Dual and Multiple Citizenships: Inimical to the national interest of Countries?

Philippines
February 21, 2007 10:14pm CST
Do you have dual or multiple citizenship? Don’t you think being a citizen of more than one country or state is inimical to the interest of the countries concerned? I mean you have dual/multiple allegiance. You swear loyalty to two or more states or countries? any ideas to share on this matter?
2 people like this
6 responses
• United States
22 Feb 07
While it could be inimical to a particular country in the short run, for the global community as a whole it is a good thing. If people get past the, "I am Country A, and you are not" they will start realizing we are all basically the same (except a few crazy people who want to ruin things for everyone because they are not in charge). So, if you have a tie to more than one country, your worldview is less limited and you are more likely to get along with others. I'm not explaining this well, but I think you can figure out what I mean. More citizens of the world equals less fighting amongst individual countries.
2 people like this
• Philippines
22 Feb 07
thank you for that response. You have a good point there. But i also think that dual or multiple citizenship can create conflict between the countries concerned especially when it comes to the laws the citizen must follow. i mean, each country will assert that their own laws shall be followed by the citizen. Countries have different laws, and considering that the citizen owes allegiance to a particular country, that country will expect the citizen to follow their national laws.And the other country/state to whom a person also is a citizen, will expect the same. this will result in conflict between the countries concerned.
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Feb 07
The laws aren't that different. I mean murder is murder. It is the fiddly ones that are different like getting your driver's license renewed (or who is allowed to drive). Just follow the laws of the particular country when in that country -- either as a citizen or a visitor and don't worry about it if you are not. Trust me, no one is going to another country to get someone because someone forgot to get their smog certificate on time.
• Philippines
23 Feb 07
there is still a problem not on the crime itself but on matters of jurisdiction over the crime committed, on matters of succession, legal capacity, etc..but anyway, thanks for responding to my post. :)
@Wanderlaugh (1622)
• Australia
22 Feb 07
I know at least one Californian who said that being a dual Australian/American has done him a lot of good in dealing with US taxes on all their various levels. I know other expat Americans who are full Aussies, and they do have some feelings for the old place, but I doubt if anyone thinks they're disguised Americans. Loyalty is a developed feeling. Most historical traitors were nationals of the countries they betrayed. A person's real allegiances are probably shaped by their relationship with that nation. I think the strain on allegiances comes when there's conflict between personal beliefs and the nation. The greater that conflict, the more likely the failure of allegiance.
• Canada
26 Feb 07
I don't believe in loyalty. I am a Canadian citizen, but I would love to be a citizen of both Denmark and Canada, as my flags, and my screenname would suggest. I am as Danish as I am Canadian. I'm white, and my parents were white, but if my mother was black and my father was white would I not be a shade darker than my father but lighter than my mother? This identity crisis even led me to change my surname, as my spoken language is English, so I wanted a name that was Danish.
@ukchriss (2097)
24 Feb 07
No I live in Uk and dont have Dual and Multiple Citizenships. Dual citizenship is a complex issue and it is important that you understand that there also obligations and not only benefits that comes with being a dual citizen. Being a citizen of two countries means that you need to obey the laws of both countries, including paying taxes and serving in the military (if required by any of the countries). The "United States Dual Citizenship Guide" explains these issues in detail. You can buy this online
@byfaithonly (10698)
• United States
22 Feb 07
I only have citizenship in one country, The United States of America. I agree with you, how can a person be completely loyal to two different countries? Too many times I've seen situations where these people say, "Well, I'm mad at this country this month so I'll support the other." or they run to the other country when in trouble with the other, they manage to not pay taxes and such in one or the other countries. I think having a home is very important and people need to decide where there "home" is going to be.
• Philippines
22 Feb 07
yes thank you for that response byfaithonly. like you i can't see how a person can be loyal to more than one country. you said it right, one should decide the country he will call his home.
@LeXDei (209)
• Philippines
24 Feb 07
I am a Filipino citizen. Having another citizenship is really far from my mind right now. I think that the enacted law is not very much consistent with the meaning that I have in mind when it comes to citizenship. I have the opinion that being a citizen of a nation means being loyal and swearing allegiance to his country. I believe that a person cannot serve two masters at the same time.
• Philippines
25 Feb 07
thanks lexdei. same with you filipino heRE.