What Are The Pros & Cons Of Renting Out A Spare Room? & Would You?

@ellie333 (21016)
April 20, 2008 2:08pm CST
If money were tight and you had a spare room in your home would you consider renting it out by getting a lodger or do you enjoy the privacy of your home more. If you already rent a room out within your home do you regret having done so or do you really enjoy having someone else live there with you and the extra income? What are the advantages and disadvantages? Please share. Ellie :D
5 people like this
21 responses
• United States
20 Apr 08
I couldn't let a stranger share my home. Just couldn't do it.
3 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
20 Apr 08
My nan used to have a lodger but that was years ago when people were more trusting and trustworthy. I don't think I could either as I love my privacy too much but there are a lot that do very successfully. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Ellie :D
2 people like this
@kezabelle (2974)
20 Apr 08
Personally no im not sure I could I dont think I could share my home with a complete stranger no matter how tight money was id rather work two jobs I think. I like my own space and like to be able to do my own thing I would have to be dressed and such like at all times and thats just not me if I want to lounge in my pjs all day then I want to do that without fear of some stranger sitting there watching me id feel too uncomfortable!
3 people like this
@kbourgerie (8780)
• United States
21 Apr 08
I haven't had real good luck with roommates. It always starts out on a good foot, but always ends on a bad one, even if its ended amicably. I had a roommate when I was 7 months pregnant with my second son who after only several months decided she wanted to move in with an ex-boyfriend. It left me high and dry and I had to move into a homeless shelter, where I might add, I ended up bringing my second son home to. I'd be hard pressed to consider that situation again.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
Thanks for sharing your experiences and thoughts on this one. I was only toying with the idea but it is a definate no no now from some of the responses I have received yet my nan had a lodger successfully for years and it was company for her too. How awful for you and your son to have been left in this situation. Ellie :D
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
I definately am not now so no worries there. Ellie :D
@KAYLLA (11)
• United States
21 Apr 08
I have thought of renting a room out later after all family is gone but it does nOt sound safe...That's terrible you ended up like that preg. then had to go back with an infant, Can't belive she just left you without thinking about what would happen to you. ...on the bright side you had a roof over your head..hope lifes treating you better now days
3 people like this
@olivemai (4738)
• United States
20 Apr 08
I would only rent a room to someone if I knew them very well, and was sure that I was not going to be hiding them out from the police! I have seen and heard of women who did not realize that they were actually aiding and abetting the hiding of someone wanted for crimes committed in the last five years! So I would be very careful!
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
20 Apr 08
My nan had a lodger for years but it was good because she had a bit of company but that was many years ago and there world was quite the way it is now so I agree it would have to be someone known very well. Well for me it would have to be because I also have to consider my children. I think I like my privacy too much to be able to though. Thank Olivmai for sharing your thoughts on this one. Ellie :D
2 people like this
@olivemai (4738)
• United States
21 Apr 08
For family, it may be easier!
1 person likes this
@littleowl (7157)
21 Apr 08
hi ellie-interesting discussion but even though i may be short of money i like my home to be my castle so wouldn't entertain having a lodger as it would intrude my space-the one way that assures me is that though my son lives with me he pays rent but lives his life and i do my own thing we never get under each others feet whereas having a lodger or stranger in my home would be an invasion of my privacy to me-i would rather just live on my own even if it was difficult-blessings littleowl
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
I know exactly where you are coming from on this one Littleowl and I also enjoy my privacy, it is different with your own children, but a stranger, no way. I also would rather struggle a bit than rent a room out. I was toying with the idea but it is now a definate no. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this one, much appreciated. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@littleowl (7157)
21 Apr 08
hi ellie-am glad to help am sure other mylotters will of done-many blessings littleowl
2 people like this
@tessah (6617)
• United States
20 Apr 08
im still looking for a decent boarder.. lol the two ive had in the past went very very badly, and they were tossed to the curb rather quickly. the first one after 3 months when i found out he was attempting to get my then 11 year old child into his room at 2am.. the other lasted 8 days and got pitched into the streets in the middle of the night when one of my friends finally tld me hed sexually assaulted her. no tmuch luck with the boarders for damned sure.. ;sighs;
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
20 Apr 08
I don't think I would even attempt to have another after those experiences. Whooaah I think I would have personally castrated the first one and maybe even the second one too. My nan had a lovely lodger who was company for her really and never had any problems but that was many years ago and times have certainly changed. I think I am too selfish and enjoy my own space too much to have one and as I have children also, no way now. Thanks for sharing, sorry you have had such a bad time with lodgers. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@tessah (6617)
• United States
20 Apr 08
my nan as well had boarders off and on for years, and they were alwyas very nice. we arent actively hunting down anyone to rent the extra bedrooms.. but we leave the option open for when someone happens to need a place to be and has no where else to go. maybe someday we get lucky. after all, these two arent the entire population, right? theres decent people out there too.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
20 Apr 08
Oh yes there are definately a lot of good guys and gals out there, but the baduns make it difficult at times don't they. I think I'll just leave my room available for friends visiting or emergency staying though for now. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@venshida (4836)
• United States
21 Apr 08
I have never done it. I think it can be difficult sharing her home with a family member sometimes, and a stranger would be worse. If you decide to do it, I would suggest someone you are familiar with.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
I was only toying with the idea but having read the responses so far I think it is a definate no no now, thanks for sharing your thoughts on the situation, much appreciated. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@jennifer611 (2514)
• United States
21 Apr 08
I have rented out rooms a few times and will say for sure that I definitely will NOT be doing that again. people like to take advantage of other people too much and I am just tired of having to deal with that. either they don't pay their rent or they steal or don't know how to treat the children that live here. I allowed on different occasions family and friends to rent a room. family stole from me, didn't pay rent, would eat my families food without even thinking of replacing it. left messes through the house. I mean they stole money, my puppy and my son's clothes. one friend I let stay here decided that she would go out about every night and leave me to watch her kids. she didn't pay me to watch them or anything. even on school nights I was watching them and it was hard because they wouldn't listen and would keep my kids up way past bed time and then they would be too tired to wake up for school in the morning. on nights she wasn't out partying she'd be going to the casino. I only received $20 for childcare ONE time. not only that, she'd have different guys in the house all the time and then get angry when my fiance speaks up and says he doesn't want them here. we do NOT want our children having that type of behavior around them, seeing someone bring different people in the house all the time, what kind of message does that send to them? and to her own kids?! but it was fine with her because they were "just friends"... I have a rule that visitors do not go to the upstairs for any reason. my children and myself sleep there and I just do not allow it. my family would wait til we were asleep and have people come over and be drinking and my 2 oldest sons told me that one night a lady they didn't know peeked her head in their door and was talking to them. oh I was so furious about that. finally I just kicked them out and threw their belongings out of my house. I will NEVER let anyone stay here again. it ends up being a bad experience each and every time.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
I was toying with the idea but after reading all the responses I have received so far including yours I definately will not be. People should have respect in your home and ths woman obviously had no respect for you, your home or herself from the sound of it! Thank you so much for sharing your experiences with me. I also have children and I would be very worried now about who to let in the home around them so I just won't. I also enjoy my privacy too much and from the sounds of it you don't get much of that either. I appreciate your input into this discussion it has certainly opened my eyes to how some people can be. Ellie:D
21 Apr 08
If we were that hard up for money, I would go back to work. I had my fair share of room mates when I was younger. You lose all your privacy. I've had one who "borrowed" something and they never returned it. The lady that used to live here had locks on all her doors including her own bedroom. That is no way to live. If we had to rent out a room, it would only be to a close friend. Too much violence in the world to trust a stranger in your home. You never know who they will bring into the house.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
I do work, I am also raising three children on my own so it was just a thought I was toying with but one I will not do. I will just cut back even more in certain areas rather than bring a stranger into the home, my nan successfully had a lodger for many years and it was also company for her but in this day and age you never know who you may get even though I am sure there are many good people out there looking to rent a room as they cannot afford to rent a whole place on their own. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experiences regarding this subject. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@stephcjh (38473)
• United States
21 Apr 08
I would consider renting it out but I sure would hate to lose my privacy. I wouldn't like the wear and tear on my home either. I have never rented a room in my home but I have let family stay with me and it invades your privacy after a while, even though you want to help them out. There is also extra wear and tear on the home at the home owners expense. The income we got was not really extra. It went to utilities and repairs.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
Yes I think I value my privacy more and the wear and tear on the home was something I hadn't considered. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this one, appreicated. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
• United States
20 Apr 08
Hi, Ellie! My personal choice would be to try EVERYTHING I can before renting a room. I would have a yard sale and get rid of everything I haven't used in the last year or so. I am actually about to do this soon myself to pay for a mission trip. I have had roomates before and while for the most part it was positive, it can put a strain on your friendship if you don't openly decide on some ground rules up front. Ground rules can feel awkward if you're good friends. If you are renting from someone from you don't know, I would strongly suggest first asking people you know and trust for referrals. If it has to be a complete stranger, check LOTS of references! Again, ground rules come in handy here, too.
@ellie333 (21016)
20 Apr 08
Thanks chicospagal, your advice is really apprecicated, it was just a thought than ran through my head as a way to get extra income but I realise that I am far too private a person to want to open my home to another other than family. My nan had a lodger once but that was good as it was company for her and in my teens I rented a room so I will try to cut back and make in other ways. Ground rules are a great thing. My eldest is at uni sharing with three others and from day one they set up a house account and a cleaning rota system so there would be no arguements and it works great. Hope you raise some good funds for your mission trip. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
• United States
21 Apr 08
I rent a room to a friend. He pays friend rent. He does not pay utilities. He does not pay for cable or internet. He pays way too little and is disinclined to go out on his own. My personal advice.. don't offer a friend a low rent. My friend has avoided moving out because he doesn't need to. The market is such that a wise person would buy their own house, but it is easy for him to remain in mine. Going from $300 a month rent to something like $1000 is hard to justify. And, in the meantime, I wish I didn't have to tiptoe around my friend weird sleep hours and excessive need for quiet from my daughter in the morning.
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
Oh I would hate to have to tip toe around my own home and how to keep a child quite, that just isn't possible and especially in the mornings when they are so full of energy. I was toying with the idea but have decided not to. Your frined is basically gettin a free ride then eh! I would be inclined to have a conversation and unless a price increase give a months notice I expect they'll agree to pay more because for somewhere else they will need to find a deposit and pay a much higher rent plus their share of the bills eh! Good luck and thank you for sharing this information and the thoughts on the subject, much appreciated. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@rombi001 (941)
21 Apr 08
You would definately have to do a background check on that person. Especially if you have children in the house or even teenagers.. Also make sure that he/she will blend in with your family and that his/her friends will feel comfortable around you. If you like different experiences I would say it is nice to have a different face in the house for a while...
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
No you are right it is not a risk I would want to take as I have young children and teenagers in the house and even with careful vetting you never know these days eh even though my nan had a lodger for years which was mainly for company as she didn't like being in the house on her own once I had left. I think it would be slightly different if it was just adults in the house. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@lynettebyc (2416)
• China
21 Apr 08
i don't have a spare house, so maybe i'm not suitable here for such a discussion. but as a lodger who rents house, i'd like to share u sth. renting a house u have to strike ur luck, if you come across a good lodger, your house will become much better than it used to be. my former landlord rent me a house, it was very dirty, i rent at 550 CNY a month, i cleaned the house everyday for the first 1 or 2 months. the moment i left, he rent his house at 650CNY, increase by 100CNY, money's not that very important, and the price rises all the time, but find a lodger who cherishes your house is very comfortable and delight. on the contrary, what if the lodger don't clean your house for 2 years? i met this, i've just changed the house, and it's in a mess~~~~ in fact, it's the house for wedding, after 2 years dispoal at random, it's nothing. heart breaking~~
2 people like this
@ellie333 (21016)
21 Apr 08
Thank you Lynette your experience in this situation has been very helpful and I appreciate you sharing this as a renter yourself. It can be heartbreaking when your home is abused but you can also be lucky and get someone like yourself who is going to appreciate it and make it better. I was toying with the idea and have now decided against anyway as I like my privacy too much. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
21 Apr 08
There are good advanages and bad advanages, If you get a long with the person that is a good thing, but people change once you get to living with them, you never know a person untill you live with them, that is for sure.
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
22 Apr 08
Well that is good, No you shouldn't if ou have kids, and if he is a Man. No you might trust him but I still don't think it is a good idea.
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
22 Apr 08
I read your comment on another response and can really appreciate where you are coming from on this but I will not be renting a room out now as I really don't want to put myself or my children in a vulnerable position. Ellie :D
@ellie333 (21016)
22 Apr 08
Thanks, I would be irresponsible allowing some to rent around the children. Ellie :D
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
21 Apr 08
the advantages is extra money, companionship, but the disadvantages could be many, the person does not life the same lifestyle with as you do, they are dirty you are clean, they are rowdy you are quiet, or you just don't get along. the trick is to screen the people you have stay with you, lay down the rules of your house before you even allow them to move in and kick them out if they don't adhere to it the first time it happens the longer you wait the harder it will be to do it later on. I have friends who rent rooms to help pay the mortgage they have been doing it for years and usually rent rooms to the foreign students at the university. They say it has its ups and downs. each roomer is different but to lay the ground rules in the beginning is easier all the way around.
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
22 Apr 08
Oh yes Winterose I think ground rules are a definate must. I was toying with the idea or renting a room out as everything is going up in price these days expect for the income but having read a lot of responses and their bad experiences I think I value my home and my privacy more and of course that of my children. My nan had a lodger for years but that was also many years ago and it was company for her too but it seems times have changed a bit and people arne't as respectful of others homes anymore. I am pleased that your frineds manage successfully to rent out rooms but like you say it has not been without its ups and downs. Thank you for sharing. Ellie :D
• United States
1 May 08
I've wanted to find a roommate for a year now but unfortunately my home was not really in livable condition (I could deal, but I doubt anyone else could! ). Now I'm forced to leave, move somewhere else and to get a roommate, after living alone for the last 13 months (my daughter chose to live with her father ). I'd do my best, try to find reliable roomies (people who could pay the rent--I don't need to be friends) and learn to deal with the changes. It's really not dissimilar to being single and then getting married--you learn to compromise.
• United States
2 May 08
Having a little one does make it more difficult! In my case, my 'little one' is nearly 15 and just short! If you had a 'mother-in-law' apartment (separate entrance) it would be that much easier, but those are generally reserved for those with larger homes. Good luck!
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
2 May 08
Thanks scorpiobabes, no I haven't a separate entrance and my son is only four, but my 15 year old stayed with her dad when I moved to finish her schooling, I think a lot of fifteen year olds clash with mum and like to spend more time with dad at that age, she'll be back bless, mine was. Ellie :D
@ellie333 (21016)
1 May 08
Thanks for sharing scorpiabes. I have decided against now as I have a little one and I'd have to be so sure of the person I took in to rent the room. I hope you get your situation sorted. Ellie :D
1 person likes this
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
21 Apr 08
If I am really tight and I know the person, I am open to allow any of my friends to rent it! But, I have to know the person better, I should know her best! Then give some rules to still keep my privacy and of course, my things too! I don't like to share my things but I would rather give if I have extra but not share it!The good about it, I will have an extra income plus I have also company if ever I am alone.Disadvantages, no 100% privacy and you will always consider the person in everything you do!
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Apr 08
I see...Well, I understand for your decision, it is very risky really to accept lodgers in our house! But, I rented for like 12 years in my life since we are far from the city and I went to College and finally landed a job after College, we were like 6 females in a room and its fun! The common problem is attitude, considering different personalities and different way of raising! But, it was a great experience! I learned a lot from it!
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
22 Apr 08
Yes my daughter is at uni as she shares a house with three others and loves it. I rented a room when I was younger to but I think inmy position it is probably best not eh! Thanks again. Ellie :D
@ellie333 (21016)
22 Apr 08
Hi Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. I think my need for privacy would outweigh my need for extra income and although I am considerate of others I wouldn't want to have to worry in my own home, can cope for visitors for a while and the compromise but long term no and also reading some of the bad experiences a lot of people have had including people that were friends and family I really don't think I will be latting a room out now. Ellie :D
29 Apr 08
I have rented a spare room and would again if money was tight. Generally speaking if you are careful about who you rent to and get references and such like, there isn't normally a problem. Obviously you take extra precautions if it is someone you do not know. I had a lock put on my bedroom door so I could lock away private papers, money etc. And firm house rules should be set down even before the agreement begins regarding food, bills, guests etc. It is not for everyone, but it can really help at times when the extra income would really help.
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
29 Apr 08
It is refreshing to hear a positive experience of room letting as some of the responses have been through such ordeals when having rented out a room. It makes sense to keep private papers etc locked away. I think firm rules from the start is a very good piece of advice. I think I value my privacy too much to actually do it but I will never say never. Thank you so much for sharing. I really appreicate it. Ellie :D
• United States
17 Jul 08
Thank you for sharing -finally!!!- a positive experience. We are not all in the position to just be able to go get a part-time job to make ends meet. I will not be able to make ends meet even with a full-time and a part-time job and unless I rent a room out, I will probably end up losing my condo. I got laid off last year from a job that paid me well enough so that I did not need to rent a room, get a part time job, or lose my condo. Times are different now, for me, and believe me, I am in the same boat as all of you - I cherish my privacy and love living alone. Come on - who WANTS to share their house??? Nobody - unless the choices are: 1) do I want to lose my house because I'm too stubborn to rent a room out or 2) do I want to rent a room out? I chose #2. For those of you who say you don't care how tight your budget ever got, you'd still never consider renting a room out, well then, let me just tell you this - when you're considering working a full-time job along with 2 or even 3 part-time jobs and come to the conclusion that you can still not make ends meet without losing your house, well, THAT is the type of "tight" budget I'm referring to. If you're not in that boat, then all the more power to you to get to live in a house without a renter. Lucky you!!
1 person likes this
@ellie333 (21016)
17 Jul 08
Hi Yes mummyof three was very positive and I thank you for agreeing and putting postive experiences and the necessities sometimes of having to share your home with others. Ellie :D
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
23 Apr 08
I rented my spare room when i lived in the city. I found it very frustrating because the individual didnt clean up after themselves, it was hard to get the rent money from them and...I couldnt leave certain things out in the main areas of the apartment for fear they'd go missing. I also shared an apartment later on with my sister and That was a bad idea because without our mom to intervene we clashed alot. It took about 3 years AFTER we werent sharing an apartment to be able to do things together again without coming to blows over some minor thing.
@ellie333 (21016)
23 Apr 08
That must be so awkward not being able to relax in your own home and not be able to leave your personal things laying around and also its ok if you leave a mess but for someone else too thats really annoying. Thank you for sharing. Your sister was porbably was harder to live with as you knew each other so well, 3 years is a long time to resolve things eh! I am pleased that you have though. Ellie :D
@saundyl (9783)
• Canada
24 Apr 08
I'm glad we did too. I dont think i'd ever live with her again and shes said the same of me.
1 person likes this