Engagement Rings
By carpenter5
@carpenter5 (6782)
United States
March 22, 2007 8:12pm CST
My daughter's boyfriend plans to give her the engagement ring that's been passed down from his grandmother to his mother, and now to him.
I have a friend that's appalled and said she wouldn't take that "old" thing?
I think she's wrong and the sentimental value is worth far more than the monetary value. Besides which it's a 1/2 carat diamond solitaire set in white gold! The ring is gorgeous!!!!
What do you think....NEW...or family heirloom?
7 people like this
45 responses
@smrrdn (62)
• United States
23 Mar 07
I would much rather have a family heirloom than a new ring. When I turned 14 years old my parents gave me their very first "promise ring". It is not the prettiest and it is definately not worth very much now, but the sentimental value that it has makes it priceless to me. I think that if my boyfriend were to give me that kind of ring it would mean so much more than one he picked out at the store.
4 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
My daughter thought so too. He gave it to her last Friday night, and she loves telling everyone that it was his mother's.
@Rosepetal (352)
• United States
23 Mar 07
A ring isn't important -- The love behind it is.
4 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
You are exactly right. I have a real peace that Hunter loves my daughter with all of his heart.
@KrauseHome (36447)
• United States
23 Mar 07
Wow... I think most women would be pleased to have a Family heirloom like that that has been passed down it is nice. I know some want New, but there are a lot of people this would not matter too. And a lot of times, when appraised because they are so old, these Rings are valued higher too. If I was your Daughter I would wear this ring proudly, and not worry about what others say. If she is Happy and Loves the man she is with then that is all that should count.
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
Friday night when he proposed, she looked at the ring, through her tears, and held out her hand for him to put it on. Then, she looked at it, and said. "Wait, I've seen this ring before." When she made the connection, she just burst into tears, and hugged his mother.
@GardenGerty (160883)
• United States
23 Mar 07
Give me the family heirloom anytime. Just think what the ring could tell you if it could talk. He has a family that obviously values connectedness, and values him and his choice. Economically it is a wise move as well. Rings of that type run about $1000, at least. I hope they get it appraised and insured. I would treasure him, for trusting my daughter with a family treasure.
3 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
The ring is a simple 1/4 carat round solitaire in white gold. But it is absolutely beautiful. Very understated and classy. Kristen has small fingers and it just looks great on her hand. And she loves it...and the young man who gave it to her.
@kancil (43)
• Malaysia
23 Mar 07
I think is ok to receive the ring. Sentimental value as you said. And is good to continue the tradition of passing down value things, ring, neckless ect or your culture's..so that the new generation will always honour , respect the value things in our life. :)
3 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
I agree with you totally. I have a pair of earrings that were my mother in law's and I cherish them above even those that are more expensive.
@ihearttinytim (614)
• United States
26 Apr 08
Well, for God's sake, don't allow what happened to me, to happen to your daughter. My boyfriend (at the time) proposed with his grandmother's ring. Three days later, he asked to have it back and promised me he would buy me a ring to replace it, but that his mom wanted it back because she didn't trust me with it. Come to find out, his mom had been talking with a friend of hers, and told him to get it back from me because she thought that if we ever broke up, I wouldn't return it. However, she only came to this conclusion after talking to that friend of hers, who had never met me before. His mother was already jealous of me, and was always thinking poorly of me. She had to have known I wasn't that type of person - but she never gave me a chance. If I would have kept the grandmother's ring, that would make me a thief, and I'm no thief! I would have gladly returned it. I wasn't really all that thrilled with it to begin with, but because I loved him, the look of the ring didn't really matter. Well, needless to say I was upset and angry - both at her, for Indian giving (allowing him to use the ring to propose then wanting - and taking - it back), and mad at him for being such a momma's boy, and for not taking the time to pick out a ring for me, himself, from the heart. Months later, my mother loaned us a bigger (and prettier) ring to use until he could buy me one. He never held up to his promise. (He didn't have to get me such a big expensive ring - a diamond ring, yes, but not a BIG HONKER). He failed to realize this about me. We also argued a lot. He was always picking fights with me and blaming me for things, and calling me a liar, and swearing I was cheating on him, etc. (He was jealous and abusive). A year later from that, he decides that he "doesn't know if this is what he wants" and asks me to move out, and gave me one week to do so. You can imagine how crushed I was.
I was in the middle of packing my things and had only one more day left before I had to be out of there when he told me to stay. I'm sorry I didn't continue packing and tell him, "you blew it," but I didn't. Like a fool, I stayed and took more abuse from him and his family - mostly his mother and older sister. Finally, a year later, *I BROKE IT OFF* and it's been good riddance ever since!
@lacurandera (335)
• United States
23 Mar 07
I think it says a lot about how the boyfriend feels about your daughter. He must love her very much to entrust her with such an old, precious family heirloom. I agree with you that the sentiment far outweighs the monetary value. Your friend sounds a little materialistic. I think it's really sweet of him to trust her enough to give her something that has been passed through generations in his family.
4 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
Kristen said the same thing to Hunter on Friday night. I wish everyone could have seen her face when she realized that it was the family engagement ring!
@whimsystoryteller (1743)
• United States
23 Mar 07
You must really be young because for centuries passing down an heirloom to a new bride is an honor. If you don't appreciate the past, you will have a hard time learning from it and are likely to make the same mistakes over and over. Tradition is a big part of people's lives. If you don't understand that, what have you got to give to the next generation?
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
that is part of what is wrong with our younger generations. They have forgotten why family is important. My daughter accepted the heirloom and now wears it proudly as of last Friday night.
@gewcew23 (8007)
• United States
11 Apr 07
I think that it is wonderful that he wants to give her a family heirloom. I would rather have something like that instead of new if it was available. If he didn't have it and went to an antique shop or something that might be different, but it is an heirloom. I think your friend has very high and stuck up taste, (NO Offense) But I think it is sweet that he wants to give it to her.
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
16 Apr 07
By the way...she has the ring, and it looks absolutely gorgeous on her little hand!
@danishcanadian (28955)
• Canada
23 Mar 07
If it's important to them, and sentimental, it should not matter one bit. I think it's a sweet idea, but it's not for everyone. If it works for the people who are receiving the ring, that's all that should matter to the rest of the world.
3 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
It's amazing how many people want to give you their opinion, even when you don't ask for it you know? After I wrote this discussion question, I got to thinking more about it, and the only thing that kept coming to mind was "How dare she?"
ANd I agree with you Canada...it was very sweet.
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
Her words to Hunter's mom on Friday night after he proposed were:
"I can't believe you love me enough to give me your ring".
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
that's the way we feel. That she has been totally accepted by his family, enough to trust her with the ring, says alot about the love Hunter and his parents have for our daughter.
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
23 Mar 07
I think its up to the person.....i personally LOVE history and antiques and old things. I love to think of the hands that have touched the things I own...
In fact my engagement/wedding rings were made (brand new) to look very old... but thats just me
btw, ring sounds awesome!!
2 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
The ring is beautiful, and her face just lights up every time she looks down at her finger. I'd love to see a picture of your rings. They sound awesome.
@camery (26)
• Philippines
23 Mar 07
I think you its an honor instead to be given such ring. A thing as what it is passed on from generations to generations is a treasure to keep. Along with it carries the trust of the guy's whole clan. Honey focus on how those people treasured it so much and you will be more blessed.
A diamond can never be a treasure unless someone recognizes its value. So whether its a gold, silver or a diamond ring you received and no matter how old it is its how you value the thing. If your guy valued it so much and he gives it to you it means a lot gurl. :)
2 people like this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
My daughter agrees with you. She accepted the ring and now wears it proudly!
@sloanjosiecat79 (299)
• United States
15 Apr 07
my sister's engagement ring is also a family heirloom. i think it's a sweet idea. and for all practical purposes not everyone can afford to spend one month's salary on a ring.
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
16 Apr 07
I know. Hunter came home from the mall one afternoon right after they started talking about getting married, and told me that the salesperson had told them that he needed to spend 2 months salary on her engagement ring. I told him that was ridiculous! She'd be afraid to wear it!
@gewcew23 (8007)
• United States
11 Apr 07
I think that it is wonderful that he wants to give her a family heirloom. I would rather have something like that instead of new if it was available. If he didn't have it and went to an antique shop or something that might be different, but it is an heirloom. I think your friend has very high and stuck up taste, (NO Offense) But I think it is sweet that he wants to give it to her.
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
16 Apr 07
no offense taken I promise. She hasn't spoken to me in almost a month, after I told her to mind her own business.
I was afraid she would say something that would hurt my future son-in-law's feelings.
@wmg2006 (5381)
• United States
24 Mar 07
I really hope your friend is wrong, because I gave my son an engagement ring that my Mother gave to me. He gave it to his girlfriend who he married last year. His wife will never be able to meet my Mother, but she has talked to her on the phone. His wife has never even met me yet. They are in Holland and I am in the US. She was touched greatly by receiving this precious heirloom from a family she has never met and a grandmother she will never be able to meet.
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
I can imagine how precious she must feel. To have you love her enough..especially sight unseen to pass these down. Wow! What an awesome mother in law you are! So many mothers who have son's feel threatened by the girlfriends, and that's just not right in my opinion.
@Foxxee (3651)
• United States
24 Mar 07
I would rather have a ring that meant something. Engagement rings are not all about looks, it's about the sentimental value, like you stated.
I mean it's an engagement ring, I'm sure he will pick something for the actual wedding band when the time comes, but for now, the engagement ring that he has had in his family is the best and has actual value.
And to me, the white gold is the best. I love white cold.
And it shouldn't matter what anyone else thinks anyway, if she loves it, then who cares what anyone thinks.
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
I agree. One of the most treasured items I own is a pair of tiny diamond earrings that my inlaws gave me on my wedding day.
@breepeace (3014)
• Canada
23 Mar 07
I think that's beautiful!
Too many woman nowadays put emphasis on getting rings that are uber expensive just to show how much their beau loves them. That doesn't demonstrate it at all. I think getting an heirloom really demonstrates the love and acceptance and is a lot more personal than spending thousands on a ring from a jewellers.
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
I agree. Spending two months salary on a ring, and then not having the money to drive the hour that they live apart to see her, would have been ridiculous. Plus, it showed my daughter how much she was loved, not just by Hunter, but by his entire family.
@vebela (310)
• United States
28 Mar 07
Personally, I agree with you. The sentimental value really is worth more than the monetary, and it would mean a lot to me to receive a family heirloom from my husband's family.
Right now, both my engagement and wedding rings are family heirlooms. I feel so honored that his family wanted me to have these rings, instead of my husband's sisters.
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
I'm laughing at your post...but only because my youngest daughter has begun a relationship with the brother of the other daughter's fiancee. (did I explain that right?)
I am wondering what they are going to do with Seth and Lauren should they end up together...because there is not another ring...lol
@DeaXyza (577)
• United States
23 Mar 07
Wish I had something passed on to me from the older generation! It has so much history attached to it.... A Ring that would tell their family history, so much warmth and love that has got passed down, the blessings that must have been bestowed upon it. I also see it as a great amount of faith that the boy has in your daughter to trust her with such a responsiblity, he must truly cherish your daughter to give her the family treasure!
I don't know why your friend remarked this way. But truly blessed is your daughter as the family she would become a part of trusts and loves her this much!
My take Family heirloom wins hands down there can never be any competition to it new or old.
And hey Congratulations mom!
1 person likes this
@carpenter5 (6782)
• United States
5 Apr 07
My "friend" and I am using this term loosly at this point, is all about money, and what's in it for me. She even had the audacity to tell me that she wanted to be able to say, my god-daughter got a ring that was ___ carats and costs over $___.
It had nothing to do with Kristen or Hunter, but her need to feel important.