How are you coping with Michigan's failing economy?

United States
March 23, 2007 8:55am CST
I've lived here - all over the state - my entire life and never seen it so bad. I think it was last year that there were a record number of people who moved out of the state due to the economy and lack of work. The unemployment office has reported about 600,000 people registered for and seeking work, with only about 20,000 jobs available - being mostly military and sales positions. I've been forced to find alternative ways to support my family after losing two jobs within two years due to company cutbacks and closings. Since 2003 I have supported my family (as a divorced mom) from working online. Are you considering moving out of state? Do you think things will improve anytime soon? How bad is it in your area? How are you coping? Do you think a change in leadership is the answer?
4 people like this
6 responses
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
31 Mar 07
I grew up in Michigan and my parents had to move back in the 80's when they had the real bad economy fall then. My mom was a teacher and she couldn't get a job at the time due to the cut backs. I can imagine how it is now. I know others I've talked to who live up there still are having a really hard time making ends meet and to support themselves. They have been talking about moving but the problem comes in cost of moving. It's not that easy to find a job out of state let alone have the money saved up enough to support yourself while you move. We have that problem here in Florida as well. Unless you have something waiting for you it's not easy to just leave. Sounds easy but it sure isn't. That being said though if I was offered the chance to move to an area where I could support myself easier I would jump at it. I just don't want to jump out of the frying pan and into the fire. I'd want to have some assurances before taking that leap.
@kelly60 (4547)
• United States
19 Apr 07
I live in a rural area of Michigan. The jobs here do not pay much, mostly starting out at minimum wage, but the cost of living is not as high as it is in many areas either. Living in areas where the cost of living is higher may make it necessary to have a higher paying job, so it only makes sense that the opposite will be true if you can find a home where the cost of living is lower, you can afford to take a job that pays less. In addition, one job per family may not be enough to support an expensive lifestyle, but if you are not afraid to live a more simplistic lifestyle, it is not nearly so bad. Many of us grow our own gardens, some raise livestock, or go hunting or fishing. All of these things help to supplement the income because any food that does not have to be bought is money saved.
• United States
28 Apr 07
Sorry I haven't been back here in a while, thank you for your helpful response! Yes, there are areas where cost of living is a little lower than average in the state and there are many ways to make cuts - take jobs that require less travel time and gas, etc. We eat a lot of venison - thanks to our neighbor. Luckily my oldest is a cook so he can make it taste just like beef steaks, LOL. Raising meat and poultry (for meat or eggs), I have found, is much more expensive than just buying it by the quarter or half...unless you also are growing their feed and have the equipment to harvest it.
1 person likes this
@kelly60 (4547)
• United States
4 May 07
I do not raise livestock anymore, but I used to raise chickens, ducks and geese. In addition to the feed we bought for them, they loved be turned loose to feed from the yard, or to be given a few leftover veggies from supper. Venison is one of my favorite meals, and although my boys are not much for hunting, my dad or my brother help me out with some venison when I start running low. My boys like to fish though, and will go every chance they get. I have my gardens where I grow my vegetables and berries, and my fruit trees. I love my fresh vegetables, and if we have more than we can eat, they are usually frozen for later use. Last year I planted a strawberry patch too, so this year I should have a nice crop of strawberries in June. I also planted a long row of raspberries along my fence so I should have some berries there this year too. I generally get a nice crop of apples too. All of these things may not be enough to feed my family, but they sure help us to get through the hard times, and I am afraid there will be many more hard times coming with the gas prices jumping as much as they have over the past couple of days.
@the_vicar (1477)
• United States
12 May 07
Maybe you could ask Mitt Romney for a handout...it appears he has millions.....why do so few have so much when the economy is hurting. Or maybe the economy is hurting because so few have so much.
@sigma77 (5383)
• United States
29 Apr 07
I have lived here all my life too. I am trying to work online, but not by selling. I keep hearing how bad the job scene is this state, but I haven't been looking for employment. I am not planning on moving out of state. But it is a possibilty. Will a change in leadership change Michigan? I don't think so. We have been an automotive based state for over 100 years and we have missed the global tidal wave of automotive innovation and progress. We have been to slow to bring in a diversified industrial base. My work, what I am trying to do online, does not depend on the economy. I could make money in a depression. I like a lot of places in this state. I have also traveled to dozens of other states. But if everyone is moving away, I just might stay here. I don't care to go where everyone else is going. lol. Hope you find a way to prosper. The economy doesn't really matter, it is up to you to make it work.
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Apr 07
Very well said! Last time I checked there were 600,000 people registered for and seeking work through the Michigan unemployment office, with only 20,000 jobs listed available (mostly sales and military). I also work online and have supported my family that way since 2003 after losing two jobs within two years way back when...both auto related. I worked in a transmission shop diagnosing, tearing down, cleaning parts, and assisting in rebuilding transmissions, and also sold auto parts at another store. Both could not afford to pay workers anymore. That is when I decided to "design my own life" independent from traditional employers. I do not do a home business or "business opportunity" either. It isn't my thing, and I'm not good at that. I am not sure if I will be staying here, but if I leave it will not be due to the economy. That's a huge plus about working from home, I can move my job wherever I go! :)
@EvanHunter (4026)
• United States
8 Jun 07
The job situation in michigan just plain sucks. I dont think the jobs will ever come back only possibility of that ever happening is if mexico and china fall into the oceans. The state has always been heavily dominated with industrial jobs and with nafta and all the big corporations moving production over seas it has hurt michigans economy big time. The only thing that seems to have held up was the real estate market. I predict that its gona head down hill fast. I dont see how they can still be building so much residential housing and the prices of realestate keep going up like it has with the job markets being so bad.
• United States
8 Jun 07
Evan, good points...actually the realtors and closing agents I know around the state say that property is stagnant. The "movement" is happening mostly through foreclosures, not through sales. Here there are new customer service jobs coming in (via WalMart, Menards, Lowes, etc, etc) but the reality is, they do not pay enough to survive on - young people are not the ones getting the jobs (too many skilled workers are fighting for these minimal pay jobs) AND I don't think they will last since many consumers around here cannot afford much besides the most bare necessities, and even then it is a toss up between paying the gas company so you can cook and get showers, or paying for food...or between having car insurance versus paying your mortgage/rent payment.
• United States
8 Nov 07
I know of many college students who are seriously considering moving out because they can't get jobs. The only reason holding them in michigan is the "in-state tuition". Many students are just getting buy working for minimum wage or a little bit above if they are lucky enough to have a job in this failing economy. Two of my room mates have applied for over 50 some entry level jobs in the past few months but still can't get in. It's crazy.