How do you determine right and wrong?
By mamasan34
@mamasan34 (6518)
United States
March 27, 2007 7:45am CST
Do you think the ability to determine right and wrong is taught? I was watching a show about a serial killer who was brought up in a nice loving home and was taught right and wrong and still he killed. I saw another one that the young man was beaten and was not loved and he killed. So, what is the answer? Are we taught right and wrong or is it just inherited?
1 person likes this
3 responses
@bluewings (3857)
•
27 Mar 07
I think it's a bit of both,the upbringing and the genes.I read a story quite similar to the event you described.There were two brothers living in a family where they didn't have one happy momory.Their father would come drunk and beat up their mother and both the kids.They would be punished for faults they never committed.The only refuge they had was their school and even there they were teased about their parents.Time passed and both of them grew up to become different individuals.One became a diplomat for his country ,cultured ,sophisticated and a true gentleman.The other was an utter failure ,drinking his way to oblivion.When a study was done on the diplomat and his family ,they questioned both the brothers separately.The diplomat narrated the conditions in which they were brought up and asked " How could I have been any different than I am "? The other brother also narrated the miseries of his childhood and asked "How could I have been any different than I am " ?
I think a lot of us become what we do inspite of our positive influences and upbringing and a lot of us also become what we do despite of our upbringing.It depends on what we choose to see.
@bluewings (3857)
•
28 Mar 07
True,I too think perseverance ,patience and determination help a lot.Perhaps even faith helps combined with these help.
1 person likes this
@mamasan34 (6518)
• United States
27 Mar 07
Yes I see what you mean. This is typical of my father and his brother. They were born to a dirt poor family and for some reason my grandfather beat my dad over all of the kids. It didn't matter what he did, he did it wrong. My uncle was the golden boy though. He was Papa's favorite. He grew up to be very successful and they live a comfortable life. My father is not so successful but he lives a good life. So, if anyone I thought would grow up to be bad I thought it would be my dad but he overcame obstacles to become a good person still. I guess perseverence also helps!
1 person likes this
@serioushacker (121)
• India
27 Mar 07
Make sure that the facts broadcasted on that show are true enough to believe. In case of the ability to decide whether something is wrong or right is by birth. As a child we can better tell what is wrong or what is right rather than grown ups! I'd advise you to read bible, the best book on earth about the benefits of good and losses of bad. It will CHANGE YOUR LIFE FOREVER!!!
1 person likes this
@gegegelay (933)
• Philippines
27 Mar 07
I agree with serioushacker. Ever since the world began, God already gave us the wisdom to distinguish right from wrong. The Bible states everything that you have to know. It will change your perspective in life. God is your only answer.
@mamasan34 (6518)
• United States
27 Mar 07
Thanks for that! My father was a minister for many years so I am familiar with the bible, LOL. But I see what you are saying. Sometimes I think that some of these "serial killers" are missing something genetically that would cause them to not have the conscience to be able to comprehend right and wrong, or is it that they just don't care? Thanks for the comments guys!
1 person likes this
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
27 Mar 07
I think that we all have a moral compasss engraved upon our hearts...but, environment and other outside influences can either enhance and re-enforce our values o f right and wrong, or likewise they can "help" to subdue our compunction and desensitize us to the whispering of our conscience to where it is no longer heeded.
1 person likes this
@mamasan34 (6518)
• United States
27 Mar 07
This is a good way of explaining it. I have seen people raised to be one way, and when they are in a different environment they become desensitized to another way of life. Thanks for adding that.
1 person likes this