turned out. If a person is inherently good then no matter the provocation he will stay good. In Snape's case I think that even without Jame's bullying he would have ventured eventually into the dark path because he has long been fascinated and obsessed by the dark arts. I think that like Voldemort, Snape was seduced to the dark side by his desire for power not because he was bullied by James Potter.
@MntlWard (878)
• United States
24 Feb 07
I may end up proven wrong, but I would think any person would have trouble allying himself with someone who's done nothing but hurt him. Even if James' actions weren't the only reason Snape ended up following Voldemort, I believe they very strongly influenced Snape's decisions in life.