The unoriginal question
By ladym33
@ladym33 (10979)
United States
April 30, 2008 8:30am CST
OK, I will ask the unoriginal question, that must be asked each week. Who do you think will go home? Or who do you think should go home? I say Jason or Brook I like them both but they have both gone as far as they can go, and we are not going to see anything more out of them. I like how they sound, I think Jason's voice is beautiful, and I would buy a CD if he makes one, but he is never going to step out of his safety circle. I like Brook as well, but she is not capable of doing more than she has.
4 responses
@thedaddym (1731)
• United States
2 May 08
I like David Cook, if anyone else wins I will be very disappointed, sorry I got in on this late, but I thought either Brooke or Jason should go. Jason just does not seem to give a crap.
@above31rubies (1863)
• United States
30 Apr 08
hehehe...I was signing in to post this same "unoriginal question" but you are right- one that simply must be asked. 
I hope..yet again...that Syesha goes. I will not be surprised if it is Jason or Brooke- though I love them both. I will be shocked if either of the Davids were to leave (as I believe is the general consensus from pretty much everyone).
I think Brooke did awesome last night- especially on her second song. She has been a huge favorite of mine (though disappointing on occasion) but after her second song last night I poked hubby and said "...and THAT is why she's in the top 5!" lol.
It will be interesting to see who goes. Though, like another poster mentioned and I said yesterday, I don't think it matters much in what order the generally accepted "bottom three" (Brooke, Jason, and Syesha) go from here.
I hope..yet again...that Syesha goes. I will not be surprised if it is Jason or Brooke- though I love them both. I will be shocked if either of the Davids were to leave (as I believe is the general consensus from pretty much everyone).
I think Brooke did awesome last night- especially on her second song. She has been a huge favorite of mine (though disappointing on occasion) but after her second song last night I poked hubby and said "...and THAT is why she's in the top 5!" lol.
It will be interesting to see who goes. Though, like another poster mentioned and I said yesterday, I don't think it matters much in what order the generally accepted "bottom three" (Brooke, Jason, and Syesha) go from here. @thedaddym (1731)
• United States
30 Apr 08
I agree with you. It should be one of those two. But based on past shows who knows what will happen.
@natgil (33)
• United States
30 Apr 08
Well, I'm not sure that I agree with that.. I do think that it's time for Jason to go home though. To me, he's way too mellow, I've yet to hear him sing something that really WOWs me. I think he really doesn't care if he stays or goes. I think this week it's going to be either Jason or Syesha that leaves...
I think at this point in the competition, it's going to be David Cook in the top 2. I'm not sure who else though....
It will be interesting to see who goes home tonight...
