Haley in American Idol

I agree with you 100%. Ive been thinking that since her audition. Simon made the mistake of telling her, "she is somebody who doesnt think she can sing, but that she truly can sing." She has been milking that facial expression since day one... I think shes a good singer, but her faking being sweet is starting to get a little annoying.

Haley was much better tonight. She's really starting to shine. I don't think she'd do well on Grease, though. Laura and Ashley can sing. They have amazing voices. I just don't think that Haley compares. Actually, I think she'll only last a couple more weeks. Maybe she'll surprise us though.

yes i agree,littletoad.i think she could go further on grease you're the one that i want rather than american idol.