Should homework for kids be banned?
By williamjisir
@williamjisir (22819)
China
77 responses
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
4 Jun 07
To some of the lazy students, they hate it. Even if it is not much for them, they would not like it. They complain about that and even ignore their homework, leaving their homework undone at all. To this kind of students, how to give them a discipline,please?
2 people like this
@henazea (313)
• Kuwait
9 Jun 07
well I remember while in school when any of us dint do our homewoks for any reason,the teacher who had assigned us the task wld make us do tat in the recess etc,but made sure we submitted it..the idea of doing homework in the recess often was an embarrasement in itself so I would always finish it at home.I think this was the school policy..
2 people like this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
27 Aug 07
It was the same with my teacher. If the sutdents didn't hand in the exercise-books the next day, he would be kept behind to do more than that as a punishment. I appreciate your response, friend.
1 person likes this
@sarwono_mandiri (67)
• Indonesia
29 Aug 07
i think homework is importan to bring a student to study at home, if no homework, student like playing everything, since 2006, my feel think homework can make me smart and make me like to study, reading and make me happines with my life...
2 people like this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
30 Aug 07
Good evening, dear sarwono_mandiri. Thanks very much for your response and time. Yes, homework is needed as always, without which the lazy students will spend more time playing and have no desire to study at home. Homework just helps to drive them to study more at home. Thanks again.
@ssh123 (31073)
• India
12 Jul 07
I feel homework is a must in the best interest of children education. With the advent of TV and computer with internet, children hardly study at home and there should be some responsibility with some target. One of the targets is homework which forces them to stuff things into their heads and some time is spent for this.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
12 Jul 07
I agree with you on that point that homework is a must in the best interest of children education. Some children are very addictive to the Internet for the computer games and consume lots of time on the Internet. Therefore it is a must to assign them homework as one of the targets to force them to stuff things into their head. Thanks, ssh123.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
13 Jul 07
It is a good way to keep you relaxed from managing your son for the two or three hours' time doing his homework. It is good to keep the kids busy with their study so that they don't have enough time to misbehave sometimes. lol. Have a nice time when he is doing his homework, my friend.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
4 Jun 07
I think some teachers assign far too much homework and seem to think they are the only teacher our kids have... but I think banning homework... or even government requlation of it is rediculous.
With my kids, I noticed that with lessons other than reading or writing assignments, they've learned everything they are going to in the first 15 or 20 minutes... the rest is just "busy work".
1 person likes this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
4 Jun 07
If the teachers would use the in class time more wisely, there would be less need for homework.
1 person likes this
@inallduetime (741)
• United States
5 Jun 07
Maybe if class sizes were smaller, teachers could use their class time more wisely. Maybe if teachers didn't have to play various rolls i.e. peace mediator, social worker, probation officer, to many of their pupils, they could use class time more wisely.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
4 Jun 07
It is so with (the) teachers that teach students who are going to graduate for higher education as they have to pass the entrance exams.
You know, teachers are somewhat forced to do so for the pressure given by the school and society. There is no other way for them, but to assign and force the students to do a lot of homework in order that more studnets can get passed.
@cjthedog64 (1552)
• United States
28 Aug 07
I don't think there's any reason to ban homework. In theory, it gives kids a chance to practice skills outside of the classroom, so they learn to adapt them to everyday life, and to work independently of the school. But I think most homework is given more as busy work than for any real purpose. Also, with all of the stuff that teachers have to spend time on during class that is not related to education (administrative tasks, breakfasts, discipline, etc) there's just not enough time to do the actual teaching, so they send it home.
2 people like this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
29 Aug 07
You are right. It is true that there is not enough time to do the actual teaching in class. The students still need lots of time to do some extra work at home to review and preview their lessons to make them learn more and absorb what has been taught and what is going to be taught. I appreciate your response very much. Thanks for your response and time, friend.
1 person likes this
@lydia002005 (101)
• China
29 Aug 07
No,I don't think homework should be banned for the children .Teachers should send some homework to the children,but shouldn't give so much.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
29 Aug 07
Yes, too much homework will bore the children and make them lose interest in study. Teachers should always give appropriate homework for them to keep up their interest. I thank you very much for your response, lydia.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
4 Jun 07
It is a good idea to keep children occupied at home and to make them study their lessons and make them more creative by doing homework. But sometimes they feel bored and refuse to do their homework. What will you do when this happens?
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
4 Jun 07
A good idea. I was trying to force them to do the homework I assigned to them before I went to Hangzhou with my two students for the speech competition by 2007 CCTV Star of Outlook. Today when I went to the classroom and asked them to hand in the exercise-books, only two thirds of the students could hand them in on time. So I had to give them more time to finish them during the coming 4-day holidays and hand them in when they come back to school four days later. I even said to them if they wouldn't hand them in, then I would not let them pass the exam. I will wait and see.
@cheongyc (5072)
• Malaysia
23 Aug 07
I think, it's basically a good thing to get the kids to do homework. Because it would help reminding them about what had been learnt in the class. But I think kids below 8 shouldn't have homework at all. They should have time to play and enjoy their childhood. Research actually shows that playing will help the brain development as well. Besides, the homework shouldn't be too heavy so that the kids could have chance to learn things other than homework.
@cheongyc (5072)
• Malaysia
27 Aug 07
I also hope that I could be a good father LoL. But unfortunately, I am still single and don't have any girl friend. So, it's still a long way to go to be a father :) In fact my girl friend left me 8 months ago, pursuing her own freedom. I was so sad and finally overcome the saddness after about half a year.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
27 Aug 07
I am so sorry to hear that. But don't worry, friend. You are still so young and have enough time to find a better one that is suitable to you so far as marriage is concerned. I wish you good luck as always.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
24 Aug 07
Morning, cheongyc. I agree that homework is the basic activity for kids and it is needed. It is right that kids under 8 should have enough time to play, which is also a way to develop their ability beside learning. You will be a good father, I think. Thanks for your response, friend.
@lkbooi (16070)
• Malaysia
6 Jul 07
I think homework is a must for students. The homework given ought to be meaningful and properly graded according to their levels. They ought to be interesting and attractive to them. Suitable amounts of work should be given. Try as far as possible to avoid excessive work for them. Otherwise they would take them as
@lkbooi (16070)
• Malaysia
22 Nov 08
Hi jisir, I’m really glad that I have received a best response from this old discussion. It’s really a meaningful and good topic related to children education though it is old. Hopefully it still could arouse the interest of caring parents to share their views here. Here I would like to express my belated gratitude (due to unstable network connection recently) for the awarded.
posting and take care.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
6 Jul 07
That is completely right. Homework is a must for the students without assigning excessive work for them, but meaningful and attrative in order not to bore them. I will try it in the new school term. Thanks, lkbooi.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
20 Nov 08
Hello lkbooi. I am very to have this discussion resolved after a year.
1 person likes this
@kimthedane (945)
• Denmark
14 Jul 07
I sure do not think homework should be banned for one simple reasson and that is the fact that it is getting more and more important in todays society to get some qualification if you want to make it later on in life. I wasn't much for doing the homework when i was a kid bit things was different back then. We could go directly from school and go out find job within the same day. I doesnt work like that anymore. I hear My daughter Mette moan on a daily basis over the ammount of homework she gets. But we will sit down together and have a look at it and as soon as she gets started she actually enjoy it and the time we spend together doing it.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
15 Jul 07
It is right that homework should not be banned in order to make it easier for the kids to get some qualication if they want to make it later on in life. Certain amount of homework is therefore needed for the kids to prepare for their future career. It sounds a good idea to get your daughter started for the homework since she actually enjoys it and the time you spend togother doing it. You are a very good father, friend.
1 person likes this
@ladybug565 (2216)
• United States
17 Aug 07
I dont think it should be banned but maybe there shouldnt be so much I have seen alot of kids come home and start homework right away and still doing it at 8pm. I think that homework can be good for kids but too much is just plain overload.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
21 Aug 07
Excessive homework makes the children feel bored with it and will make gradually lose interest in doing homework. Proper homework can not only help raise their interest but also can make them learn more in an active way. Thanks for your response, ladybug.
@ladybug565 (2216)
• United States
2 Sep 07
I agree. not only does it make them lose intrest but if they are up untill 10pm doing homework how are they supposed to do well in school the next day?
@Sharon38 (1912)
• Jamaica
16 Oct 07
I say it should not. It allows me to know whether or not she understands what has been taught in school. It also allows me to see how well she is progressing and find out how best I can help her in progressing. My child is 9 so you will find that her homework is much less than a child in High school.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
17 Oct 07
Right. It should not be banned at all as it is so helpful to the kids to make them do more researching work outside class. And it is necessary that they should do more active study at home so that they won't waste their time doing things that are meaningless, but there should be appropriate homework instead of excessive homework so that they can enjoy themselves by doing something that they like in their spare time.
1 person likes this
@jungle_girl (138)
• Philippines
23 Aug 07
If we ban homeworks, its like encouraging children not to think.
Let's face it, teachers can't really dedicate all their attention to only one student. Homeworks help the children understand subject topics better.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
23 Aug 07
I love what you have commented. It is absolutely correct. Homework should never be banned in order to help the kids think more actively instead of leaving their brain unused. Thanks so much, friend.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
26 Aug 07
Though the equation was not fixed, it was still fun to have somebody work together for it. I think that your parents must have great interest in math. And it is good for them to have the ability to teach their children math. I am sorry to say that I don't have a math head. lol.
@jungle_girl (138)
• Philippines
25 Aug 07
One thing about homeworks in our house too, it was always bonding time with my parents since they help me answer assignments when I was younger.
I remember when I was in high school, we were given a special set of equations in algebra. Special because it was for extra credit. Both my parents are good in math, I am not bad myself. But this one equation was just really hard to solve. So my parents and I took an hour to solve it and after a few wasted sheets of paper, we realized that the equation was undefined. HEhehehe
1 person likes this
@MamaJacci (16)
• United States
30 Aug 07
Class room works should be banned, not home work. But I guess that's not possible in a society where there are not so many stay home parents. I think kids loose big when they learn their social skills and morals from other kids. They also loose in an environment where the adults are not allowed to correct their behavior.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
30 Aug 07
So you are more in favor of home school kids? That can be a good idea, but also it has some deficiency that the kids will not be able to learn as much team spirit and group work as they can at school with the other kids. This is what I think though I have not had such experience. Besides, parents need to work. Who will teach the kids? Hire some tutors? It must be very expensive to have a tutor unless one parent stays at home to teach the kids. Thanks for your reponse, MamaJacci.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
3 Sep 07
Thanks for being such a great mama to all of your kids. I have to say that you are a very learned mama and you are very capable and talented. I think that your kids are very lucky to have such a great mama who has well brought them up to be so helpful people. Thank you, dear MamaJacci.
@MamaJacci (16)
• United States
2 Sep 07
Yes. I'm in favor of homeschooling. But you are correct. Many people can't do it because they have to work. I have been blessed with having the option to be a full time mom or to go to work. I home school and my children do not lack in social development. My 14 year old daughter is a competitive gymnast and my 3 younger children are in Taekwondo. My 18 year old just finished high school....with 38 college credits. I have been very blessed with the opportunity to manage their educations. But I do understand that not everybody has the opportunity to do it. Thanks for the discussion topic. It's a good one.
1 person likes this
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
20 Nov 08
The school my son goes to, doesn’t not give too much homework. In fact except for maths, there is seldom any written work to be done at home. Revision is expected and is good too, coz in the humdrum of the classroom, not all children can retain everything taught. But in the serene confines of home with a parent as a personal guide, children comprehend more. So little homework is good for overall development.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
20 Nov 08
Hello friend. Yeah, it is true that a parent as a personal guide can enable his / her children comprehend more. Thank you for the response. Have a good day, friend.
@mkirby624 (1598)
• United States
7 Jul 07
I only have 45 minutes a day with each group of students I teach. That is not enough time to cover everything that needs to be covered in the course of a year.
I don't assign a lot of homework (I teach English) because I like most things to be done in class where I can supervise. However, when you are teaching something that repetition plays a hand in (spelling words, vocabulary words, etc), it is easier to assign homework in those areas, that way, the student can practice at home. If I spent as much time in my class as I needed to drilling vocabulary or spelling words, then we would never get to other benchmarks that have to be met.
This comes up most often in math. In 45 minutes, you have time to teach the material, have the students get a bit of practice in class, and answer any questions that come up once the students begin working on their own. Then class is over. Math skills need to be practiced over and over for them to stick. There is simply not enough time in each class period to do those repetition drills, therefore, extra practice at home by the student is needed to allow the teacher more time to teach new concepts the next day.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
8 Jul 07
It is so true, mkirby. I am glad that we are in the same line. I teach English as well in a senior high school, namely, from the students' tenth to the twelfth year. English in China is considered to be the most important subject along with maths and Chinese. Nowadays, whenever you go to apply for a job in a comapny or even in some other line of business, you will be asked about what English level you have reached while you are interviewed. English is needed as a basic demand. It contributes to the open policy to the world by the government ever since the 1980s when Mr. Deng Xiaoping, our beloved leader started to pay a visit to the south of China, especially to Shenzhen city, which is next to Hongkong. Ever since then, English is placed in a very important position in whatever school you are studying at.
Let's come back to the point. I agree with you that 45 minutes in class should be well used in an effective way and some extra time for doing homework is needed for them to strengthen what they have learnt at school for learning more upcoming knowledge in class each day.
Thanks very much for your participation.
@theprogamer (10534)
• United States
14 Oct 07
Sick thought, but I do believe in this. Perhaps the school year should be extended to something closer to an actual year. At least there is more time to cover the materials of the course. I know its just a slight copy of other school systems especially those abroad but I do feel its a scenario worth looking into.
I do agree with the rest of your posting though. Back in high school it was easy not to finish materials in the classes, many times it was just 2/3 or 3/4, rarely did a whole class course get truly finished.
1 person likes this
@castleghost (1304)
• United States
3 Jun 07
I truly would like to know why some people think that homework should be banned. For the life of me I can't think of a good reason why it should be. I do believe that there should be a limit on how much homework the teachers give the students. There are times when a children is given so much homework that they don't have time for anything else.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
4 Jun 07
Some of the students say that it is enough for them to listen carefully in class and it is better to leave them some time to finish doing their homework in class, not ouside class. They say this way they can spend more time to do things they like to do outside class. They say that they can still learn a lot on the Internet.
The students are complaining about the homework assigned to them every day, leaving them no time to enjoy themselves, especially those who are going to take part in the college entrance exam as well as those who are lazy in study, which is a headache to them.
Thanks for your response and I agree with you that there should be a limit on how much homework the teachers give the students and give them enough time for something else.
@lancingboy (1385)
• United States
14 Sep 07
I think some of the homework should be banned, meaning making sure the students do not have too much of it. There are many Junior High and High School students who have to carry heavy backpacks home because they are full of textbooks they need for the homework.
@MisterPlus (1915)
• Philippines
26 Nov 08
Homework is helpful for students. They will be more responsible when they get to the real world and probably ready for any challenges there is to face if they come to attend to the homework to be done.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
26 Nov 08
Hello MisterPlus. It is true indeed that homework is very helpful for the students to enhance their responsibilities when they get to the real world. Take care.
@Angel4you730 (114)
• United States
7 Nov 07
Yes, I think homework should be banned. Kids spend enough time in school as it is. When kids have more work to do when they get home, it's when they begin to get over-whelmed and just want to give up. The time in the classroom should be used more wisely to let kids get work done. Those who need to get a job while still in high school have a hard time because of the out-side pressures from school. this is speaking from past experience.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
7 Nov 07
Morning, dear Angel. Thanks for your comment about this topic. I agree with you that it is better for the kids to have enough time to finish their homework at school or in class before they go home so that they can have some of their fun time to enjoy themselves. Thanks again, dear friend.
@wangguoxiang (114)
• China
26 Nov 08
From my standpoint,as to students,we should be obliged to do homework.Or else some students will pour themselves into playing after school,forgetting to the importance of studying.Homework can build up our understanding and consolidate our foundation.
1 person likes this
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
26 Nov 08
Hello wgx. I quite agree with you that it is not supposed to be banned as it helps the kids to consolidate what they have learned at school. Take care.