No diploma, no license.
By sheenac1983
@sheenac1983 (63)
Canada
March 6, 2007 11:50am CST
In Canada, we are trying to pass a law where, if you do not graduate from highschool, you will not be able to get your drivers license. They will also be raising the age to 18 (from 16).
Do you agree with this new law? Do you think it is a good idea?
I personally think it is an excellent idea. Right now, if you do not have your diploma, you are going to go nowhere. I know from experience because I just got mine last year (when I was 23). Without your diploma, you are stuck in minimum wage jobs.
Education is essential in order to be successful in life. With less highschool drop outs, we will have fewer people on the streets, fewer people in min wage dead end jobs, etc.
I think it is good incentive to finish highschool. Those who don't care enough now, will definately care in the near future.
10 people like this
36 responses
@oiixdaii (1059)
• Philippines
6 Mar 07
I think this law is a little harsh. What if the person couldn't finish high school because of financial problems. Having a driver's license is very important because they could also use their driving skills as a source of income.
@sirensanssmile (3764)
• Netherlands
7 Mar 07
In most countries, high school is free (Well paid for by everyone's taxes but no dues individually.)
So financial problems hindering high school? For Many countries that excuse doesn't make sense.
In high school times, finances shouldn't be on the students concerns but on their parents still as they are still under their parents in many cases.
I think that countries should do things to motivate their people to get their education. If they simply allowed their people to stay uneducated the future of their country doesn't look so bright.
@MattKuhl (5)
•
7 Mar 07
I think it is a great incentive to make students finish highschool. I, myself did not graduate due to medical issues. However, I have been lucky and chose the correct career path for myself (radio), in which I am paid according to service and talent rather than my past education.
I have a tough time deciding whether or not I support this law. Many students in the United States have after school or weekend jobs, in which they must drive to get to. This allows them to save money for their own car, college, and other things.
1 person likes this
@melody1011 (1663)
• India
7 Mar 07
I agree that education is very important. but there are also certain cases where people cannot complete their education due to various genuine reasons. maybe they dont have the means, or the ability to clear their exams. In that case it would hamper their earning ability as well. But i dont live in canada so i cannot say much for most of hte people out there
1 person likes this
@jasonsian (231)
• Malaysia
7 Mar 07
That's something which I strongly agree if our government will do something like that. This act urges teens to finish their highschool and by increasing the age of getting a driving license from 16 to 18, I think there's reason for the government to do so. I think what they want is actually decreasing the rate of accidents. You know there are a lot of teens who likes speeding on highways which may turn out to be a deadly accident.
I'm from malaysia, that's what they are trying to do, but they are trying to increase the age of getting a driving license from 18 to 21. It has been 2 years but nothing has been done due to objection from the people. I really hope one day our government will apply the same policy as what the Canadian government did.
1 person likes this
@ElementalDragon (156)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I would favor not having unlimited (adult) driving privilege (driving is NOT a right, contrary to popular belief) unless you had completed high school. I also would favor a graduated scale of driving privileges, which I've heard about recently in news articles relating statistics on teen driving fatalities.
As far as minimum wage jobs, they are always going to exist, and somebody is going to need to do them. Of course, some people may like to do them, for all I know.:)
My $0.02 at the moment.
@red158 (333)
• Canada
7 Mar 07
We already have a graduated licensing system here in Ontario, and although I agree with it for young drivers, I don't agree with it for adults (over 25). As far as having to graduate high school I feel that is going to far, do you know in Ontario you have to have a credit in gym to get your diploma.
Another posted put forth the scenario of a young single mom who had to quit school to look after a child, are you going to penalize her further. Maybe our Government needs to actually put forth some effort and help these kids graduate.
@ElementalDragon (156)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I don't agree with no limits based on being a certain age, whether it's 18 or 21 or 25 or whatever. I think it ought to be based on driving experience. Kansas already has limits based on expereince for younger drivers, but just because you are 25, doesn't mean you have any driving experience.
Maybe your citizens need to be better informed of what assistance is available for people who need it. Most governments have assistance programs for all sorts of things. I can't tell you what Canada has, but I have had to take advantage of several that the United States provides over the last couple of years.
As I said, driving is a privelege, not a right. It is something you need to earn or prove you can handle.
My $0.02 at the moment.
@Methodless (882)
• Canada
7 Mar 07
You are misunderstood, you can get a drivers license if you drop out, you just have to wait until you are 18 instead of 16. They are not considering not letting you ever have your licence, at least not to my knowledge.
@sirensanssmile (3764)
• Netherlands
7 Mar 07
Well I think it will give more motivation to people to graduate. Some may think it is harsh, but trying to motivate people to be educated isn't harsh to me. I think that education should be a big deal because it is for your county's continued future. What would the state of your country be if people didn't seek out their education?
@funzone (86)
• India
7 Mar 07
I personally think that for getting licence age must be considered and not the education. Though it is a good idea for all people to be educated but it is bad too. If a person who have not enough money to get educated then what will be the options for him to earn.
@mrbranan (1012)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I complety agree. I think haveing a license is a sign that you should be growing up and making good decitions. If you are not mature enough to stay in school your not mature enough to get a license.With out an education you might as well plan on staying at home with your parents and having nothing the rest of your life.
@alienation68 (103)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I think for most kids this would be a good idea, unless there's a serious reason they're not able to get a diploma. I don't think kids should be punished if family is in immediate need of them. if an only child is raised by a father with cancer I think he should still be allowed his license until he is able to return to a school setting and obtain it.
but like i said first, it's a great idea for slackers and kids who have no interest in their futures
@flpoolbum (2978)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I agree with the idea of needing to graduate before getting a driver's license. However, I think that there should also be a Grade Point average requirement, perhaps a minimum of a "C" average (A=Excellent; B=Above Average; C=Average; D=Below Average and E=Failing). There is no sense in having someone stay in school without them making a real effort to get something out of it.
I also think that it is important that school systems assist students who are having problems. There as been a problem in some United States schools, where children who are not passing would be promoted to the next grade anyway. That is why some children in high school have extremely low scores in reading, math and science.
When I was in high school in the late seventy's, my school district had developed courses with the main purpose was for children to like them, a good example was a course for children with low reading skills called "Comic Strip Characters". One teacher studied some Psychology or Psychiatry so she talking the school board into allowing her to create a class where the students could talk about their problems or feelings. All school systems should be required to study their cirrculums and have more programs with more requirements in Math and Science. The United States Government has a website that tells what careers will grow in demand and what careers won't. There are many careers with growing demands which require Math and Science.
It is also a good idea to allow 16 year olds to get a restricted license as long as they maintain the required GPA.
@nirmalkomal (63)
• India
7 Mar 07
yes i agree with this new law.i personally think its an excellent idea
@cloud_kicker_32 (4635)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I think its a good idea for some points..although having a diploma its just as hard getting a job..just as bad as not having one..BUT..I dont want ANYONE drivign that cant read..there are to many signs that people need to be able to read..And i like the idea of age the age limit going up to 18..i have always thought 16 was wayy to yung myself..But i do disagree on the few people on streets.having a diploma realy has nothing to do with that..heck i know college kids that are on the streets..and alot of times they cant get jobs they spent all that money on...
@20031969 (932)
• India
7 Mar 07
i would first thank to Canadian Govt. who has made a law regarding driving license. it is indeed good to be passed graduation and the enhancement of age bar from 16 to 18. if you once graduate, not only you are entitled to get driving license but also you can make your carrer doing higher studies or getting good job for your livelihood. there must be some minimum formalities from the government (each and every country)to make people compel to obey law.
@lloydanthony111 (4698)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I usually don't go for these kind of things, but in this case, it's a great idea.
It gives them incentive to finish high school and you will have a better educated driving public.
That's one rule I wouldn't mind seeing here in the U.S.
Lloyd
@Aryanbharani (209)
• India
7 Mar 07
i cant say either way, agreeing to this law would be agreeing to the fact that ppl without a highskool education are doomed and refusing it is like asking a kid to drive.........ppl without a highskool degree too have shined in life, and there are several ppl who dont go to skool cos they cant afford to