Believing doesn't make it so.
By Pose123
@Pose123 (21635)
Canada
September 5, 2007 10:40am CST
One of the comments make in a recent discussion, was "just because you don't believe in hell, doesn't mean there is no hell." That's a very valid point, and one that can be used in many ways. A blind man may not believe in light, or that the sky is blue, but that doesn't change the fact. There are many different beliefs especially when it comes to God/Gods and religion. My belief affects nothing only the way I think. Many people say that they know their beliefs are true, and of course they are true - for them. In another discussion, we were asked, which is true the Bible or the Koran? Of course there are millions of people on both sides of the question, all equally certain that they are right. Believing then, doesn't make it true for anyone except us. " According to your faith, be it unto you".
4 people like this
10 responses
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
5 Sep 07
Great post. I couldn't agree more. Your belief is yours & yours alone. Without hard provable fact thats all it can be.
I was in a discussion earlier with someone who finds it surprising that people are offended when they tell someone that their going to hell. This is using your BELIEF to degrade other people but they don't get that ( much as I tried to show them ).
Here's the link.
http://www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1265628.aspx
Whats your opinion?
3 people like this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
5 Sep 07
Hi uath, I went to that link, and boy you did a great job! It's amazing how people can think that way. I consider myself a spiritual person, not "religious", as that word leaves a very bad taste in my mouth. I thank you for responding to my post. Blessings.
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
5 Sep 07
Thanks, I usually try to make the point without actually quoting verses from whatever religion but they set themselves up for it.
Notice during all that I never actually even mentioned my personal beliefs ( besides the whole institution thing ). Their mine & I feel no need to impose them on others. To try to do so is rude.
2 people like this
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
6 Sep 07
...christians are taught that unless someone is persuaded, they will perish, or worse! This is what motivates most christians to try to persuade others of the faith they believe.. It's not necessarily because they are mean, or even 'pushy'. I myself believe there is no logic to people perishing, nor certainly to some sort of fiery afterlife. If there is God, he's Life itself (who/what else?) and there's one basic truth - in order for Life to remain aLive and Living it can only be excellent! I.e. perfect. Nothing else is possible. And therefore, the 'end' result of all this, can onLy be the absolutely best possible 'end' result.
@Springlady (3986)
• United States
5 Sep 07
Heaven and hell are real or they are not real. It doesn't just apply to some, but all people. The Lord spoke of both places being very real and He cannot lie.
Whether you want to believe in hell or not is not the issue...the issue is that it is very real and do you know where you will spend eternity? Jesus Christ is the only way to Eternal Life.
God bless.
2 people like this
@katydidmc (210)
• Canada
5 Sep 07
The lord? are you talking about that guy who was executed for telling people to rise up against the religious and political leaders? Did you know there were dozens of similar guys at that time who performed 'miracles'? I think maybe Jesus just had a better press agent than the rest, or was more mobile and harder to catch, kind of like Osama Bin Laden today. I wonder how many people, if they bothered to do ANY research on the bible, or quran would realize how silly those beliefs are.
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
6 Sep 07
It is very true that we all create our own reality, for the most part, but there has to be an underlying reality. In the end, either there is a real burning pit of eternity called "hell" or there isn't. As far as determining what is true and what is not, I find logic the best tool for that. What good does it do for me to tell myself, such and such is true, but I never reason and investigate to see if it is. What good does it do me to believe such and such is the purpose and reality of what life is, if I have no idea why I believe that... All the universe, vast as it is, moves together, and this is because of one major natural law - gravity, or the law of attraction.. if everything went its own way according to their own perception of reality, well, everything would fall apart. Just like we see happening in and to the world today.
- As a believer, if I am sick, according to my faith, will it be unto me.. If I am in deep trouble, my safety threatened, and I call to the Lord for help, according to my faith shall it be unto me. For He can throw me a rope, but if I cannot perceive of it, I can't grab it.
But that doesn't change the reality of what is.
- The central question facing man is "is there a God who created all that is and has a purpose He's working"? Or, did everything slowly, and completely on its own, evolve from nothing? We can observe things around us. We can observe and learn the natural laws which govern everything, to see which theory stand up within those natural laws. And we can reason and investigate. And no matter what my finding are. One is true, and one is not. And no amount of my opinion will change the reality whatsoever.
:) blessings!
@katydidmc (210)
• Canada
5 Sep 07
You could also use the reverse. Just because YOU believe in Hell, doesn't mean there is one. There are more and more people every day who realize the bible is just a series of morality tales and the quran is nothing more than the ravings of a crazy man. Atheism is on the rise, and about time, too!
@MikeMe (100)
• United States
6 Sep 07
I see your point, but I think we need to take it a step farther. One of the greatest enemies of our souls today is this concept of "relative truth". Just because it's true to me, doesn't make it true. Many people believe many things, often in the face of much contradictory evidence. You know, "don't confuse me with the facts". People today want to define their own truth. Fact is if its true, its true. If its not, its not. Got nothing to do with whether we believe in it or not. Has our collective ego gotten so huge that we really think we can make something true by believing in it?
No matter how certain we are that we are right, the fact remains, its true because its true, not because we FIRMLY believe it to be true.
2 people like this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
7 Sep 07
Hi MikeMe, Thanks for commenting. Of course when it comes to religion, people believe all sorts of things. That's okay as long as they realize that it's a belief, and that others may believe something entirely different. Of course if there is a God,(and I believe there is), he will be there for the unbeliever as well as the believer.
1 person likes this
@theprogamer (10534)
• United States
8 Sep 07
Can't really add to this, but yes beliefs are your own and no one else's. They are unto you and you can believe them or share them. Do not try to force it down others, let them believe and live the way they want to. I think its better to live this way instead of playing holy warrior and actually going out hurting or offending others needlessly.
1 person likes this
@headhunter525 (3548)
• India
8 Sep 07
Yea, we should not force down our beliefs upon another but if we let people believe all the false ideas and we don't do anything to rectify that then there would be no progress... no need to read and study. No need to reach Philosophy or Mathematics. I think what we rather need to do is learn to correct and accept correction...for that we need to humbly and persuasively give reasons for our belief, but do it in such a way that the choice is finally left to the person to accept or reject.
with regards,
headhunter525
1 person likes this
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
12 Sep 07
I believe it depends on what we are talking about here. When it was discovered that the earth wasn't flat, even though most people thought it was, people had to be educated to the truth. If we are talking religion, and discussing whether or not there is such a place as hell, then there really is no way to prove who is right.
@pumpkinjam (8754)
• United Kingdom
6 Sep 07
I'm with you on this one. Particularly a comment you made on someone elses response that you are fully accepting of the fact that you may or may not be right. I also am fully aware that if I believe in something, it is only a belief which suits me and it may or may not be true. I don't like people going to extremes to convince others that they are right. I don't know why people can't just accept other people's choices and accept that their opinion might be right for them but they don't "know". For example, someone who is an Atheist might say they "know" there is no God, and a Catholic for instance might say they "know" there is a God. Well, I don't persaonlly see how either of them could know for certain. As you say, believing in something does not mean it is true just as not believing in something doesn't make it untrue. It's not only religion which we could do this with but it does seem to be the main thing. I could tell you there is a giraffe standing in my garden. You can choose to believe me or not. It's just one person's word. The chances of there being a giraffe in a suburban English garden are, of course, extremely low so you would maybe assume that it was not true. Of course that doesn't mean it's not there even if you say you "know" and, on the other hand, someone who knew me and thought I would not make up that kind of thing might say they "know" that it is true but, of course that doesn't mean it is.
@headhunter525 (3548)
• India
7 Sep 07
Believing something does not necessarily make it true. Long time ago people believed that the earth was flat. They also believed that the sun goes round the earth. But just because they believed that way, reality did not just follow their belief. Reality behaved in its own way irrespective of people's belief. Later on people just discovered the reality.
1 person likes this
@alamode (3071)
• United States
6 Sep 07
I, as a person, go against nearly every proscribed belief and belief system... my goal in my life is to be a full, complete, contented human being, and I find I can't do that by following a program.
That puts me at a place where all blame and/or praise falls only to ME, and I can't step away from the responsibilities I have taken on voluntarily. I don't want a crutch, I don't want a scapegoat. I don't want fear to rule my life.
I will make the most of what I have today... tomorrow will be what it is.