How old were you when you found out Santa Clause wasn't real?

Santa Clause - Jolly old St. Nick!
Singapore
March 19, 2007 7:18am CST
It's a stupid question and most of you probably don't celebrate Christmas. But for those of you who does and were brought up and introduced to Santa...How did you find out he wasn't real? Me? I was around 10. I actually don't remember how I found out. No, there weren't disappointments. I guess I just kinda knew...when my bright shiny bike wasn't under our tree.:) I guess I just grew out of it. But that was a fun time. I remember I always wrote him letters and then around midnight my brothers would hand me my present saying it's from Santa and I'd ask where he was and they said he just left.:) God, I was gullible!
11 people like this
41 responses
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
19 Mar 07
my daughter is 10 and still believes and because kids grow up so fast these days, i am gonna let her hold on to one last vestage of childhood!
3 people like this
• Singapore
19 Mar 07
I know what you mean, I let my nephews and nieces believe in him too. I told them to write their letters to Santa Clause and told them to ask for two things, that way if I can't afford one I'll just buy the other. :) It was fun and it's nice to see their faces when they open their presents. *sigh* the innocence of childhood.
2 people like this
• United States
19 Mar 07
I guess I was somewhere in the 9-10 year range when I figured out that Santa wasn't a real person (catching your mother putting presents under the tree doesn't help in believeing LOL) although I feel that the spirit of Santa lives on in all of us :-)
3 people like this
• Singapore
19 Mar 07
I agree. Maybe part of me will always believe in him.
2 people like this
@hazydazy (783)
• United States
19 Mar 07
I was 6. My cousin, out of anger, decided it was time for me to know the truth. I was heartbroken. I remember crying myself to sleep. I still hold it against her...LOL.
2 people like this
• Singapore
19 Mar 07
OUCH! Why that Bubble burster. :) I hate it when people do that. What's wrong with letting a child believe in something that's good? :)
1 person likes this
@justreal (2364)
• Canada
19 Mar 07
believe it or not, but I found out when I was at the age of 9 years old. I was actually waiting for Santa Clause to come down. And I was awake for a awhile and then my parents told me that do ot wait for anything go to sleep, because Santa Clasue isn't really real.
2 people like this
@NatureBoy (493)
• Singapore
20 Mar 07
Your brothers really cared about you. :) I never really believed in Santa, not because of whether he exists or not. But because I stay in an apartment with no chimneys hahaha. There was no chance of him coming down the chimney for me. haha
2 people like this
@reeze_828 (137)
• Philippines
19 Mar 07
I was 9 years old that time! When i've caught my mom putting some candy in my socks! I was so disapointed that santa wasn't real. But i appreciate my moms effort for the candies and toy's! She just wanted me to be happy! I love you "mommy santa".
@ajithlal (14716)
• India
19 Mar 07
I think when I was 10 to 12 years that I found it true, but I still love to believe in Santa Clause. We used to write long letters to the santa clause when were young stating what all things we wanted and how good we have been etc. Some times I used to find presents and gifts under the Christmas tree leaved others for me. It is very good feeling to believe in Santa Clause and fairies. I used to read lot of fairy tales when I am young. Most times when we are down believing in Santa Clause, guardian angels, and fairy tales helps us to be happy and keep going in our life.
• Singapore
19 Mar 07
I know what you mean. It's nice to believe in something magical. And when you look back at it now, you'll think you're gullible but you'll always have that wonderful feeling around Christmas.
1 person likes this
@babyhar (1335)
• Canada
21 Mar 07
I do not believe that this at all is a 'stupid question.' I actually quite do like the question! You know.. For the life of me I cannot remember the 'exact age' that I was when I had found out that Santa Clause was not at all real. I do remember though when I had found out that Santa Clause wasn't real. I remember the location & what exactly had happened. It's funny though how I cannot remember the exact age that I was though. I remember when I lived in Saskatchewan.. One of my favorite places that I grew up in.. How one night my mom had made me & my sibling go to bed.. So we tried to but knew something was up as we heard crinkling of something.. I thought something was wrong or our dog at the time had gotten in to something.. So we decided to be all quiet & go & look at what the noise was.. As I knew I had thought it was Santa Clause.. My sister kept trying to tell me that Santa Clause wasn't at all real.. She tried to convince me for the longest time but I wasn't willing to believe her.. We we're able to be quiet & made our way around the corner & behind one of the couches.. As I peeked over the couch to my dismay.. There was my mom & the man whom she was dating at the time. Wrapping up gifts with wrapping paper.. I was in complete shock & didn't want to believe what I was seeing.. So closed my eyes hoping when I would open them that Santa Clause instead would be the one who was wrapping the gifts.. I looked up & still seen the same thing I had before.. My mom wrapping the gifts. She ended up looking up & panicked & tried to hide the gifts.. But never got the chance to do so as it was to late.. The tears began to fall.. I just felt so heart broken knowing that the whole idea of Santa Clause was not at all real. My mom tried to convince me that there was a Santa.. That she was just wrapping the gifts for Santa because he was busy.. But would be bringing me more gifts that he had wrapped himself.. But after that night I just wasn't willing to believe her.. It was to late.. I seen what I had seen & was not able to be convinced by anyone else that there was indeed a Santa Clause.. I honestly do wish that I hadn't found out the way I had.. I wished I would have found out some other way instead of witnessing my mom wrapping our Christmas gifts for us.. I wish I would have grown out of the idea on my own.. Or just found out through some other form.. Or at least from someone else.. But I guess what's done is done.. I just wish I would have found out another way I guess.. In conclusion.. I don't remember the exact age I was when I found out that Santa Clause wasn't real.. But I do know exactly what had happened that helped me to find out.. I know that when I have kids because of what I had gone through.. I do not want to spoil the idea for my own children I have someday in the future.. I'd much rather prefer if they would find out on there own.. Without me having to tell them that he isn't at all real.. I want them to just like the idea of actually opening up a gift that Santa had bought him/her.. Or being able to write a letter to Santa himself.. I know personally that I'd much rather allow them to grow out of the idea of Santa Clause or find out some other way.. As I would never want to take that away from them.. As I know what it was like for me to find out the way I had! . . Thanks for allowing me to share! xx
• Singapore
22 Mar 07
Amen! But we all have to find out one way or another. I guess for other people, the way the found out is harder. :) It's sort of a bittersweet memory. You'll remember that feeling of anticipation when Christmas comes around but you also remember the disappointment when you eventually found out. But would you deprive your child of having a wonderful, magical Christmas memory just to shield her from a little disappointment? We will all get disappointed, heartbroken, one time in our lives but we will only be kids ONCE. You only get to believe in Santa once. Share the joy! :)
• United States
20 Mar 07
What do you mean there is no Santa Claus?! He exists.Whenever a person gets what he always wanted for Christmas, Santa was there in spirit. I always knew "Santa" was my dad. I would always make Christmas lists and I knew my mom and dad would be the ones to get the gifts. Whenever I hear "I saw Mommy kissing Santa Claus", I would think of my mom and dad.It sure helped that my dad was round and jolly like Santa.There is a Santa.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
20 Mar 07
You know what I mean.. ;) Of course he is real, read one of my comments above. I always liked seeing big guys with large belly and white hair coz they always remind me of Santa.
2 people like this
• United States
20 Mar 07
I don't remember how old I was but I do remember that I was devastated because I really believed and I was very upset to find out my parents had been lying to me. Of course, it was just one more lie from them and it made me mistrust them even more. I think it's cruel for a parent to tell their children to believe in something that's a lie. I think it's fine for kids to enjoy the fantasy of Santa as long as they know it's just a fantasy and not real. And, I think it's wrong for parents to mislead their children about anything because it causes mistrust and insecurity. Of course, since I grew up in a home where I was being hit and I didn't have anyone I could trust, I think I feel more strongly about this type of thing than most. I still think it's wrong to deceive a child if you really want them to trust you.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
20 Mar 07
I'm sorry you feel that way. But if the time comes when I will have children, I'll let them believe in Santa Clause. And if somebody tells them that he's not real and asks me about it. I'll just tell them that He is real and that He is St. Nicholas and he started the spirit of giving. It's not necessarily deceiving. There's always a good lie and there's a bad lie. I don't really think that you should always expose your child to the truth. There are some things in this world that needn't be told a child---not yet anyway. It's always important to shield their innocence. I guess you feel strongly about it because as you have said, your parents hit you and always lies to you. But if you introduce Santa to them in a loving and trusting environment, when your child eventually finds out it's not real, he'll know that it's not a lie and he'll appreciate the fact that he believed in Santa. He'll always treasure that magical feeling he has when he was a kid whenever Christmas comes around. That anticipation that Santa is coming. I know for a fact that I appreciate my parents doing that and I don't hold it against them that I was disappointed when I didn't get the bike or that they "lied" because the fact remains that I loved and will always love Christmas because of Santa. :)
1 person likes this
• United States
19 Mar 07
I think I was about 8. I remember being told he wasn't real by a trusted friend, and how disappointed I was. Some part of me believes he is real to this day.
2 people like this
@meguchan (181)
• Spain
19 Mar 07
I think i was very very young, but I no remember exactly the age, I never cryed for that.
2 people like this
• India
19 Mar 07
i knew it from the beginning that these were all stories
2 people like this
• China
20 Mar 07
Hehe, I learnt Santa Clause wasn't real the day I got to know him, because I lived in the country when Santa Clasuse is not recoganized. But I have always been dreamming of enjoying presents from Santa Clause. Children should have such kind of joy. That is the color of their coloful childhood. You learnt that Santa Clause was not real very late. That means you enjoyed more than others of the pretty tale.
1 person likes this
• Singapore
20 Mar 07
I totally agree. The later a child finds out that Santa isn't really just means that he got to enjoy that magical feeling more. I envy that.
1 person likes this
@neon2000 (2756)
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
I found out that santa is not real when I was already a young adult and I understand even if he is not real. There is no bitterness because when I was still young, it makes me happy about the story of santa claus. It's what makes the children happy. Someday they will accept too that santa is for children.
@5000ml (1923)
• Belgium
20 Mar 07
I think I was about 10. I don't remember exactly how I found out, it might have been an older kid that told us, but I definitely don't remember being upset about it. I had already started thinking that he wasn't real, anyway.
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Mar 07
I was a gullible child as was my sister. I was about 10, so my sister 7 when we figured it out on our own he wasnt real. My cousins brought up to NOT believe used to tease us about hearing Santa coming. So I was at Target one day when I was young, and saw after Christmas something that I had gotten from Santa. And my mind thought about it, why would there be a "Candy toy" from santa at a store? So I realized he wasnt real. My mom likes to play up the santa thing each christmas giving us candy still but we know at this point its her :))
1 person likes this
@LeYaHaNn (100)
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
i discoverd that santa clause is not real when i was 10 years old. It was Crhristmas time and i put my socks in the window and i saw my dad puting something in the sock. I only remember these incident maybe 7 months ago when my dad got drunk and asking that " who discovered santa clause"? i told him "that was me"
1 person likes this
@cherinai (65)
• Philippines
20 Mar 07
i was six yrs old then when i found out that santa claus wasnt real..i was kind of dissapoited because in movies he allotted most of his time sending gifts to children..walking tip toed..then came one christmas that i asked for a barbie doll..but what i found in my big socks was lots of chocolate coins..i just eat them though. now that i had a two-year old son..i still wanted to tell him stories about santa clause..for him to experience some excitement on every christmas..
1 person likes this
@neglitex (347)
• Latvia
20 Mar 07
WHAT!?!?! Santa isn't real?......ok ok :) , I was about 7 or 8 years old, although I already had suspicion....it was hard to believe it! Still, I think I'm over it and can live my life normally again! :)
1 person likes this