Do you think children should be a part of the decision making in your family?
By tjades
@tjades (3591)
Jamaica
May 3, 2008 11:50am CST
I remember family time being a regular part of my family since childhood. We would gather together and discuss family issues.
I cant remember those sessions being used to and humiliate anyone. There was some heat at times leading to anger and tears but it was all about expressing ones self and having a say in what was happening.
We learnt from early the financial standing of the family and did not make over the top demands. We learnt to be satisfied with what we had. We laughed and talked alot.
We also got to help make family decisions or at least say how we saw it from a child's pespective. I loved that.
Even as adults we find ourselve gathering for impromptu family meetings were we reflect on where we are and discuss issues and give advice. It still gets heated sometimes but I just love the fact that we have those family times.
Is it like this in your family where the children are involved in the decision making process?
Do you think such a practice is valuable in family life?
4 people like this
21 responses
@rev1wendy (611)
• United States
4 May 08
Most definitely!! We are parents to teach our children. How are they supposed to make good, sound decisions if they are never taught?
1 person likes this
@rev1wendy (611)
• United States
4 May 08
I taught my kids from an early age that there are decisions to be made in life that will have a great impact on your future. There are now all in their mid twenties an continually bring honor to me and the way that I raised them.
1 person likes this
@edgyk8inmomma (2157)
• United States
4 May 08
Yes, this is very valuable and a regular occurence in my family. I think it is extremely important to include the kids in any major decision. It gives them a taste of what life is really like, and helps them understand why things change when they do.
When I first started dating my fiance, it was my girls who came to me and asked about him being around. As we got more serious and they started form a bond with him, they came to me and asked if they could call him dad. They knew their father and knew he wasn't their father, but felt a connection with him. I left it up to him and the kids. Well, now they are all so very close I wouldn't dare anyone to say they aren't his kids. If your feet didn't get stomped on by one of the kids, or your shins kicked, you'd get something from him as well. When we were trying to decide whether or not to move out of state, they were involved in the whole process. ANd when we decided to buy a house, they had the final say yes or no to the one we chose.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
Your girls sound very confident of themselves and their place in this life and their family life.
Now that is what I am talking about. Kids who feel valued at home and are equipped with confidence and a good self estemm make much more grounded adults.
Adults always having the final say is just not practical if we wish to involve our children. We have to step back and allow them to have the final say and support them just as we would have them support the decisions we make.
Thanks for sharing Edgy. And keep that bond going strong as you pass it on.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
5 May 08
Yep. I realized the relation between you two from another of my discussions. I am really loving the mutual and free compliment flowing between you two. The way you speak of each other and the ups and downs of your lives are very encouraging. I wish you both the very best as you keep the fire of mother and daughter love alight.
@edgyk8inmomma (2157)
• United States
4 May 08
Most dinitely. It is very mportant to me to equip my kids for real life.
And by the way, I am one of those three kids the rev on the first page was referring to.
@djmarion (4898)
• Philippines
4 May 08
children although we think have no sensible reasoning should still be part of the decision making or at least their opinions should still be considered. i guess it will a good practice and will be beneficial to children in the future, by making them a part of discussion and asking their opinion we are teaching them the value of consulting anything to the family before doing it. this will also make them feel valuable and in return will value your decision and opinions when the time comes that they will be needing it.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
5 May 08
Hi Djmarion. As I shared with the poster before you I can clearly remember aspects of my life from as early as three years. I wouldnt say kids dont reason sensibly as my interaction with kids does not support that at all. They are unable to express themselves clearly but when we take time out to learn their pattern of of thought and speech then we realize just how much they are really paying attention to their sorroundings and how it affects them.
Yes. It does so much for them when they know their thoughts are valued and it makes it easier for them to seek advice before acting. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
@kbourgerie (8780)
• United States
4 May 08
Yes, I do think that this is a vital role for a child to play in a family. Obviously there are some issues that are beyond sharing with a child, but generally speaking, it makes the child feel like a valued member, it makes them know that their opinion counts and can teach a number of valuable lessons.
@jairgirl (2877)
• United States
4 May 08
hello tjades,
your family sounds like a perfect one, i know there is no such thing as perfect but i sure wish such thing happens in my family when i was a kid till now.
anyway, to answer your question i dont have a kid yet but my husband and i believe that our kid should be bale to express himself and be part to whatever we do in life and in our family.
we want our kid to know that we value their views and perspective in life.
a kid who can express himself with no problem seems to grow with much more respect about life and others point of view as well.
i feel that a kid who have such experience in family will not want to be always on the middle and push himself to hear what he says.
such practice at home is so valuable and will make him a better person in the end.
my husband and i would like our kid to reason and stand up for what is right and fight for it. we believe in freedom of speech and a kid should practice that as well.
anyway, thanks for sharing such a wonderful and loving family of yours. it sure makes me wish to have one as well, oh well i can only hope to have it on my own in the future then.
takecare and good night!
@jairgirl (2877)
• United States
4 May 08
thanks for sharing again, yes such practice do really make you fully equipped to face the test of time in your life.
thank you for the compliment, i really hope i can have a better family than what i have i dont want my kid to feel cage nor he/she is not allowed to speak up like when i was growing up. i hope to give them a better future that will make them a better and loving human.
btw, you are right that a person always heard dont seem to be pushed easy by peer pressure, i am lucky to be smarter than others despite all that happened in my life and i am grateful that i didnt fall for that. i wouldnt be in a place i have right now if i did not follow my heart.
anyway, have a wonderful week and i wish you all the best.
takecare!
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
You are right when you say there is no such thing as a perfect family. We had a whale of a good time together yet we have so many thngs that went wrong.
The good times and good family practices helped to bring a balance. We still have our struggles now but bieng equipped to deal with them is what really matters.
The challenges in the family and the coming together to sort them out helped us as children to make better decisions in our social life and so were not overly pressured by many things that many of our peers struggled with.
You certainly have the right concept for involving your children in family decisions when they come along. It will certainly do all that for their self confidence and much more. Thank you for sharing your hopes and dreams with me here and all the best as you seek to expand your family.
@redkey65 (221)
• China
4 May 08
children should be a part of the decision making in family.
It can help them to be independent in future life. They will know more about the real world, and they will treasure the happiness and unhappiness in later life. It will make them more success later.
@lingli_78 (12822)
• Australia
4 May 08
absolutely... they are part of a family as well and as long as they are old enough to understand, they should be involved in discussions and have a say in making a decision in the family... this will help them to think maturely and grow up as well... my parents always involve me in the decision since i am a child and i grow up to be a responsible and much wiser person now... have a nice day...
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
5 May 08
It really does a lot for a childs confidence when parents consult them and take their input seriously. Of course they dont always make very concrete imputs but its a principle that is being instilled in them and it really makes a difference to them. Thanks for sharing Lingli. (lol)
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
5 May 08
Thanks for sharing Sahyd2don. I am curious though as to why you think kids should not be involved in this manner.
My nephew is just six years old but his level of reasoning is amazing. He may not be able to clearly express himself but we do run certain things by him especially if it will directly affect him. His little input makes a world of a difference sometimes and he's not shy of letting us know when he doesnt like something. If it cannot be help then we explain to him why it has to be that way. The look on his face at being involved in this manner and the confidence and trust he has in coming to us about anything is worth a lifetime of happiness.
We had this experience as children and have always cherished it. We would never deny him. Sometimes his ideas are not workable but we find a way to use it or respectfully expplain why it cant be used.
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
4 May 08
yes our boys were always included in Family conferences. Everyone had an input and it was a fun time for everyone. Kids like to feel needed and will do their best to help in any situation. Problems between parents are better solved in Private as Marriage is a private arrangement between 2 people.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
4 May 08
Yes, I think allowing my girls to be a part of the decision making helped not only make us closer and helped them to feel more a part of things but it also helped in their decision making skills. Every thing i did affected them in some way so it was important for us to discuss things. Of course the final decision was mine but I always listened to and considered their thoughts. They also knew about my finances etc. Some people thought that was horrible but I will tell you, it was realistic and it helped them to understand why I could not buy certain things. Yes, family meetings occured pretty regular in our home.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
Theres nothing terrible about letting your children in on your financial standings at all. It certainnly helps them not to make demands that cant be fulfilled and I think it helps them to face the reality of what is and what is not. It has certainly helped me and as you related so too your girls.
The proof is in the eating so there the critics would have it. You are obviously very proud of your girls and so you should be if the fruits of your labour in raising them has helped them to be wonderful adults.
@dragonfly242 (1060)
• Bahamas
4 May 08
Sounds like a beautiful thing tjades.
Growing up my imediate family was small just my dad,sister,brother and me. But my dad also let us take part in some of the dicision making, and mostly called meetings when there was some dispute between us children.
I do the same thing with my kids because i feel that they should at least have a say in anything that effects the family. I feel that this is valuble to a family's unity, the family works together when they know that they can have an imput in certain decision making.
@ctyhhz (47)
• China
4 May 08
i think children is surely to be a part of the decision making in your family.
i am a child of my family,sometimes when the thing is related to me my parents will ask my view on that decision.but at most times they are always thinking that i am just a little boy knowing nothing!
that's not equal.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
5 May 08
And it does hurt a childs feelings not to be taken seriously. It is wrong for parents to tink this way of their children. I can still remember various aspects of my life from I was as young as 3yrs. To say something to my parents and have them put me down would hurt like hell. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
@melissacody (88)
• United States
4 May 08
To answer the question I absolutley feel like children should be a part of family decision making... to the point they are able to understand. Understanding where a child is coming from is essential to having a close relationship.
When I was growing up, my parents included my brother and I in decision making that we were able to definitively contribute to. Even if it came to decisions that my brother and I could not yet make, they included us in most everything and allowed us to know what they thought we could handle.
When I was 6 years old, my brother was 3 and my mom had just given birth to our baby sister. When she was 11 months old she was diagnosed with a rare form of childrens cancer. Our parents told us that she was sick and they were going to work closely with the doctors to try to make her better. We were always included at the doctors visits but they kept us away during the treatment, because watching what chemotherapy can do to a sibling can be frightening. They didn't want us to remember her that way.
After many treatments and surgery's the conclusion was made that she would not win her battle with cancer. My parents told us that they had done everything they could and the doctors did everything they could, and she wasn't going to get better. She was coming home.
When she came home we just enjoyed each others company and took a trip to disney, our last trip all together.
They made it so special for us.
My sister passed away at 23 months.
I can honestly say, that I have such great memories of my sister that had my parents not included me in what was going on with her, I would have resented them.
Now at 24, I have my own family, and 2 lovely little girls of my own. I find that I am letting my girls in on what they can handle, while still allowing them to be kids.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
That is great story to share Mellissa. Thank you for sharing it here. What your parents did is a very good example of including the children in family decisions rather than to just make the decisions and expect children to accept and follow without questions or doubts.
I am sure happy that have such happy memories of your baby sister. Good luck and God bless as you seek to bring up your two girls the best you can. (lol)
@maddymahir (90)
•
4 May 08
ya i do.definitely the children should be a part.but they should not be a decision maker.their suggestions must be asked.if so then it will be easy for them to take decisions when they are grown.so it is a serious thing take care of it.
@SunnySkies (93)
•
3 May 08
Family time is the most valuable thing that you can give your children. When I turned 50 I was very touched when my daughter got up and made a speech about how I was always available for her and her sister and even her friends made a comment that I was the one mom that never moaned to cart kids around.....
@Pose123 (21635)
• Canada
3 May 08
Hi tjades, I believe that children should be a part of family decision making. Family time is a great idea for all families, and while children can't be expected to understand situations as adults do, they should certainly be included. Stressing togetherness is important and facing problems together will certainly help the child. Blessings.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
Hi Pose. Yes. Family time should certainly an important part of our family life. I think it would certainly help to make everyone more socially responsible. And assisting with family decisions just seems to give a child a confidence in life that cant be beaten.
Thanks for sharing. (lol)
@kezabelle (2974)
•
3 May 08
If the choice being made is going to directly affect them then of course they should have their say although I do think as adults its ultimatley down to the parents to make the final choice and it always helps knowing how your children feel to come to the right choice.
Mine are only 4 and 2 so obviously big choices they have no say in but we often give them chances to make their own choices or help us to come a choice how else will they learn to make responsible decisions as they reach adulthood.
@Xdrowninghavocx (3117)
• United States
4 May 08
Children, depending on the age, should definitely be involved with making family decisions. And it also depends on what needs to be discussed as a family. How about moving, for example, if you don't have to move for a job related reason, just because you wanted to and your child doesn't want to leave their friends, shouldn't their be a conversation somewhere? My family didn't take enough time with me to include me in that particular situation. And I lost a best friend because of it. A child is very much a part of the family home.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
4 May 08
Thats avery valid point. So many times children end up being hurt and adults just view it as something they'll get over. Thats not always true and it is really better if parents can spare the time to listen to their children. We do learn a lot of things from children. Thanks for sharing. (lol)
@qtfrog99 (279)
• United States
3 May 08
I do believe that children should be included. When I was growing up my sister and I were always included and I feel that instilled us with the morals and values we use today. Now I am older I have a 20 month old son of my own and I love including him in on our discussions, especially since he is talking clearer every day. When I look back on my childhood one main thing I will never forget is every night we had dinner as a family and discussed our day, no tv, no videogames at that time, it was family dinner. That is something my fiance and I are instilling in our son too. We sit down and have dinner as a family every night.
@tjades (3591)
• Jamaica
3 May 08
LOL. What happy memories those momments bring. It really just becomes a natural part of you too so that you pass it on to your kids. With family values on a rapid decline we have to do our best not to fall victims to it. Good choice of family time I must say.
@yangjiaju (33)
• China
4 May 08
children play an important role in our family, so i think they should join in decision no matter things is important or unimportant.