Which American Idol Judge is the most Honest.

Barbados
February 17, 2007 6:39pm CST
Everyone says it is Simon but I beg to differ. Simon tells you like it is and sometimes he does it in an offensive way. He is good yea but paula loves everyone including the bad singers. Her heart is too soft and cannot judge fairly. Randy swings with the mood but in all honesty, I think he is the best Judge. I prefer Simon and I really like to see him on the show. I look forward to the show every week and the one off Judges that come and go, they are Ok but not as good as Simon. What do you say.
1 person likes this
4 responses
ibusann
@ibusann (36)
•
18 Feb 07
That's right Simon Cowell does own the show, same as he does here in Britain. He also owns (or is a very big shareholder in) the X-factor, which I actually prefer to Pop Idol, because I like Sharon Osbourne, who is one of the judges.
insanegoob
@insanegoob (72)
• India
18 Feb 07
Well in a recent intervies Paula admitted that it was Simon's show you know...and honestly that is true....Inspite of Simon being so rude and everything he is correct most of the time and he does his job the best and all the participants look to impress him more than the other judges...
lilaclady
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
18 Feb 07
Judging music is an area where it is one persons opinion only, as many times the jusdges have been proven wrong and sometimes they judge an artist in areas where the buying public would not, so its not a case of being honest I think they should have judges that can offer their opinions with out destroying a persons dreams as some of them do, the buying public all have their opinions and buy accordingly....
ibusann
@ibusann (36)
•
18 Feb 07
I don't know the American judges, as I've only seen the British version. I like Simon Cowell and know he can be brutal, but it's always with good reason. If he likes you he will say so and he will also say, even if they've not had an absolutely brilliant audition, that they have potential and allow them a chance.