who's out?!

I must agree, they are not top 12 material so they must go. But they should of gone already so who knows? I believe Holly will be going home tonight also, her performance was as forgettable as Simon said it was. If someone good instead of Sanjaya goes home tonight I will be very dissapointed.

Both have very weak singing voices. I think they just got lucky to still be there. I've been thinking that these two would make a good couple for each other! I'll be schocked if they are not gone tonight

Yes, I agree. I don't think either should be in the top 12. I also think Sundance Head isn't up to par, either. Check out www.votefortheworst.com. It is actually a campaign to get people to vote for the worst contestants. Not that I would want anyone to do that. I just thought it was a funny site.

I think Antonella and Sanjaya were just lucky to pass that 2 previous week when I think they were the weakest performers. I think they'll be gone tonight and Hailey too and I have no idea whos the other guy. Maybe the bald one.

I totally agree with your choices.It amazes me that these 2 performers even made it this far. Especially,Antonella.i truly believe that if she weren't so pretty, she'd have been voted off the first week.It's just a shame that this is supposedly a singing contest and should be treated as just that.She is literally hard to listen to,shows no real personality and her song choices are way out of her range of talent.As far as Sanjaya is concerned, he belongs more in a high school talent show, than on American Idol.Nice enough person,but totally out of his league.Wake up America, these 2 have to go.Wow, how I miss last year.