Do you think a person should be close friends with ex inlaws?

United States
March 7, 2007 12:45pm CST
I have been divorced for almost 10 years, I am still friends with my ex mother in law, and my brother in laws, except for one of them, who thought I was wrong to get divorced from his brother (he thinks his brother is so perfect, which is his opinion and that's fine, he just refused to listen to my side). My mother and his mother also remained friends. I'm not sure how much was for the children, but even though my children are 18 and 22, we're still friends. My new husband of 9 years is still friends with his ex brother in law and his wife which I find a little strange. He and his first wife were only together a few years and only married about 2 years. Her parents aren't too friendly with him and her brother only calls once or twice a year but he still thinks of them as close friends. I'm not going to tell him that it's wrong or that I won't allow it, I just think it's a little strange that they never see each other and they weren't family for that long, but he thinks they were so close, when it's obvious to me that they weren't, and now that his ex wife is remarried they don't talk to him at all any more. Do you think a person should be close friends with ex inlaws?
8 people like this
26 responses
@fatragu (677)
• United States
8 Mar 07
I think that if you had a good relationship with them then the divorce or breakup is no reason to all of a sudden stop the relationship. I love one of my mom-in-laws and both my dad-in-laws. Before someone gets confused hubby's parents are both divorced and remarried. My 2yr old also has an uncle that is only like 9 or 10. Her oldest is 34 or around there.
2 people like this
@JuliaPan (564)
• Canada
8 Mar 07
I personally don't see nothing strange in that. If people continue to be good friends in spite of their relatives' relationships with their exex, why not? But I remember how my mother told me that she was very much offended when she got to know that my fathers' relatives remained friends with his first wife (my mother is the second wife) many years after my father and his first wife's divorced. That divorce was rather a dirty thing because my dad's first wife gossiped about their relationships. That's why my mother was offended - she felt sorry for my dad in fact, she said he didn't deserve such relatives.
@jillbeth (2705)
• United States
7 Mar 07
You divorce the spouse, not his family! I think it's great, especially for the kids, if everyone can get along. My ex-MIL is 1500 miles away and we don't keep in touch but I'd like to think we would get along. My husband and I are friends with his first wife's family, which is nice, we can even tolerate his ex. She comes to the grandkids birthday parties at our house! He had some hard feelings against her for a long time but once the grandkids came along I guess it gave us all a common bond.
2 people like this
@Willowlady (10658)
• United States
7 Mar 07
I don't see anything wrong with adults being friends with whomever they please. Some are still aunts and uncles anyway. As long as they all act in a decent manner then it should be a good thing in their lives. Especially if there are children involved.
2 people like this
• India
8 Mar 07
well I would rather like to congratulate you.... that from my point of view is really something very unusual... And very sensitive tooo.... and it shows that u r a hearty person... u ended up one relation but in no sense it shud make out this sense that you gotta terminate all relations....right... So u still tAlk to your ex - husband.... what kinda relation do u maintain with him?
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
Well, I think I put this as a comment to someone else, however I wanted to answer you're question directly also, so if I'm repeating myself I aplogize. My ex husband and I were friends before we got married and a couple of months after our divorce we returned to a friendship, he and my husband had even become close friends, it wasn't until he moved a girlfriend and her sons in that he stopped talking to us, even if it had to do with our 2 cildren. Now, a couple of months after they got married, he won't even talk to our children. They are adults now (18 and 22) so they know what's he's doing and it hurts them so much. I know my husband and I can't change the situation so we just make sure that they know that we will always be here for them and will always love them no matter what. Thank you for your nice comments.
• United States
8 Mar 07
I do not see anything wrong with it as long as your not in the middle of their divorce or split up
2 people like this
@JC1969 (1224)
• United States
8 Mar 07
I don't see anything wrong with this. When you marry, you become part of an extended family, and many times form bonds with in-laws that are as close as the ones you have with your own family. Sometimes the divorce is amicable and a mutually agreed upon circumstance, whereas it leaves no ill feelings with the couple and their families. Even if the marriage ends on a bad note, many times the in-laws are able to see passed the issues in the marriage and still maintain the relationship they built, especially if their are grandkids involved. In your husbands case, I am guessing their is no ill feelings that manifested from the divorce, but life has gone on and even though he doesn't see his ex-wife's brother often or speaks with him regularly, he would still like to think that they did and do share a bond of friendship--maybe there are good memories and good conversations that have bonded them so the quantity of communications doesn't define the relationship and the quality of the communications does. Is it also possible that your husband was friend with the ex-wife's brother before he became a couple with the sister? Maybe they had a pre-friendship that existed before he married the brother's sister.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
I see what you're saying. however they didn't meet until after he and his ex wife became a couple. I know they did hang out, but not too often as we live in Georgia and his ex brother inlaw lives in New York. I guess I just don't see why he still thinks of him as such a close friend when they only speak once a year, when my husband calls him and it's obivious that there has been a change in the way he (and his wife)feel about my husband since his ex wife remarried. I know I have to live with it though, my husband has a big heart and he holds a lot of people dear, even though a lot of them don't return the feelings. Thanks for the response.
@Bee1955 (3882)
• United States
8 Mar 07
There's nothing wrong with being friends as long as its amicable. I still talk with my sister-in-law and considered her kids my nieces and nephews though I've been divorced from her brother since 1988. I was their aunt for 15 years of my marriage and they still call me Aunt and their kids called me Great-Aunt. Just because you divorce the spouse doesnt mean people have to sever good relatons, no matter how long the marriage.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
I think it would be easier for me if my ex husbands neices and nephews continued to see me as an aunt, but they don't, and I was married to their uncle for 9 years. They still come to birthday parties for my children because they're cousins, but I'm just considered their cousins mom. They even come to parties for my son that I have with my husband now.
@djmarion (4898)
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
there is definitely nothing wrong on being close to inlaws, be it former or recent since when you get married you will be a part of your spouse family. even if you are already divrced by now its still good that you can get along with your inlaws, and for me there's no such thingas ex-inlaws...they will always be your inlaws.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
I know what you're saying, even though I don't consider them in laws any longer, we will always be connected because of the children. They will always be my children's Grandmother and Uncles. I guess I was asking this type of question because I know there are some people who won't have anything to do with the ex (like in the case of my husband and his ex wifes family, after the divorce, they didn't have much to do with him and now that she's remarried they have even less to do with him, even though he is still their granddaughter's dad). Thanks for the response.
• United States
8 Mar 07
i don't really thin it is that strange. Sometimes peple can look past their differences if they truly enjoy(ed) each other.
• Canada
10 Mar 07
I think it has to have to do with how they broke up if they were honest adn it was a mutal thing and they realised that things were bad then i belive it is a normal part of any relationship. Thsoe type are very rare unlikemost others where one does nto have the guts to tell the truth adn end it liek an adult. To me i sounds like your husband had one of those and he has nto hidden it from you. I think you are lucky to find a guy like that.
1 person likes this
@cielo_22 (38)
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
theres nothing wrong being closed with your in laws or with the relatives of your ex husband.actually its really good for your kids.they will be much happy if you still get along with their fathers relative.and even the two of you.besides when you divorced your husband it doesnt mean that you also want to forget his family.the problem was only betwen the two of you and his family is not included. of course you`re wishing to have new friends itsokay but it doesnt mean that you`re going to forget your old friends.it would be much better if your current husband and your ex could get along well.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
My husband and my ex had become real good friends, they hung out all the time, wheather it was just hanging out at one of their houses,going to ball games together, concerts, and camping, it wan't until my ex moved his new girlfriend and her children in, that it changed to, as his girlfriend put it, "He has a family now". Where as I always thought that there are many types of families, even if it's just a man and his children (his new girlfriend doesn't even consider my children her family, even though now they are married).Thanks for the response.
@catbvq (364)
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
Why not? It has nothing to do with your divorce. Friends should be accumulated and keep forever. We do not pick friends they come to us because they like who we are and it does not affect them even if you have finally ended your relationship with a member of their family. Some couples who divorced still remain friends maybe because they understand that even if they are no longer compatible they still care that much for each other. Some of the extended family feel that way too, they can't help staying friends with the ex's because they learn to love them too.
1 person likes this
@mykykko (424)
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
My relationship w/ my husband is in crisis right now.In my case im having hard time to do what i really what since his family treats me so well and love me as i've love them.For me it is very hard to leave my in laws because of the years we've shared that i treasure most. If in case we get separated i would say i'd stiil be close w/ my ex inlaws,but if the case is they are bad to me during our marriage of coarse i would be glad to stay away from them and just keep them as a part of my past.
@neon2000 (2756)
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
Its just fine, after all it's your ex that you get divorced and not them to be affected. Just ignore the one who doesn't understand you in divorcing your brother if he can't help.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Mar 07
there's nothing wrong with being friends with them. if you built a genuine friendship then your connections of the past shouldnt affect you. you're great coz you're still friends with them!
• India
8 Mar 07
Yes a person can be close friend with ex inlaws. There may be no problem because you mingled with the family and there is no cause to break them because you took divorce from your husband. If inlaws are the main cause for break up you may breakup with them too.
• India
8 Mar 07
friend ship is the ark of life.no need of being close friend with ex inlaws ,closeness with ex inlaws will bring him somany problems,he will be depressed because of her memories and dont accept him to be frendly with ex in laws
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
When we get a divorce from someone who was once a big part of our lives, we divorce the person not the family. You can't blame the entire family for something that went wrong between two people. Families are permanent units based on love or blood. And those people who becomes our in-laws through the union of two people based on love remain as much a part of the person's family after a divorce as they were during the marriage. In-law relations are often so ridiculed in our society and of such poor quality, the fact that you still regard your in-laws as friends and keep them in your lives is exemplary of how things should be in a perfect world! Bless you for that!
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Mar 07
I think its okay. Just because your no longer married to the guy, doesnt mean you cant be friends with their family. sure, it can be a little akward, if your hanging out with them and he's there, but what can you do? your divorcing him, not his family.
1 person likes this