Would you remain friends with someone you loved?

Friendship - Photo: Friendship
Philippines
November 20, 2007 4:57am CST
Have you ever experienced this one? What if you fall in love with your close or bestfriend, will you remain being friends forever? Is it true that friends can be lovers but lovers cannot be friends? This situation is very hard especially if the one you loved does not love you and would only desire to stay as close friend with you. But, as long as there is life, there is hope, so don’t lose hope. How about you? Would you remain friends with someone you loved?
5 people like this
30 responses
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
20 Nov 07
Definitely yes for me, if we already have closure and that we parted our ways peacefully. But still, this depends on her, if she wants to remain friends with me or not. There are times where the saying "bestfriends can be lovers but lovers can't be bestfriends" apply, it take alot of guts and maturity for both people to accept everything that happened for them..
@maryannemax (12156)
• Sweden
20 Nov 07
yup. situations differ from person to person. not all can remain friends with their exes but some can. i do believe that it will depend, too on how they parted ways. as for me, i am the kind of person who says "past is past". i had bad experiences with my exes before and break ups were really hurtful. so, for me, there's no reason to remain friends with them. i do smile and say hi to them whenever i meet them somewhere. but that's just out of respect. i don't see myself as being friends with them anymore. anne
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's true. The situation really varies, it always depends if she would still want to remain friends with you, even though you're very willing to remain friends with her.:-)
• Philippines
20 Nov 07
In my younger days, i fell in love with a best friend of mine. Of course after a long time being with each other, the feelings developed. Until one day it becomes obvious that started to make our friendship become weaker because obviously my feelings was caught. My heart shrink as talked that we could never be lovers but remain friends forever. That was a very hard thing for me to do. I even rejected invitastions to do the things we used to. Until one day we parted ways, remnants of memories were etched in my heart and would never vanish as long as i breath. But a small room in my being was reserved to be empty for this friend of mine to be backed in my sanity. Thanks braveheart for being brave in this kind of situation. In my case i never been so brave enough to fight my feelings and to win the love that was about to be mine.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Thanks statickery for the compliment. I know sometimes we failed in loving someone but this should not be the basis of giving up. Never give up my friend. Have a great day!
@subha12 (18441)
• India
20 Nov 07
It is really a tough question to answer. it happened to me in some different way. My so called best friend proposed me but i rejected knowing that it is not the real feelings from his side. We decided to become friends. Actually it was from my side. But he told that one day you will definitely feel that thing. But i was wrong in believing him. He was a cheat and acted this for his own advantage. Few months back he behaved very badly with me and now not in touch anymore.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
I think it needs a lot of time for you to know if he has real feelings for you, so you've made the right decision to reject his proposal for you.:-)
@AshleyHasan (1024)
• India
21 Nov 07
Yes, we can remain friends with some one we loved, this situation is better if the other person is not loving us and if they just want to be friend with us. I have fallen in love with my best friend, but my story is different he proposed me , I said yes, we got married and settled happily till today some times we will be like friends and I can not give that much respect to my husband beca he was very close friend to me and I call him the way I want to ....But this will not happen with evey one....
1 person likes this
• India
22 Nov 07
Thank you!
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's really nice! I think it's nice that you treat yourselves as close friends, though you're already commited with each other as husband and wife. I think it would make your relationship more stronger, healthier, and very intact. Have a nice day and may you have a safe and happy family.:-)
• India
26 Nov 07
Yes definitely we would be friends obviously it would take time to be normal again but that would be a short period..The person mey have rejected may be because he/ she is looking for some qualities which may be not there or may be taste is different..
1 person likes this
• Philippines
27 Nov 07
You're right. It would take time for the relationship to be normal again but that's for the time being only.:-)
@ayou82 (3450)
• Philippines
20 Nov 07
For me yes, for instance he said no to me then its alright why not make friends to someone who loves the other person.. there nothing you can do if he cant love you back for some reasons maybe youre not the type of person he is loking for then nothing to worry about keeping things lcloser makes magic.. could be possible
2 people like this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's true.:-)
@Lifeless (2635)
• India
21 Nov 07
I wud certainly try to remain friends with that girl to whom I had been in a relationship, but it also depends upon her approval, whther she wants to be in touch with me or not.. But I wud always like to be in touch with the person with whom I had passed sm beautiful moments of my life...
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's great! Personally, I will also do the same. The beautiful moments that you've been through are priceless, so that's why it's worth it to stay and remain friends forever.. :-)
@wisedragon (2325)
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
I don't think I can stay "just friends" with someone that I love. At some point I will have to tell her. Never mind risking the friendship. I have to tell her how I feel. Even if it doesn't work out, at least I have no regrets.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's true! I think it's better that you have to tell how you feel, though it may affect your friendship with her, at least you will not feel regret at the end. Who knows she also feels the way you do..:-)
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
21 Nov 07
In the past I thought it was not possible. Because he was someone who I loved deeply, so it would be sad if I treated him just as a friend. Now it is different. As I am already married and have a happy family. I already let the pass love go. And I can treat him as well as one of my good friends and there is no problem at all.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Good that you were able to treat him as one of your good friends right now and beside, you're happily married right now. Actually, it's hard to remain friends especially if you're deeply in loved with that person.:-)
@vicki2876 (5636)
• Canada
24 Nov 07
I am only friends with one person that I have dated in the past. We were engaged to be married but it didn't work out. Though a friendship early on wasn't possible because of fresh pain of breaking up, we did reconnect a couple years later and are now very close friends.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
25 Nov 07
Good that both of you are still close friends right now.:-)
@errielle (442)
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Yes. My answer is YES. Although it really depends on how the friendship started and what kind of decisions you do. You can be friends with someone you love but who doesn't love you. It can be done if you are mature enough to face the situation. SOmetimes, even if what they wanted is just company and friendship, it's already a consolation. But again, it really depends on how you accept the situation.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
22 Nov 07
You're right, it really depends on the situation. Acceptance really plays an important role here. :-)
@khateya (263)
• Australia
21 Nov 07
i have broken with many of my girlfriends but i can see that i can't stay with her as her friend anymore. i really want to be her friend but when i meet her i really feel something that i don't know what to say... I will try to be her friend..
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
I know you can make it my friend. Just believe in yourself, have confidence, and everything will follow. Have a great day!:-)
@bing_r77 (237)
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
They say that lovers or sweethearts start at friendship. but friendship can also be broken because of loving a friend and not accepting what he or she feels for that friend. In case that would happen to me that i will be in love with my close friend and he only wants friendship, well, i will accept and respect his decision. but i will still keep loving him in secret until what i feel for him is gone..
• Philippines
22 Nov 07
That's really sweet. Well, I think I will also do the same way you do. Though, she will never accept my love and would only want to stay as friends, then I will never force her but I will still keep loving her secretly and silently.:-)
@jennyp08 (68)
• United States
21 Nov 07
I am assuming that this is pertaining to you? Well don't answer that, but I feel that you should still be able to stay friends maybe not close but still buddies because that's what you were before you chose to become lovers. I hate to say it but it's better to have friendship than nothing at all.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Hello jennyp08..^_^ Well, this topic just come up in my mind only and does not really pertain to me. Like you, I am not closing the door for friendship to anyone else. I like having a lot of friends and I will be very grateful if they're already part in my life. Yeah, you're right. It's better to have friendship than nothing at all. In fact, friends are like treasures, they never change their value, always precious, always hard to find, and always unique, so once I find them, I always cherish them.:-)
@maryannemax (12156)
• Sweden
20 Nov 07
i don't think that it's applicable in real life. i mean, when the heart starts beating for someone, it will continuously beat for that person whether she or he is a friend or not. the difficult thing is the acceptance part. if that person does not want you to be a girlfriend or a boyfriend, that will really hurt. but if that friend has the same feeling for you, that's gonna be a blessing. all it takes is to give it a try. just tell that person how you feel and be prepared for whatever the reply will be. my boyfriend and i started out as friends. and from there, our love grew. we are in a relationship for more than a year and a half now and really happy together. and ofcourse, we are lovers and we remain as friends. i think it's a better relationship if you aren't just a partner to your other half but a good friend as well. anne
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Yeah, I agree with you. The acceptance is really the difficult part here but as what you've mentioned, we should always be prepared to whatver the reply would be. I think it's healthy if you have a combined relationship, good lovers and bestfriends, isn't it? Have a blessed day to you!:-)
@faith210 (11224)
• Philippines
20 Nov 07
Hi braveheart! Actually, I have fallen in love with my friend and I am married to him until now. But if it happened the other way, that I have fallen in love with him and he does not love me back, I don't think I can stay friends with him shortly after the rejection. Maybe after I have healed, I will be a friend to him again. Who knows, he might wake up one day and find his heart beating only for me or probably I will be the one who will wake up one day and realized that I am not in love with him anymore. Take care and have a nice day.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
I think from the very start, it's hurtful on your part if that situation happens to you to still remain friends with the one you loved, but as what you've said, perhaps if the pain will start to heal, then probably it's still possible to remain friends with him or her.:-)
@izathewzia (5134)
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
I tried my best to befriend my exes. But unluckily they are the ones who refuses. Maybe because they are guilty. lol But I consider everything under the bridge now. That is why I am offering a platonic friendship. But since they are not ready yet, then it is okay. Besides i am happily married with kids already.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Good for you that you're happily married. We cannot please everybody, so I think time can only tell if they are still willing to remain friends with you.. :-)
20 Nov 07
You CAN remain friends but to do so you need to go through a period of not talking to each other at all. Why? Because to truly get over someone you need to not see them for awhile so all the hurt and pain just goes after awhile- to a point where you feel nothing when you see that person again. That is how it works for me.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's a nice strategy mugglegirl. Good that this really works out for you. Have a great day!:-)
• United States
21 Nov 07
I tried to but it didn't last more than a year. I had a good friend(a cute guy too)who I love as a best friend and no more than that. He stay being my good friend though two of my break ups. He was there to pick me up when I got dumped by one and when I broke up with another. He was always there to make me smile. Then I hooked him up with another one of my gf and they went out on three or four dates. I at the time just got into another bad relationship. This looser was always putting me down in front of my friends. Needless to say my relationship fell apart and yes my good friend was by my side. When we had a heart to heart conversation where I told him I only want to be friends with him, our relationship started to sour. Then it dissolved. Good luck with yours.
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
Sometimes it's nice to remain as close or bestfriend rather than going to a serious relationship, isn't it? In your situation, who knows you will be able to learn to fall in love with him as well..Only time knows what will happen. Good luck my friend. Take care!
@cait89 (30)
• United States
20 Nov 07
I'm not sure. My now boyfriend and I were friends, then we sort of dated then were friends again until last January when we got back together. That between time was really hard. We stayed friends but it was tough. So honestly no, I probably couldn't do anything like that again.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
21 Nov 07
That's sort of an on and off relationship and I think your decision really fits from the situation itself.:-)