JUDGMENTS--What is Your View of Them--How Have They Helped/Harmed You?
@Perspectives (7131)
Canada
June 25, 2007 6:10pm CST
Judgment is a tricky thing to pin down because people have many opinions about it and the reason I wanted it open for discussion. One thing I do know for sure is that people who judge others view things with a narrow lens. They see everything as THEY ARE...rather than the WAY THINGS ARE.
People who claim to be non-judgmental are rather deluded. We have to make judgments every day in every way. Every thought we think has some form of judgment to it. To say 'it is a beautiful day' is a pesonal judgment. What if the person you say it to is sad, depressed, lonely...it probably doesn't feel like a beautiful day to them. Each time we evaluate anyone or anything...we are making a judgement. So in reality the only way to avoid judgments would be to refrain from thinking any thought...and that is ridiculous. So this topic needs to put in context of reasoning judgements versus harmful judgements of others.
Another interesting observation is how blind judgmental people are to the reality that their opinions and perceptions rarely alter anything or anyone in and of themselves. Just because we judge someone does not necessarily do anything to change them...that choice is theirs to make. People are defined by his or her thoughts, words, behaviors and beliefs...not by the judgments of others. (Unless they buy into it, of course.)
Another thing 'judgers' overlook is how their judgments DEFINE THEM. Spouting off about cultural/racial differences, religious beliefs, gender, age, appearance and choices made revealing statements about whether they are respectful/bigoted, inconsiderate/caring, arrogant/accepting bullish/ gentle, egotistical/ honoring whether they own up to it or not.
When I recognized this truism I was able to replace tendencies to judge... with greater acceptance. In my view acceptance is forgiveness in action.
In closing I will share how I have learned to handle the judgments of others. If I am upset by their words then it is usually a clue that their comments have triggered something within me that is unfinished or needs attention. Other times I look at the source...and if they are not offering something constructive then I don't really care what they think and let it go. After all what matters more than anyone else's judgements is what we think about ourselves and whether WE respect the person looking back at us when making eye contact in the mirror each day. So my final comment on the topic of judgments is this---they can only harm us...if we let them. But that is only my perspective...what is yours?
7 people like this
7 responses
@craftcatcher (3699)
• United States
26 Jun 07
Very nicely put. I have never had a problem with people being judgemental. We're only human after all. Where we advance in our thinking process as humans is whether to judge without facts and proceed on assumptions based on stereotypes and myths or judge with facts and logic to serve up an opinion that could be used as a learning point.
Openmindedness and compassion usually negate the will to do harm to someone with an opposing viewpoint. Closemindedness breeds contempt, hate and violence. Always has and always will.
Personally, they don't know me well enough to know how to hurt me.
3 people like this
@Perspectives (7131)
• Canada
27 Jun 07
Your additions to the discussion are appreciated and I will definitely be checking out your site to hear more of your viewpoints on other topics. Your leadup to 'learning points' is a good description n how we can turn knowledge into wisdom. The way illustrate outcomes open and closemindedness is a conscise addition to the topic of judgments. Your closing statement about 'them not knowing you well enough to know how to hurt you' shows you have already developed a keen sense of discernment. Thanks for partipating!
1 person likes this
avoidance
awakenings
better left unsaid
compassion
compassionate sight
discernment
doing what we know
friendships
having a blast
having fun
holidays
judgements
judgments
lack of them
lightening the shadows
loving
moral judgments
narrowmindedness
offensive people
projections onto others
respectful dialog
seeing the sights
sharing ideas
snowstorm comments
staying in touch
unwanted judgments
valuing input
walking a mile in anothers moccasins
words better left unsaid
@youdontsay (3497)
• United States
26 Jun 07
The kinds of judgements that cause the most harm are evaluation of a persons "goodness" or "badness". Of couse we evaluate all day long: This way is too far for me to walk; That color flatters her; Those flowers are wilted and I'd like to replace them.
But to believe that someone or something is inately bad or good because of your opinion is faulty reasoning. It translates our evaluations into moral judgements: This way is bad; That color is sinful; Those flowers are evil.
Pretty silly, right? Well, it isn't any better to make moral judgements of other people. We can only rightfully judge our own moral choices.
Obviously, some choices people make work and some don't. But that in and of itself is not grounds for evaluating them as morally right or morally wrong.
And to say that a person is bad because his behavior didn't work for the good of the community or his family or his own life is faulty. "Good" people can do "bad" things.
Thankfully, we mortals are not the final judge of others - or even of ourselves, for that matter.
@youdontsay (3497)
• United States
26 Jun 07
I forgot to address how judgments have hurt me. I've been judged by other as bad or sinful many times. When I was younger I felt enormous guilt that kept my self-esteem and self-confidene low. I've also been guilty of judging others as bad or sinful until I matured enough to differentiate the person from their behavior. Doing that limited my ability to develop meaningful relationships, to reach out to people who were different from me.
I think the most helpful experiences were when I went to college and met so many different kinds of people. As long as I stayed isolated in a small homogenous community it was easy to believe that "not like me" was something to avoid.
2 people like this
@Perspectives (7131)
• Canada
27 Jun 07
Hi youdontsay,
I appreciate what you DO say...especially on this topic. Your comments about rightfully judging our own moral choices and that mortals do not have the final say about others or ourselves is a gift in and of itself.
I try not to make moral judgments about others at this stage of life and am working to come from a place of 'compassionate sight." So often we do not know people's history, what messsage they received growing up and what led them to think and act the way they do. When I was younger I had a tendency to judge people without taking the time to realize I was not 'walking a mile in their mocassins' and therefore could not judge them until I did.
Life has shown that it is much easier when coming form a place of acceptance. People have a right to do what they do and learn from it..or not. The longer I live the more intent I am on doing more navel gazing and less casting of stones towards others. Saves a lot of time and energy to boot!
1 person likes this
@Katlady2 (9904)
• United States
10 Mar 08
Raia, I love your discussions so much. You always make me think. I think being at least mildly judgmental is pretty much human nature. But I agree with you that voicing those judgments can be detrimental at times, either to ourselves or to the person we are passing that judgment on. I honestly think that if people would just take a good long look in the mirror, looking into their own eyes, they would realize their own personal faults that they need to take care of, and they wouldn't spend all their time concentrating on the perceived faults of the others around them. Thank you for this awesome post hon. Hugs to you.....Carryl
2 people like this
@Perspectives (7131)
• Canada
12 Mar 08
Hi Carryl...how good to hear from you again. I haven't been here as much and am always happy to re-connect with valued Cyber gal-pals when I log in. How are you doing? Hopefully well. You have been in my thoughts and prayers...
Thanks for your positive feedback about this discussion and other perspectives topics. Always good to know how offerings are being received...it is a gift to me. As a writer and life coach sharing ideas is my life's work and whenever those ideas hit the mark is gives ma lovely little inner tickle!
I appreciate your view that people often project what they least like about themselves on other people. Boy have you got that right! Also I think we all have a tendency to be harsh, judgmental and overly critical with ourselves. What a wonderful life we'd have if we could love ourselves and everyone else with acceptance...even though we are bound to disagree. It would be pretty boring if we did that all the time. However, it is all in the approach.
Big hugs to you too my friend!
Raia
1 person likes this
@bast09 (20)
• Canada
12 Mar 08
If you use judgments to define someone I think that is wrong. If your judgements are of a personal nature and you do not act on them, then I think that is healthy. Its when we use judgements to control or hurt others I believe it is bad. We all need to use a little less judgement and a bit more comon sense.
1 person likes this
@cordacs99 (15)
• Canada
12 Mar 08
Foe me its a question of judgement or judgemental. We need to exercise judgement everday just ot survive and live. It is our judgemnets of other for me where the trouble is. I do not feel unless it is a legal or personal moral issue I do not have the right to judge others. In Moral and legal cases I can judge but then the question is what do I do with that judgement. If it is something I find offensive I will simply not associate with the persons or persons involved....
2 people like this
@Perspectives (7131)
• Canada
12 Mar 08
You have presented some interesting aspects when you say it is a question of judgment or judgmental. Yes, we do have to exercise judgments every day and it is when we get into making others wrong and ourselves right in demeaning ways where judgments cause harm.
You have a sensible approach in avoiding those with offensive attitudes. Those heavily invested in their beliefs have the hardest time changing them alright.
Thanks for you input.
Raia
1 person likes this
@Winter08 (441)
• Canada
10 Mar 08
Judgements are definitely a needed part of the human life experience. From judgement grows discernment.
Oh! Wait! Discernment is actually a different aspect of judgement ... coming from the "harm none" side of judgement. Well, darn! If I want to keep labelling people to keep them in their place so I can stay comfortable in my limited little world, I'd better quite being discerning. Darn! Darn!! Darn!!!
Sorry. Got carried away with the sarcasm (which does not translate well in the written word). :)
Thought provoking topic, here.
So many small everyday actions/words in life fall into "judgementallity", and they are so very easily overlooked because they have been a part of the learned life experiences from a very young age. Good people, smart people, people who have the best of intentions inadvertently pass judgement on others without realizing that that is what they are doing simply because that is what they have always done, that that is what their families/friends have always done.
Fortunately, there are discussions like this one that may help bring more awareness to the subtle judgements being made in everyday life.
1 person likes this
@remo999 (49)
• Canada
12 Mar 08
Judgements from others are always a difficult thing. Mostly because a lot of people do not take the time to learn about what they are judging. When judgements are made this way it usually becomed a hurtful process. Only through dialogue and understanding can we truly get to a point of understanding, not judging.
1 person likes this