When to start kids on Harry Potter
By kesfylstra
@kesfylstra (1868)
United States
February 20, 2007 8:03am CST
I was having this discussion with a friend who has a six year old who is starting to express an interest in reading/having read to her the Harry Potter series, but her parents tell her she is too young yet, which I agree. When do you think is a good age to introduce the series?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
20 Feb 07
My son who is 8 has a love for Harry Potter as well. He isn't much into reading the books, but he has seen all of the movies. He was started very young on the series. In my opinion this book series is like any other where the characters mature. It is up to the parent to decide what books in the series are age apropriate. Personally, I don't see anything wrong with reading the first book or two to a child that young. I don't recall it being much worse than other books geared for children that young - "Lady in the Water", "Polar Express".
2 people like this
@kesfylstra (1868)
• United States
20 Feb 07
Very true, I've heard those are both pretty intense too.
@nil_secl (33)
• India
20 Feb 07
Children of mine has started at the age of 8.From the very begining they got involved in it to such extent that they tried to associate themselves with the series in such a manner that on getting the news of the end of the series,one of them started writing of herself to extend the series, as if Rowling has exhausted her imagination, let me lend her the ideas, how the series may go further.
Childish, may be but,they are in the world of their imagination, and i do not disturb or poke my nose.
Recently, they again depressed a lot, seeing Radcliff in the naked posture, in some of the British drama.Even she tried to cover with suitable attire to cover the boy.
1 person likes this
@kesfylstra (1868)
• United States
20 Feb 07
Hmm, I missed that. It is unfortunate. Guess he wants to grow up faster than Harry.
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
20 Feb 07
Radcliff if MUCH older than HArry is in the stories. He wanted to expand how he is known as an actor. I think he did the right thing for himself and his career by participating in that production and taking the photos. If you search CNN or another news stie, I am sure you will find the photos. They were major news for a day or two.
1 person likes this
@missyd79 (3438)
• United States
26 Feb 07
well my son is 5 and has seen all the movies of Harry potter so far. if she wants them read to her i do not see the problem, it will help with her vocublary and her reading skills also and with them reading together if she has any questions she can ask them right away and her parents can also explain alot more to her about what is going on and that harry potter is a fictional book and it make believe, ect.
1 person likes this
@imsilver (1665)
• Canada
20 Feb 07
how discouraging! If a child has the ability to read and comprehend the language of a book they should be able to read it. Harry Potter is a great kids book. A friend of mine's son is really bright and was reading them at 6. I own all of them (and am impatiently waiting the next one). My son is 9 and has picked up the first one and looked at it. I can't wait until he actually sits down to read it.
1 person likes this
@smartie1685 (450)
• United States
21 Feb 07
I really don't think that the first few books would be inappropriate for any age. Although I really wouldn't recommend anyone over probably 5 or 6 reading above the 3rd book because then it might get too scary for them, but if they get through the first books fine than it can't hurt. As long as the child understands that what they are reading isn't real, I don't see a problem. Any book that a child wants to actually read and can understand is a good thing in my opinion.
1 person likes this
@silver_moon525 (282)
• United States
20 Feb 07
I think it all depends on the child's reading level. If the child is already starting to read chapter books at her age, then I think she should start. It doesn't negatively affect your mind or anything, in fact it probably just boosts one's imagination! My brother started reading Harry Potter at around six years old. I kept trying to delay him because I didn't think his reading level was quite up to par yet, but now that I think back to it, he was already reading chapter books as long as Harry Potter anyway. Plus the language that Harry Potter uses isn't really that deep or complicated. So I say if the six year old can read stuff like Goosbumps and Animorphs then she should be able to start on Harry Potter (besides the first book for Harry potter is short anyway.)
1 person likes this