why do people ask questions that they dont want an answer to?

@hahzen63 (157)
Philippines
February 16, 2007 4:37am CST
a friend of mine way back asked me if she was gaining some weight. since she was a friend, and she knew i usually dont lie to her, i answered, yes, she had indeed gained some pounds and it was probably about time she did something about it. i thought i had answered her question, but upon seeing her eyes were kinda teary, i said sorry and told her that she was not that fat, she just gained some few pounds... now, am just wondering, if she did not want me to tell her she was getting fat, why ask the question in the first place? you? do you have your own share of questions that were asked that those who asked would much rather have unanswered? or are you the ones asking the question? hehe
1 person likes this
4 responses
16 Feb 07
I think they are looking for assurance from you. I do that too! I will wear something nice and ask my Mum and her silence speaks volumes "you don't like it fine" tearfully I will take it off and try again. Yes the truth hurts but if you lie to her than that is pain ful too.
@hahzen63 (157)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
hmmmm probably my friend does...but believe me, we must first be confident of who we are... :) thanks for the response!
@sonnet (164)
• South Korea
16 Feb 07
People ask these questions when they have a little insecurity they want resolved. They don't want to know if they are fat. They want reassurance that they are not fat. When people feel down, they seek positive reinforcement from friends. It's kind of tricky when you are the friend, especially if you are an honest person. Sometimes a good way to answer if you don't want to lie is to find a positive slant - such as telling a girlfriend you think she looks more womanly and suggest a new top to complement her shapely bosom. Maybe I'm being a little silly here, but it is possible to find a fun light-hearted comment in these situations, depending on the friend where you can provide reassurance without resorting to a lie.
1 person likes this
@hahzen63 (157)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
hmmmm...positive reinforcement really is tricky...but i've tried that before and my friend spat on me saying i was a liar...hehe...probably it just depends on the person. thanks for the response. :)
@Agimat (355)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
Tricky situation there. What I usually do when I'm asked that question is say "No, you don't look like you gained weight .. Why? Do you feel like you have?" That usually works best for me.
@hahzen63 (157)
• Philippines
17 Feb 07
nice one there my friend! :) i'd probably try that the next time around...hehe...probably it would work with me too. :)
@comptech (53)
• Australia
16 Feb 07
Well people asking questions like these expect good answers or opposite answers so they can feel better but sometimes it doesnt work and becomes the opposite like in your case.