Freedom Of Speech

@Rozie37 (15499)
Turkmenistan
April 15, 2007 6:12pm CST
This is one of those things that is constantly being discussed in one form or another. I decided today that I would try to think on how I feel about this subject. This may sound like a contradiction, but I feel that freedom of speech, like every other kind of freedom should have it's limits. America is considered a free country, but just because that is the case, doesn't mean that one should be able to do and say whatever they want without consequences. A person should have to think twice before offending a large group of people. Anyone who speaks in the publics hearing should be censored nad that includes actors, singers, news journalists, and anybody else that I have left out. I believe that there is a point where one persons freedom, takes away another persons freedom and that is why there hast to be a set standard or this world will become increasingly chaotic.
6 people like this
11 responses
@clary21 (54)
• United States
16 Apr 07
Rozie37, I hardly know how to respond to some of your beliefs. You say that freedom of speech should have limits. How can an individual think twice before offending others when he/she does not know they will be offended? I think intention must be a part of it. Was there intent to offend others, or was it an accident? How can there be freedom of speech when we have to constantly feel like we are walking around on eggshells? I say things without realizing what it means, and when someone explains to me what it sounds like, to them, I apologize and say that is not what I meant. Sometimes the English language makes it hard for us to communicate effectively in this country, and that is why we need more discussions. What is in an individual's heart is sometimes not what others hear coming out of his/her mouth.
3 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
16 Apr 07
Do you think that Don Imus meant to offend African Americans and women when he made the comments that he made? Do you think that rappers mean to offend women when they call women the things that they do? Do you like to hear women being referred to like that when you are out taking care of your business? Some people really don't mind, but for some of us, it is a offensive and it needs to be stopped. Just because you have a certain talent does not mean that you can use it any way you see fit. And they get paid for this crap. While our young girls are growing up thinking that this is what they are and calling each other that. There hast to be a limit to what people are allowed to speak in public. If there is not, things are going to get worse and I have known of people getting killed for less.
2 people like this
@Stiletto (4579)
16 Apr 07
I think it's very dangerous when we contemplate restricting freedom of speech because it offends a large group of people. I agree that there sometimes comes a point where one person exercising their freedom can impinge on another persons freedom but offending someone is not taking away their freedom. If we have freedom of speech then surely the offended party has a right of reply? As for the suggestion that anyone speaking in the publics hearing should be censored my first question would be who does the censoring? Who decides what is and isn't appropriate for the public to hear? Personally as an intelligent adult I prefer to decide for myself what I want to hear about and if something offends me (and many things do) then I'll exercise my right to freedom of speech to speak out about it.
3 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
16 Apr 07
I believe that offending someone does take away their freedom. When I am walking down the street, I want to be free to not hear a song referring to women in a rude way. Therefore I feel that there should be a law saying that that kind of music should be freely played in the privacy of your own homes. Just like there is a law in my city (at least) that you can not smoke at the bus stop. This gives me the freedom to be able to stand or sit at the bus stop and not have my lungs polluted. However, it takes away the freedom of the person who wants to smoke where ever they please. Non censorship says that words don't hurt. Just like the Rutgers basketball team was her by the offensive things that Don Imus said. Not only that, he offended an entire race. His hated and everyone elses needs to censored from affecting the masses. Public figures need to start taking responsibility for what they do and say. Just like the situation where Janet Jackson had the "Wardrobe Malfunction," I don't believe that the stations should have been fined for that at all. She that money should have come from her pocket, whether she did it on purpose or not. She should not have taken a chance like that. Didn't she have enough common sense to consider that this could happen. And don't get me wrong, I am a fan of Janet, but wrong is wrong. The station had no idea she was going to pull a stunt like that, yet they were punished for it.
2 people like this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
16 Apr 07
Good morning Rozie37, You've certainly openned a dialogue on a very important topic. Being open to hearing other's perspectives on such a cherished freedom as speech remains as important today as it was 231 years ago, when The Founding Father's penned the Declaration of Independence. For generations, American children grew up with the verse: "Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words can never hurt me." I know I recited it when other children may have teased or taunted me. As I'm sure most American kids did. The power behind those words is monumental. Endowing ourselves and our children with the inner strength to not be affected in the face of another's insensitivities is fundamental in not only preserving the principles of free speech, but also in creating true diversity. How can we, as a nation, tackle the big issues if we're so hypersenstized to something as insignificant as one mans thoughts or statements, regardless of how inappropriate they might be? Some may not like hearing this, but it's the truth: Censorship is a necessary tool used by fascist's. Those who wish to rule and dominate. Censorship is not a principle cherished by democracies or representative republics. We cannot have a free society if a segment of the culture is controlling what can and cannot be said. The tides of governance will always shift. Meaning that representatives will be elected into and out of office. If we empower the current electorate to begin censoring speech today, what happens when representatives that hold contrary views to our own are elected tomorrow? The reason why this nation has succeeded is because despite the winds of change in our electorate, the principles to which they are bound do not change. If we start messing with that now, then this will no longer be America, "The home of the free and the land of the brave".
2 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
16 Apr 07
I just don't see America as a success. Yes, it is better than any other country that I am aware of, but does that really make it a success. I really believe that there is such a thing as too much freedom and in my opinion, America is well on it's way to proving that. With abortion, homosexuality, hatred,(both overt and covert) and all the other things that we know in our heart is wrong. In my opinion, America is going to hell in a hand basket, and most of us down even seem to care.
1 person likes this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
16 Apr 07
Hi Rozie, What would have to change in America for you to see it as a success? And, how would you suggest we enact such changes by means of amendment of government, rather than a paradigm shift in the thinking of mankind as a whole?
2 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
16 Apr 07
First of all, we call ourselves united and in a lot of ways we are, but not in some of the ways that we should be. Americans have taken the term "Looking Out For Number One," to an all new low. We need to stop this, that's not my problem and as long as I get mine before you get yours kind of attitude and learn to work together on every level of life. Not just in government and public where everyone is watching, but in our individual lives where there is no cameras and there is no one around to witness our goodness. We need to stop putting time and money into other countries and take care of home first. Our troops are over fighting and working to help Iraq, while South Central Los Angeles is falling apart at the seams because of crime and poverty. Just because there is no place greater, does not make this country great. We have gone completely over board with our so called freedoms. No one stands for what is right any longer. Everyone wants to be politically correct and do what everyone else is doing. This is not freedom. Freedom is doing and saying what you know to be right regardless of what others are doing and saying. We have become so ignorant in our freedom that we think that we can be free from the laws of God also. There has to be a standard and limits. In order for America to be truly free, there hast to be limits or we become a prisoner to all the sickness of sin.
@katzbee (91)
• Canada
17 Apr 07
I do think think that the term Freedom Of Speech, is greatly taken out of context especially by those people who see it as a forum to air their petty dislikes and their prejudices. Originally the act was written so the government of the day could not jail people for expressing their opinions especially if the opinions were different from the government. But today its really an umbrella that allows people to hide under.
@clary21 (54)
• United States
16 Apr 07
No, I do not believe that Don Imus meant to offend black women with the comments he made. And no, I do not believe that rappers mean to offend women, either, even though they constantly do it. It is the shock value they get from it. This morning I went out to buy some gas and a young black man drove up to the pumps with his windows open and his radio blaring with music where the musicians were saying the "N" word over and over. Under my breath, I said "Turn your stupid radio off!!" Hey, who are you to say how our young girls are thinking? You and I do not know what anyone is thinking until we ask him/her. There needs to be more open discussions to encourage communication in our society because, like I previously stated, the English language makes it hard to communicate. For example, the word read is in 2 tenses (present and past). Also, the Red Sea was once known as either the Reed Sea or Reid Sea (I can't remember which) because of the reeds or reids growing in it not because of the red color, even though it is red. Do you understand what I am saying? Even though I know what I mean, someone else may not and take it differently and that is what causes so many confrontations. I am not making excuses for anyone; I am only stating the problems that go along with freedom of speech. It is not that we should not have it, it is the fact that we need to know the meaning behind our words. We should question one another's intentions for better clarification. Better clarification leads to better communication on both sides.
2 people like this
• United States
16 Apr 07
i was actually talking about this in my public speaking course a few weeks ago we were talking about yelling out racial slurs in public in front of ppl that could get offended. personally i dont think its very mature for one to do that but i mean according to freedom of speech you can say whatever you want to buts I dont think it can be anything depending on the crowd thats around.
2 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
16 Apr 07
Read the Holy Bible. The chicken came first. God said two of every kind of animal was to go into the ark, not two of every egg. This is exactly why America is so screwed up. This just proves my point. Everyone wants to be wise in their on eyes and constantly question the truth. The wisdom of God is foolishness to the world and the wisedom of the world is foolishness to God. Pray for Godly wisedom.
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Apr 07
Yes, you may say whatever you want but not to anybody. Try calling a police officer a bad name and see if you do not land yourself in jail. And it is up to the crowd if they want to get offended or not. For example---when Al Sharpton called the poor white lady jogger that was beaten up in Central Park a wh---(expletive)most folks just ignore him. I realize that he was saying this about her only to gain attention to himself. It is too bad we have so many shock jocks in our country because it does nothing to help ease the tensions among our many different cultures.
2 people like this
@academic2 (7000)
• Uganda
16 Apr 07
Freedom of speech is typical of all countries that adhere to democratic principles. If the civil society organizations are seeing something terribly wrong that is taking place in the country, they usually use the principle to inform the people and the international community! In my country, there is alot of talk against arbitrary actions of government and usually radio talk shows smack of too much freedom of speech because those who speak do so a little beyond the limit. The good thing with this princile of free speech is that if you over speak, you face such charges as defamation, which means free speech must be exercised responsibly. So by and large it is a good idea to allow for free speech and free press-it builds democracy and improves civic competence!
1 person likes this
@taby00 (827)
• Pakistan
16 Apr 07
yeah u r right but freed of sppech is not allowed in all societies.
1 person likes this
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
16 Apr 07
Yeah you are right about this. I agree. I hear some people that speak on tv that just takes things to far sometimes.
1 person likes this
@easy888 (10405)
• Australia
16 Apr 07
I think freedom of speech is very important in a country, for example a citizen should have the right to speak or critize the government so that the country can be improved, but there shoudl be limit to the freedom of speech so that when people is expressing their opinion om something, it should be based on the fact no on particular person so that no no will abuse the freedom to offend other people to get advantage .
• India
16 Apr 07
i support this, coz with this freedom sometime we can get very good and smart ideas from any one and life will be beautifull. so we should feel and should have freedom of speech
2 people like this