Autistic Children
By albert2412
@albert2412 (1782)
United States
March 12, 2007 4:06pm CST
I was just thinking. Since autism is caused my mercury poisoning, can we perhaps help our autistic children by stimulating areas of the brain where mercury has not bonded with the brain? Most children are right handed with expressive language localized in the left hemisphere of the brain. Most left handed children are bilateral and use both sides of the brain for expressive language. If some of these right handed autistic children were taught to use their left hands for doing things, would they become less autistic because they are using areas of the brain where there may be less mercury? What do you think? When a child thinks and speaks using a different area of the brain, the electrical impulses in his brain may move the mercury around and help expell the mercury.
3 people like this
14 responses
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
13 Mar 07
Autism isn't necessarily caused by mercury poisoning. THey don't know what causes it. And relearning something with the other side of your brain isn't only difficult, it doesn't work all the time...
2 people like this
@albert2412 (1782)
• United States
16 Mar 07
Hello MrNiceGuy. I do not know everything anymore than any body else does, but I would ask you a question. If autism is not caused by mercury poisoning, how come autism started and was discovered about 1943, about the same time that childhood vaccines started to become widely used? (mercury, called thimerosal, has traditionally been used as a preservative in vaccines.) If autism was genetically based it would have been mentioned in the medical literature from the 1800's.
1 person likes this
@payingforschool (678)
• Canada
17 Mar 07
It is mentioned in the medical literature, it just iasn't labelled Autism. People with symptoms that we now call Autism would be labelled 'simple'. Often, they would be hidden, kept out of records, and kept of of family tree charts, because people were ashamed of them.
@unusualsuspect (2602)
• United States
13 Mar 07
Tons of research has shown that there is no connection between mercury and autism. Autism existed long before people starting getting bent out of shape over the idea that vaccinations were causing it. There are many different types of neurological problems with autism and there is no single effective way of dealing with it. Not to mention that your knowledge of how the brain works is a bit lacking. There would be no way to move mercury or anything else around in the brain.
2 people like this
@SageMother (2277)
• United States
13 Mar 07
Autsim caused by mercury poisoning?
I think there are many more causes than just this one. I don't think you could simply apply electrical current to the brain and remove the mercury either. I think it uses covalent bonds that would require the introduction of another chemical form outside of the body. You couldn't just change the charge of the chemicals already present.
Some autism is the result of people waiting until they are past the age of 25 to have their first children as well. That isn't a mercury issue...it is an aging sperm and ovum issue.
1 person likes this
@payingforschool (678)
• Canada
14 Mar 07
That's just one of the several autism myths. There is no evidence whatsoever that age of parent has anything to dow with Autism. Not even the slightest hint of it,a ctually.
@NancyLobo (680)
• India
13 Mar 07
Autism is a horrible sickness, and the children suffer terribly when they get this, only parents and siblings of the affected child will realize the pain nobody can understand it better as parents we try to figure out why this autism occured, we think it would be mercury or some other reason, but the world will not understand it, aas many other children take the same vaccinations but they do not get Autism, so they won't accept it anyway no use of thinking at the cause as at present we are already having the child suffer, proper training can improve the symptoms of autism, parents have to do that work as it requires a lot of dedication and perservation, I think the best way to destroy autism is through prayers, God can do it nothing is too tough for him that he cannot heal, even though there is no hope in the present world, he can heal, nothing is too hard for him, pray to the Lord Jesus for wisdom and he will help us to destroy autism in his name.
1 person likes this
@sylviekitty (2083)
• United States
13 Mar 07
I appreciate your sentiments, and a lot of what you say is true. However, I do feel that even if every parent of a child with Autism prayed nightly for their ASD to go away, it would not happen. It isn't about faith (or lack thereof) in God. Miracles can happen, but you're asking a hell of a lot there.
1 person likes this
@NancyLobo (680)
• India
14 Mar 07
Please don't get me wrong that I said autism is a horrible sickness, I am a mom of a son with autism, I have done my best to train my son with whatever knowledge I have he has learnt a lot, some things like speech even though we do our work of training them God has to open their mouths to speak, I meant campared to mental retardation or any other sickness in autism some skills are learnt by the children very fast but speech and some social behaviors they are very far behind I love my son with autism very much and I train him to the best of my capacities but In India were we live we lack all the resources of training In US all the facilites available so it is okay , I never lose hope to teach my child so don't get me wrong,I just vented out my feelings.
1 person likes this
@redstrawberry113 (102)
• United States
13 Mar 07
I admire your dedication to prayer for autistic people. I do howevever object your idea of autism being a horrible sickness. The reason so many autistics kids don't get anywhere is because other people view them as hopeless and that there isn't anything we can do about it but try to educate them. If you believe that something, in this case autism, is horrible, then you are setting up these kids for failure. There are many phases for parents to experience when their child is diagnosed, one being denial, and that is understandable, then there is grief, parents have to mourn the loss of the dreams they had for their child, but to give thhe children a life prophecy of never being able to do what "normal" kids do is wrong. I have just read a book called "Son Rise" by Barry Kaufman. It is an excellent book and while not all autistic kids are the same it helps parents embrace their child instead of giving them a self-fulfulling prophecy that they will never be able to do this and that. Mr. Kauffman's son was diagnosed autistic when he was younger and now he's graduated college and has no signs of autism. It's all about approach and instead of feeling sorry for what you don't have and having a negative impact on your child's life, do something that will help them, whatever it takes, cause if that child was "normal" you wouldn't have a problem embracing them. C'mon people it's not the end of the world. God chose you as parents for an autistic child because he knew you could handle it. If you are truly interested about autism read that book, it helps.
@Debs_place (10520)
• United States
13 Mar 07
Albert, where did you get the idea that autism is caused by mercury poisoning? The true cause is unknown, although they are looking at genetic causes and possible environment.
I would be interested in learning your source.
What is your background in the field?
1 person likes this
@Garry_NEC (155)
• Canada
12 Mar 07
Although you're idea is quite good, I don't think it would work. All humans use both sides of the brain and use both hands (yes one to a more precise degree) but both are used. I think mediation would help-since it stimulates and strengthens both sides of the brain equally. I think the best solution wold be done by using nanotechnology. By removing the mercury molecules. Though we're not their yet, we will be.
@Thoroughrob (11742)
• United States
13 Mar 07
Hopefully someone has already started checking into it. I think I would ask the Dr. what he thinks. I do know with CP we are trying to teach our children things that have been damaged because of a defect. We are teaching the other parts of the brain to take over for the damaged parts, so it really makes sense to me, but I am not a scientist or Dr..
1 person likes this
@destinycole (827)
•
13 Mar 07
er autism is not caused by mercury poisoning. The cause is unknown but it is believed that genetics hold the key to this condition.
Be careful stating something so broad without backing it up with evidence.
Mercury kills, it does not stay in the brain, it kills as in we die when we are poisoned by mercury. It does stay in the brain.
My evidence is based on research and I would urge any reader to go the National Autistic Societies Website for more researched information. http://www.nas.org.uk/
They state
What causes autism?
The exact cause or causes of autism is/are still not known but research shows that genetic factors are important. It is also evident from research that autism may be associated with a variety of conditions affecting brain development which occur before, during, or very soon after birth.
@mobyfriend (1017)
• Netherlands
13 Mar 07
There is no link between mercury and autism but what do you mean exactly by autistic? If you think that that autism has to do with lacking in expressive language than you are wrong. Autism has to with interpretation wihtin all the five senses. Therefore someone who is autistic needs to live a very structured life. There are skills you can learn to survive in a world which demands a lot of everyone but it is not a cure.
Als there a several levels of autism. Not everyone is highfunctioning and on there also austists who are mentally handicapped as well. You cannot apply the same treatment techniques to everyone.
1 person likes this
@payingforschool (678)
• Canada
14 Mar 07
First - Autism is not caused by mercury poisoning. There is absolutely no causal proof of this, just a lot of correlations which means nothing. I coudl give you correlations between bird migration and price of coffee, but it doesn't mean that birds fly away when coffee gets expensive. It's just that the two things happen at the same time. Add to that, the mercury CORRELATION (not causation) studies are getting weaker and weaker. Especially since they deiscovered the gene sequence.
Second - you clearly don't understand the human brain. There are areas that are specialized for cetain tasks. They are physiologically laid out that way. You can't just make the body use a different part of the brain for a different function. You also clearly don't understand Autism that well, if you think it is a disorder of communication.
Can't wait for you to actually READ and RESPOND To the many, many comments you get over your many discussions showing you the faulty logic in the Autism-mercury link.
@byfaithonly (10698)
• United States
12 Mar 07
I'm certainly no scientist so would have no way of knowing if this would help or not, might be something to check with the experts on. For 3 years I worked in an adult foster care home and several of the residents were autistic, each had different levels of communication but very little verbal from any. I am also good friends with a family who have a daughter who is autistic and they work very closely with her - she is very verbal although slurred. I may run this thought past them as I'm sure they would be interested or know what progress is being done in that area. My concern would be the mercury moving around and causing more damage rather than expelling it.
@xenatessmocker (339)
• United States
13 Mar 07
There are different kinds of autism and all the genetic and environmental causes are not yet known. However you do pose an interesting hypothesis.
1 person likes this