hey who's the future star for MANU....Carrick or Smith???

My opinion is that Carrick is the future star of The Devils. He's young and healthy at the moment, not injuries or other problems. Playing nice and prospered football. Smith is a proved footballer. His skills had been shown till he was playing in Leeds. He is a great footballer too and I wish him to be more titular in the team. Regards.

welllllllll as far as the current form is concerned...man u is going red hot.........and there is probably no one that could stop their rampage. welllll for man u each player has been contributing to the teams success......and wellll it was a surprise to see smith score.........who's carrier was in doubt due to injury........wellll for me carrick is the man.....he's is gonna be a great superstar....the two goals against roma was top class.

I would say carrick.He is one of the best younger player who is now at the field.He is really going to be good asset to the manu team.Along with Ronaldo,smith and other younger players he is going to bring up a good revolution in the manu team.They going to win more matches in good margins with all these young talented players being in to.

Carrick seems to be a super midfielder who can orchestrate ManU's attacks...a guy to watch out for the future...love smith's committment

I think Michael Carrick will be the future star for Man Utd.. As right now.. i think no one can do a better job than him in Man Utd and he certainly mix well with the rest of the team.. Consider that he only join Man Utd this season.. As of Smith.. unless he dont get injured more often.. and grab the chance well when Saha or Rooney is not available.. He will be the future star too.. but i think Alex Ferguson will be looking for a well established striker when the transfer window start..

I think carrick becouse carrick is good midfilder and MANU always search for good midfielders ex. David Becham or Christian Ronaldo, MANU knows how to train midfielders :D

I say Carrick Because I saw his great performance this season. Smith is shown yet his performance this season because his injured problem isn't it ?

Yeah, they both have great potential, but I if I had to choose between the both of them I'd say Carrick. You can't deny that Smith is an excellent striker on his good days, but he doesn't seem to have that killer instinct when they need it the most. Besides, As far as being the future star of ManU I think that either Rooney or Ronaldo could be the next Cantana.