Haley's gone home... Should it have been Phil?

It was a good call by the American Public. Phil has been horrible as of late, but Haley only had 1 good performance. Sanjaya still needs to go.

I think it was the right choice for Haley to go home. She is definitely not as great as the other female singers. I like Phil (maybe because he is from my city & state!). But he will probably be the next to go since he has been in the bottom three for the past few weeks. I'm still confused about why Sanjaya is there... There have been a lot of great singers go home while he continues to stay. Hopefully he will be leaving soon. I sure hope so!!

I think it was the right choice. Phil is not far behind. Sanjaya should be but it looks like we are stuck with him.

I did not see it last night either. I do not understand why Chris is in the bottom three. I liked the clip they showed, and I have liked him on most every show. I do think he should not have been there.

I am just glad one of them went home..so Phil is okay to go next week I hope ( of course I really want it to be Sanjaya but he has many fooled into believing that it isn't about singing..but then he's so smart he dropped out of high school and took the GED...great careet booster.) Haley had a very limited vocal ability..and this was about as far as she would go..not to say she won't make some strides in the future and be a recording personality. Sorry to be so hard on Sanjaya but I am really bothered by the fact that he is so proud of dropping out of school and then wants to be a recording personality which equates to a role model...and so many children are exposed to that fact and begin to believe an education is not important when it's the most important thing they can do for themselves...

I actually watched her performance on Tuesday (a well as previous weeks) and thought she deserved to go home as it wasn't that good. Phil should be kicked off next, and Sanjaya...well, he should have been kicked off of American Idol a long time ago. Even though his performance was better this past Tuesday, it's not up to par to what an American Idol singer is all about.

I think that Phil should have gone home tonight. Haley is a much better singer thatn he is. I hope that Simon's comment about her clothes did not change the way people voted for her. God bless Haley she is a good singer and she will go far in whatever she does.

I think Haley should have gone home a couple of weeks ago. But, I also think Phil should be going home, too. I have given up on hoping Sanjaya will go...LOL He's just too darn popular. LOL Haley wasn't bad last night...I don't think she's ever bad, but she isn't that great either. Same with Phil...he's a good singer, just not up to par with the others.