Why would anyone think that this is the right thing to do?
By sedel1027
@sedel1027 (17846)
Cupertino, California
January 28, 2008 10:17am CST
We have been talking about having a kid for awhile and DH wants to wait. I am okay with that, just not the length of time he wants to wait. Quite a few people have been asking about babies lately and I keep saying well he isn't ready. I have had - I kid you not - 5 people seriously tell me to stage an "accident" and get pregnant. I even had a few people tell me that is how they got pregnant. To me that is the wrong way to handle things. Am I the crazy one?
8 people like this
20 responses
@AICIRT81 (847)
• United States
28 Jan 08
You're not crazy. I think anyone who purposely lies, especially about something so important, to their husband is the crazy one. You need to be honest with him and respect one another. Having a baby is a huge life change. You need to consider your finances, career, life style, your and your DH'd emotional available to care for child, your age and the number of child you want to have and how far apart you want to have them. Children are should not be planned accidents. Present Dh with your wishes, make sure he's aware of the difficulties that can arise from waiting including possible infertility or difficulty concieving and the increased risks of birth defects. But most importantly be open with him and make sure you both are in this together.
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
We are both well versed in what can happen is you wait too long. He knows I would rather have a kid now rather than latter. His main issue is finishing college; second on that list is that he is afraid that he will get "stuck" at the job he is at now (which he loves and makes a lot of money at, but isn't his "dream job"). I would rather have a child now because I can afford to stay home (I work mainly to humor him), his job now is be better than the one his degree will get him, and my son is almost nine.
1 person likes this
@libertarianfreedom21 (3198)
• United States
28 Jan 08
I would if i could but he uses the pull out method which has worked wonderfully for 3 years. I want to have my first kid and my mom, his mom, and others say stuff like when you going to have one. His nephews are real young and it would be good to be close in age. His son is alread 9 about to be 10 and if we dont have a kid soon Elishas going to be 18 b4 the kid is even old enough to play with each other and get to know each other as good brothers. But its hard to stage an accident with our method.
@libertarianfreedom21 (3198)
• United States
28 Jan 08
lol everyone else thinks differant but me, thats ok i dont care. my mom had an accident with me if she didnt i wouldnt be here.
2 people like this
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
wow, you are lucky that even works. I have heard lots of horror stories with that method not working at all. In fact it is touted as one of the ways most people do get pregnant since there can be sperm in the precum.
3 people like this
@libertarianfreedom21 (3198)
• United States
28 Jan 08
yea i know thats why i always hope for that precum sperm LOL but oh well i know the reason he wants to wait is b/c he wants to be more finacially stabel which is understanding im just impatiant. but yea im amazed that its working
@ebsharer (5515)
• United States
28 Jan 08
I personally wouldn't stage an accident but I know of some people that have for one reason or another. I think you need to find out why he doesn't want kids yet. Is he waiting for a more financialy stable income? If so you will never be financially ready to have a baby some thing always comes up. Are you trying to have a baby during martial problems thinking it will save it? If so it will only make it worse. Does he really want kids? I think there an underlining problem that you need to figure out. If you two are happy, have decent jobs with decent pays, a place to live, vehicles to drive, and health insurance I don't see what the problem is. You may be waiting for a long time if you don't take the time now to see whats going on. What would you do if he said he didn't want kids now?
1 person likes this
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
His main issue is finishing college; second on that list is that he is afraid that he will get "stuck" at the job he is at now (which he loves and makes a lot of money at, but isn't his "dream job"). I would rather have a child now because I can afford to stay home (I work mainly to humor him), his job now is be better than the one his degree will get him, and my son is almost nine.
1 person likes this
@SixPaulEleven (552)
• United States
28 Jan 08
No you're not the crazy one. They are the crazy ones. I would never do something so underhanded. That is by far one of the lowest things any woman could ever do to any man just to trap him. A former friend of mine did this to her "husband" (boyfriend at the time) so they'd have to get married so she could "beat" me to the aisle. I was the last one of our group in college to marry. Do I care? Hell no. I've stated in the past threads why we got married and it was for his health, not because we wanted to. We were happy living together.
BUt before I go off on a tangent, my friend started skipping her birth control pills until she became pg. He was flabbergasted and a bit dense on how birth control works, so he bought it that she had a pill baby. They got married, then she miscarried. He threatened divorce and she quickly got pregnant again to hang on to this beef cake.
You didn't ever say how long he wants to wait. What are his reasons for waiting that long? Is he not stable in his job? Are you not stable in yours?
He's going to be the one that provides half the DNA of the future children, so do what you can to talk him down, but be prepared to wait if he doesn't change his mind right away.
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
He isn't worried about the money. He just doesn't want kids right now. He keeps saying "When I finish college" but he hasn't even started going back to school yet. This summer we are suppose to get a house (just to save us money over rent) and he will be back in school. I figure I will start working on him again about it towards the end of the year. Either we will come to an agreement or we won't, its okay either way.
1 person likes this
@chrysz (1602)
• Philippines
28 Jan 08
If you are not yet ready, then don't have it yet. You're readiness would affect your pregnancy and the baby's well-being. If you wanna have a child soon, tell your husband about it. Tell him you want to enjoy your baby longer and if you hvae it soon, the longer timeyou will be spending with them. In most cases, the husband would also get excited but in some, they make it an issue and would blame you for having it accidentally do I guess its better to be honest. Who doesn't want a baby right? It is a blessing and forever will be.
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
His main issue is finishing college; second on that list is that he is afraid that he will get "stuck" at the job he is at now (which he loves and makes a lot of money at, but isn't his "dream job"). Which I can understand, but his "dream job" is probably not more than just a dream and not a well paying on at that. I am not looking to necessarily change his mind at this point, just either push him closer to being okay with it or us both come to the decision to not have kids so that some thing permanent can be done.
@chrysz (1602)
• Philippines
29 Jan 08
I dont think that having kids would hinder him from finishing college and getting a good job but if he doesn't want a baby yet then try to understand him. If you are eager to have one,then talk to him about it. Some people become more inspired if they have kids but then again, everyone has their own preferences.
@kymommy72 (588)
• United States
28 Jan 08
I think that is completely the wrong thing to do. First off you got to be honest in a relationship. Anybody who pulls something like that, if they had any sense at all, it would just eat them up inside. Having a baby is the most beautiful thing, you don't want it tainted with a lie. You will be miserable throughout your pregnancy, which is suppose to be one of the most special times in a woman's life. Also having and raising kids is hard enough ( I have two little ones) if you are not both on the same page and working together as a team, it will be a nightmare for you. You don't want to have kids with someone who isn't ready for them. You will have to deal with resentment and pressure you just don't need. It will interfer with your marriage and how you raise your kids. Give it a little more time. If after awhile he still isn't ready then maybe you need to sit down and talk about the things you both want in life, if they don't match...then that will require an even bigger talk. And tell those nosy ppl who keep asking that you are both just enjoying each other right now and babies will come when you are both ready for it!
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
28 Jan 08
The thing is, I already have a 9 yr old that lives with us. So I don't want to wait because the age difference is already too large. Honestly, if I have to wait I probably just won't have another child and on some level I am okay with that because I will be over 30 and I would rather not have kids more than 10 years apart.
@kymommy72 (588)
• United States
29 Jan 08
I totally get what you're saying. I didnt have my first born, til I was 32. And after he was born I was deadset against having another baby because I didnt want to have back to back kids. I knew I would have to wait a few years and I didn't want to have kids when I was 35 or older. But surprise surprise..at 35 I was pregnant again. I was a little scared because of my age. But my little girl is truly a gift for God and I am soooo glad I decided to have her...35 years old didn't really matter. As far as the age difference between your two kids, I don't think that will be as big a factor as you are afraid of. To my way of thinking, it may acutally be a plus. At 9, your other child can help out with the baby, may be above all the jealousy younger kids can sometimes feel when a new child is brought into the family. Have you talked to your 9 year old and asked when he thinks about have a brother or a sister. My mother was 11 years older than my aunt. She treated her like own kid instead of a big sister. My aunt always tells me that my mom was like her mother. It may not be as awful as you think it may be. I say being how your husband doesn't want any at the moment, this will give you all some time to take a step back and really think and plan this all through. And believe me I am not telling you to do this in any way shape or form. What works for one person, doesn't always work for another. You need to do what is right for you, your family and your situation.
@flowerchilde (12529)
• United States
29 Jan 08
...surely it is better for the relationship to be honest.. Though I can sympathize with the other ladies.. I think it would be better to pray/meditate/and calmly wait for the 'breakthrough' in your significant other's ideas...
@tentwo67 (3382)
• United States
29 Jan 08
When I became pregnant with my son, it was not planned. It was an accident, but it was not staged. 5 and a half years later it's the greatest thing that ever happened to me, but it was not an underhanded thing to become pregnant when my partner wasn't ready. Actually of the two of us, I was the one who was more freaked out and felt less ready... but it all worked out.
I think that what you've described sounds like a very dishonest way to bring a life into the world, which is not the fault of the child of course. I am just coming to believe more and more that that intention and purpose behind our actions is really important. I think that we should all strive to have honest and loving relationships, and if this can't describe your relationship then why would you want to have a baby with that person anyway?
I don't mean to sound preachy, but I do think it's a pretty dirty trick.
@SViswan (12051)
• India
31 Jan 08
No, you aren't! Any relationship should be built on trust...and staging an 'accident' breaks that trust (even if the partner doesn't know that you didn't do it on purpose, YOU know it)...and you already think it's wrong....then it is! Your morals and principals will not allow you to do it and don't let others convince you! It would have been another matter if you thought it was okay to stage an 'accident'.
@sneezeklenex (344)
• United States
29 Jan 08
Well, to be honest, I seriously thought about staging an "accident" because I'm in the same situation you are. I will wait until I know we both are stable enough to handle it, but I have thought about doing that. You are not crazy! If you are, then that makes two of us! lol Just make sure you're careful and nothing is happening in your life that will make it difficult for the child. You see, the reason why I'm waiting is because we are living with his father at the moment because he has severe emphazema and needs us. Taking care of him is like raising a child, so it would be too hard for us if we had a child right now.
@mflower2053 (3223)
• United States
30 Jan 08
If you would do that it might make him want to leave you. Having a kid is alot of work and takes alot of money. Puts a strain on relationships because there is so much that each of you would have to give to that child and take away from time with one another. Don't get me wrong kids are great and I think they are the best thing that happen to me but if your not ready then your just not ready. Marriage is about meeting in the middle and maybe you can explain to him that you want to have a child sooner for these reasons and give him a list of reasons. I'm not sure how old you are. As far as money you will never be ready if you wait for that. Good luck.
@Crysi23 (515)
• United States
29 Jan 08
Honestly in my opinion that's not the way to do things because that's a way to lose the one you love. How I would go about it is "I really want to get pregnant." I know you want to wait,yes I'm o.k. with it but is there a way for us to comprise. Communication is the key staging something is not the way to go about things. Remember you both have to be ready not just one of you. Talk it over some more but try not to push him give the other person some time and communicate but it doesn't always have to be about a baby. Bring it up once than drop it re-visit it every couple of weeks or even once a month.
@chrislotz (8137)
• Canada
30 Jan 08
No you are not the crazy one. Do not stage an accidental pregnanct. It can only back fir in your face and you may lose everything. You don't want to be raising a child alone, and that could quite possible happen if you force the issue on him. If he's not ready, he's not. So making it happen isn't going to make him ready. Being a parent is a big responsibility and not something either one of you should be rushing into. When your husband is ready he will tell you. Just keep the communication lines open with him and the time will come when you are both ready.
@Estina54 (385)
• United States
29 Jan 08
I won't do something like this. I won't stage an accident to get pregant. It might make somebody mad and walk away from you. Some people can accept this situation. But I won't count on it. Just knowing that someone tricked me like this, would make me mad. I CAN forgive somebody's cheating physically on me, but NEVER somebody's setting me up into something I'm not ready to do!
@roshnichaudhary (1160)
• United States
28 Jan 08
Are you talking about getting pregnant accidentally? This is not very unqiue. But its good to be careful and have baby after being mentally and otherwise prepared and have good understanding with partner. I am sorry if I misunderstood your statement.
@sacmom (14192)
• United States
29 Jan 08
To me, tricking your husband is not a good way to get pregnant. It's one thing if it was really accidental, but it is another thing to stage it. It just isn't right. Both of you should have a baby when BOTH of you are ready for a baby. Since both you and your husband are willing to wait, why not see if he is willing to negotiate the length of time he wants to wait. For example if you want to wait no more than 1 year and your husband wants to wait 3 years, why not see if he'll meet you in the middle at 2 years? I don't know if he'll agree, but it is worth a shot, right? It's better than tricking him, that's for sure! :P
Good luck!
@dlkuku (1935)
• United States
28 Jan 08
No you are not wrong, you want your baby to be loved and accepted by both of you, and doing something like that would seriously damage the trust your husband has for you.
When asked this question, maybe instead of saying your husband isn't ready, say that you both have decided to wait for a while.
@quiltedblessings (1066)
• United States
28 Jan 08
No, you are not the crazy one! Anyone that would tell you to "accidentally" get pregnant is out of their minds! Can you imagine if your husband ever found out? He would never trust you again (at best), at worst he would leave you. I think it is best to wait until you are both ready. He may surprise you and be ready sooner than he thinks.
@sailorstripesss (23)
• United States
29 Jan 08
You two should come to some sort of agreement that works for the both of you- perhaps there is some sort of time in between what each one of you want that you can agree upon. There has to be a decision that you two can come to that you both agree on, it may not be exactly what either one of you want, but at least it will be the honest way to go about it. This the only way that you'll be happy about your child coming and exciting for its delivery.
Do NOT stage an accident- that is deceptive and disgusting. What happens if your husband is really unhappy with this baby coming and isn't accepting of the situation? That won't be fair to YOU or YOUR baby... you won't have the support that you need from him and therefore it could affect your health-- fighting, etc. You are going to be PREGNANT, do you need anything extra? The stress could possible harm the health of yourself and your baby... you should wait until you two can both agree on a time which you guys will feel comfortable with. That way, you can have the most successful pregnancy possible and you can both be excited about the arrival.
Good luck!! And sorry to sound so harsh... but it disgusts me that people would even suggest such a thing!