HARRY POTTER - Book Vs Movie

United States
October 14, 2006 3:04pm CST
Which one do u prefer ?? I have seen the movies and read all the books too. I personally think itz the BOOKS....Movies dont do justice to her imagination. what do u think ?
3 responses
D.C. Malcolm - Historical Mystery Author
@indiandevil (2410)
• Canada
14 Oct 06
The books are better. It isn't so bad with Soucerers Stone or Chamber of secrets, they stick pretty well to the exact book...however from the POA and on they leave out alot of very important details in the book. Like for instance in Goblet of fire, they leave Percy Weasleys Role out, however it is going to be very hard to explain why Percy has shunned his family, and why the weasleys disown him in OOTP.
pspl521
@pspl521 (89)
• United States
15 Oct 06
Exactly my point...the movie leaves out the small details..which are imp for the story !! Thanks for haring your view
D.C. Malcolm - Historical Mystery Author
@indiandevil (2410)
• Canada
15 Oct 06
your welcome I could talk alnight about harry potter...
pspl521
@pspl521 (89)
• United States
15 Oct 06
me too...glad to meet another Die Hard Harry Potter Fan !
Smclin1
@Smclin1 (324)
• United States
15 Oct 06
I agree with IndianDevil. The movies just started to leave out more and more as they progressed through the series. And add to that, they deviate from the original plot on many details. I much prefer the books and can't wait for the 7th one.
pspl521
@pspl521 (89)
• United States
15 Oct 06
Yeah..me too waiting for the 7th book
istanto
@istanto (8548)
• Indonesia
15 Oct 06
i already see the movie.. not good yet.....