who determines your child"s career?
By BYOLA2871
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
South Africa
February 27, 2008 9:06am CST
While growing up my parents allowed me to choose what i want to study in school i chose the commercials and i have never regretted,above all i was glad that i was allowed to follow my passion.One of my classmates then was however not as lucky as i was,his parents forced him to study arts and he eventually studied law but never made a good lawyer right now he is into stockbroking and he is doing very well,my question is who determines your child"s career you or you allow them to make a choice under your guidance?
6 people like this
16 responses
@SassyKittyKat (2135)
• Australia
27 Feb 08
No parent has the right to choose what their child should be when they get older. That is taking away their individuality, not to mention their freedom of choice. I think any parent who does this is extremely wrong...
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
28 Feb 08
you are right parents ought to respect their kids just like they expect the kids to respect their decisions but children need to take decisions with good care and guidance from parents but not by domination
1 person likes this
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
i am sure that by now a lot of people who intend to choose their children"s career will have a rethgink because ,as far as i am concerned career choice is the children right which is to be exercised with guidance from parents
@SassyKittyKat (2135)
• Australia
28 Feb 08
Yeah, I think that that kids should consider any words of guidance that the parents give them because their parents have been around longer and know how the world works. However, the final decision on what career to choose falls to the the indivual and not the parent.
@Darkwing (21583)
•
28 Feb 08
I feel you need to let them decide for themselves which career they want to follow. They know the subjects they like, and how well they're likely to progress within certain subjects. If they're anything like me, then they will only enjoy doing something they know they can cope with. It's never good to "force" a child to do anything, because they will rebel, and their future will be ruined. I think the best way is to discuss with them what they want to do, and then discuss with their teachers which subjects they think my child will excel in and whether those subjects would be helpful in my child's chosen career.
Brightest Blessings.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
you are right so its better left with the kids to make up their mind they also want tyhe best for themselves as much as we also do
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
yes they have to decide cos they know what they enjoy doing beyond our own resoning and like you said you will always enjoy doing what you know best and not what you are forced to do,i used to hate mathematics cos i was bad at it but with a little encouragement from my parents i fell in love with it and now i still enjoy anything numerical but i was not forced to do anything
1 person likes this
@meljessxena (2315)
• Australia
28 Feb 08
my parents never tried to force me into studying anything i didnt want to, they priased me with whatever i wanted to do and accepted it. i studied hospitality but later on decided not to, i am now studying and working in childcare and love it, they are very happy for me. when i have children i will allow them the same as what i grew up with, letting them making their own choices on careers that they want. if i was to choose they may end up unhappy and hating me.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
its a good thing that we have parents who understood the idea of the child"s freedom in the choice of a career in fact when i told my father i dont want a paid job again all he told me was i support you and he advised me on some other issue like discipline in finances and sincerity to clients
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
you are also correct but even if your child is still very young you will be surprised that suddenly she is already 18 soi its ok to already know what to do from now,dont you think so?
@squaretile (3778)
• Singapore
29 Feb 08
I guess I have heard of so many stories. I had a friend who said that her father told her that there were only three respectable professions - doctor, lawyer or engineer.
she became a doctor.
Personally I think I would allow my kid to choose. so long as it is a decent career, something he is interested in, and something that hopefully will help him to support his family. that should be sufficient. i think parents should not have too much input into what the kid studies. ultimately we can guide but the choice should be the kid's because he will have to live with that decision for life, and you don't want him to be blaming you for life.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
i totally agree with you though there are times a child does not really know what to choose i think at this point you as a parent can write a list based on your experience or observation of your child"s career inclination and discuss with himn or her on how to choose then the child will feelcarried along in decision concerning their lives this makes them to want to succeed at all cost
@Suresh1972 (17)
• India
27 Feb 08
My idea is to give full freedom to my daughter to choose what she want to be. I will just guide her in this. Acutally we need to give freedom to our kids to select their future.Then only they will get satisfaction in their future life
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
28 Feb 08
yes suresh1972,you are right if we give good guidance to kids at a early age the tendency is for them to know what to do when they grow up but a child left to him/herself will definitely make bad decisions both in the present and the future
@sadraz (9)
• India
28 Feb 08
Till the class of 12th, parents guide is very important for each child. After that they will turn to right position.
@julyteen (13252)
• Davao, Philippines
28 Feb 08
that's a good opportunity you have experience...i think the only responsible to decide what career to take up is you...because will be the one to struggle the consequences with regards to your studies...parents role is to guide not to dictate... they will support through financial and moral aspects...
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
you know i have heard of parents telling their kids that they will withdraw their financial support if the kids will not do what they want and its so funny i wonder what they expect those kids to become
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
thanks but some parents dont think the children can make good decisions on their own especially the over bearing parents,some will go as far as withdrawing their financial support if the child wants a career different from what they want them to choose,what about that?
@subha12 (18441)
• India
28 Feb 08
I am single and do not have children in my case the freedom was f=given to me to choose my career. and that is the way i did too. but nowadays it seems children are pressurized to choose the career of their parents choice.It is not at all correct i guess.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
28 Feb 08
yes even while single i think its ok to know a few things to do so that you are equipped for when you are married and as for the career choice you have made a good decision
@lordwarwizard (35747)
• Singapore
28 Feb 08
I am not a parent myself yet but I think the child should decide his own career.
It is alright and in fact ideal for the parents to provide him with career advice but that's that.
Parents should be mentors, advisers, guides but never dictator - not unless you want the child to hate you - yes, this is so even if you are "right" (though "right" is really very subjective. :P).
So ultimately, let the child decide. So if he needs to blame anyone, he can only blame himself.:P
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
good point there,am sure your kids to be are in for a great time,as parents we are supposed to mentors,advisers and not God or a dictator,it breeds anger in the children abnd ultimately hatred
@michele_villasenor (624)
• Philippines
27 Feb 08
Being a parent myself, I think it's best to let your children decide for themselves. It's their lives anyway so let them have it, enjoy and make the best of it. Our role is to support them-morally, financially, emotionally, spriritually. Besides, if they follow their heart's desires they are more likely going to succeed because they will work towards what they want and not just what is being dictated to them. It would be more fulfilling for them that way.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
27 Feb 08
yes you are very right and its actually passion that brings the best success whatever you enjoy doing can never become a stress or problem as long as you are enjoying it so lets give the kids the chance to determine what their careers will be with prayers they will chosse right
@violeta_va (4831)
• Australia
27 Feb 08
I was also very lucky because my parents not only didnt influence me in my choice but also stood by me and suported my decision. I aslo had a friend that was under presure to study law but she wasnt that good of a student and didnt get the marks needed she was in war with her father every day because of this. Today she is into banking and is totaly obsesed with career and money and all that (not my kind of person).
My son will be free to choose his career and I will suport him all the way.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
27 Feb 08
i guess we happen to be amongts the very few people who have been allowed a choice in matters concerning our future congratulations and with regards to the kids please make sure you watch them and see where their interest lies and encourage them in it,my 7 year old daughter seems to have something about singing,each time she is close to anything micrphone or musical instrument she picks it up and pretend to be playing or singing,she asked to be enrolled in a music school i did that without thinking twice and i also encourage her to see other areas but without force but i must say she seems to be doing fine if she wants to sing am with her all the way
@ayou82 (3450)
• Philippines
27 Feb 08
Well I always want to follow what the kids want to be when they reach the right age for them to have choices.. im just here to guide them but not manipulate them in everything because I dont want them to be hurt or deprive them on the things they want to do.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
27 Feb 08
yes i quite uderstand you sometimes they need to make decisions on their own and also get things done without being manipulated but well guided by us its gives them a sense of responsibility from the start
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
even if your daughter is still so young dont be surprised that before you know it she is suddenly 18 and no longer the child you use to know and what do you do if you are not prepared?
@jervischin (17)
• Singapore
27 Feb 08
i think that child's career should be determined by themselves, is not for their parents. Because every child's personality and habit is different, if their parents force own child to learn something, then it will bring negative effects to these child, so i think that's very important for being determined the child's career by themseleves.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
28 Feb 08
the child"s career is their own personal future and as such the best a parent can do is to watch and understand the personality of each child then guide them in the best manner in a choice of career
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
29 Feb 08
well i hope you are not talking about dictacting their career choice because if that is what you are saying you will abusing their rights,it may become a problem in the future but if its a bout advise and guidance based on your experience you are on the right part
@izathewzia (5134)
• Philippines
27 Feb 08
It should be our children who will determine their careers and not us parents. We are just here to tap their potentials, cultivate it, and guide them a long the way. But it is still our children that should decide what career they want for themselves.
@BYOLA2871 (4371)
• South Africa
27 Feb 08
i totally agree with you and i ts just unfortunate that some parents try to make their children choose what they want without considering what the interest of these kids lie in and i have also discovered that no matter your qualification,talents and passion play very important roles in children"s success
@kdhartford (1151)
• United States
2 Mar 08
I think that I'm going to let my children decide for themselves. I think that is has worked OK for me. I'm just about finished with one career and woving into another...won't it be great.
I definately see my children leaning toward one or another occupation. My son is definately leaning toward an inclination toward history and my daughter toward working with animals. I will support them and guide them into doing something that will allow them to actually get paid, but other than that I want them to do what they are inclined to do.