Who is your favorite American Idol judge?

I really like Simon. Sometimes, like in the real industry, people aren't nice to you. Not only does he seemingly prepare you for that, but he's usually right. I think that he's got the ability to remain objective, something that I think Randy and Paula have problems with at times, and he will never let you go without knowing exactly how he thinks you did. Paula is all over the place, and Randy sometimes doesn't say what he's really thinking. He's also quick to recant sometimes or focus on meaningless positives.

Its Simon of course! He can be really mean at times but he is always says the right thing. And did I tell you I cant stand Paula Abdul? She tries to be someone she is not. Randy is not bad at all!

I like Paula the best myself although you are right she does like to sugarcoat things.

I think my favorite would be Paula. I know she sugar coats things a lot, but I think she helps to bring positive feedback and help the contestants feel better even if they did horrible. She seems to always have something nice to say, and I really like that about her.