hello this is Q for indian And other who know about it ?

Classics cannot be repeated. Classics are written or picturised with the current taste of readers/audience in mind. another version of the same can be a different one suiting to the taste of different generation but cannot be as good as the original. Take the case of Parineeta. Bimal roy was a bengali director and understood the naunces of the story. Asok kumar was a bengali and could act as a bengali gentleman. The house hold atmosphere was depicted exactly as it was in Bengal at the time when the story was taking place it was authentic and realistic with most of the songs in typical bengali tunes. I enjoyed that picture very much. I saw the new version of Saifali Khan and vidhya Balan. They acted well and music was pleasing to the ears and became popular. But the entire background of the picture was set in middle part of 20th century. Things had changed a great deal by that time. So the very essence and innocence captured by Bimal roy was absent in the new version. So it will be in the case of Sholay 11nd Such characters do not exist now. Chambal dacoits have become lieutinents of politicians or they themselves are standing for elction.They have mobile phones and AK47.

there is a chemistry for all creations! do you thinksomeone can paint monalisa once more? i am an indian classical fan myself and have attended a few concerts by maestros like pandit jasraj and his like. it has happened that the same raga was sung twice by the same peformer and there was a vast difference between the two performances. even the performer himslf admits so! the thing that remakes are made proves that the remaker has no confidence in himself to be creative! if he claims to make the remake better than the original it is hoax!

hi amar wasup dear,heyy i lke srk and whatever he does i kinda always like him so liked don and yes waiting for sholay lets see what rgv does to it he is a good director.