favourite judge and why?

I agree! Simon is the best! Besides the fact that he is a hottie he just tells it like it is. At least you don't have to worry about him lying to you!! lol. I do feel bad for the people that he makes me comments to (especially the ones during the auditions) but those people knew what they were getting themselves into. I can't sing and I know that. So I definitely wouldn't go on there and act like I can and get upset when they tell me I can't! lol. I don't know what is wrong with some of these people out there.

I like Simon best, too. Randy is always annoying with his "Yo, Dawg!" Paula is always like she's on something... Simon is always for real, he's honest, he doesn't act goofy like the other judges, he makes me laugh, he interests me, and it seems I always agree with him and not the other judges.

That is an easy one- Randy drives me crazy with the "dog" remarks-- all the time.. It really makes him look unprofessional and silly. Paula mimicks Randy in what he says- You were pitchy- says Randy- Paula-- I have to agree you were pitchy at points. That was great says Randy- Pauls says You gave me chills- Think for yourself Paula. I too Love Simon! He livens up the show- The contenders know all about Simon- so if they cannot deal with the criticism- don't try out for Idol. He keeps it real and makes me laugh at all once. I have to admit-- When I think someone did a great job-- alot of the times SImon says- That was just dreadful! Good thing I'm not a judge!

My favorite idol judge is Simon Cowell. I like his honesty when he gives out his comments. I also believe his statements are helpful in improving the singing of the idol contestants.

Of course Simon. He also can admit if he made wrong comments, that usually other people can't do. I several times saw that Simon said, "I'm sorry if I judge you before about bla bla bla... but today you prove that bla bla bla...", that's a very sportive attitude. He also dry honest, dry humorous person, and I think he also not easy to get mad even people always judge him about the rudeness (he will get mad maybe after several uncontrol situations) well that means that he is quite patience person although he is always complain but also can accept the condition.

Simon, the best judge i've ever seen. He always said the truth, some people said that he is so cruel but basically he is nice guy and always said what he thinking about.