AMERICAN IDOL-Boys you stimk tonight !!!

I wouldn't go so far as to say that they "stink." However, compared to previous years, there certainly isn't a major star amongst the guys. I like Blake. While he doesn't have a fantastic voice, he definitely has a unique style, is quite contemporary and may just emerge as this year's winner. I think with the women there are 3 of them that will split the major vote. LaKeisha, Stephanie and Melinda are all quite exceptional, with similar styles. Because of this I think that there is a chance that one of these 3 will be eliminated within the next couple of weeks, and we will all be shocked. That's just my opinion.

They really didn't have a good night did they? Chris did so good. And so did Blake...a little off key a couple of times, but still good. I hope the girls give us better performances tonight!

This season is a big let-down. There is no one exciting who stands out. The songs these guys chose were just plain boring. How many seasons has this show been on? How many times have they heard the judges say they want to see "the wow factor"? I want to see the wow factor too. This is just plain boring.

No they were lousy but I just finished watching the girls tonight they sure make the boys look bad. These girls are good!

I think that they did to. I am kind of cheering for the bald guy. I think he sound perrty good but who know who will win. but I agree with you about chris tonight.

The guys STUNK big time. What did Sanjaya do to his hair - not a cool look. Why is he still there? Well I guess we will see what happens Thursday.

I totally agree with you. The boys did stink. The girls have been blowing them away.

The boys were awful last night with the exception of the two Chris in the contest and Blake. They chose poor songs or the songs they sung they did poorly. Even the judges commented on that they were not very good last night and they felt that only four of them belong in the top 12. I definitely see a female winning the contest this year. The girls are a million times better than the guys, with the exception of Antonella.

I am usually glued to the tv when American Idol is on. But sadly not tonight. The Boy's just literally stink. I will tune in for the Girls tomorrow night. But next week Tuesday, if they have not moved to the big stage yet I for one will not be watching! How could they have picked so many poor performers???? Yuck , no talent at all tonight except for Chris Sligh.

I actually missed the episode tonight and for some reason thought that the girls were on tonight. Now that I think about it, the boys have been going first all along. LOL I must be losing my mind. Well I'm excited to watch the girls tomorrow but I must say that I am rather displeased this season. I don't feel that anyone is exceptionally good this season. I've found that with each season I am less interested. What's going on with American Idol?