Making a Loan to pay off another loan...

@aseretdd (13730)
Philippines
May 19, 2008 12:14am CST
Do you think it is right to make a loan to pay off another debt like credit card debt?... i have been thinking about this for quite a while now... since my bank is offering this loan scheme where the monthly interest is only 1.5% payable in 2 years... compared to the 3.5% of my credit card... that will surely save me like 2% from my credit card debt ineterest... Have you ever done something like this... did it work out for the best or did you regret it in the future... i would appreciate all the responses... i want to make up my mind real soon... before the bank offer expires...
3 people like this
18 responses
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 May 08
I don't think it's a great idea. If you are paying off one loan with another...your interest for the second loan also keeps building up and then you might have two sets of interests...and when banks offer interest...they 'forget' to tell you the loop holes of how the interest builds up. Even with a credit card, one has to be very careful. If you use it like cash and payback promptly every month...without leaving any balance, it works out great....but if you pay the minimum and then let the balance buildup and keep paying only the minimum every month, it works to a very huge amount...because most banks start calculating interest from the first day of credit (the first time you had balance). I know this person who took a loan of Rs 70,000 for his wedding...and he kept paying only the minimum amount after that...and now he's in debt...and the amount is Rs 1,96,000!!! So, do you have a debt on your credit card?
2 people like this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 May 08
I think i need to confirm everything with the bank first... before i finally decide... i don't actually just pay the minimum amount to be paid... it is just that... whenever i see the monthly interest... the more i want to close my credit card... and the only way i can do that is to pay the whole amount... which i cannot afford right now... thanks for the response...
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
19 May 08
So, you mean you want to take the bank loan to pay off the credit card debt at one shot and pay only the interest to the bank, right? Then it sounds like a better idea to take the loan...but pay that off soon too. But talk to the bank first and clear every doubt...make sure there aren't any hidden costs.
2 people like this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 May 08
That is what i plan to do... to pay off all my credit card debt so i can have the option to close it immediately... sorry if i did not clearly state that in my discussion... i will surely clear everything with the bank... i don't want to get in a lot of financial difficulties because of this...
1 person likes this
@longbangod (1785)
• Philippines
19 May 08
I think its better to apply for that loan. I'm sure it could help. 2% difference is already big money especially when you have high balance yet. Try to grab the opportunity. If I have that chance myself I will also do it at least I could free myself from my credit cards...
2 people like this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 May 08
It is indeed an opportunity... and since the interest is way too low compared to the credit card interest... i can use the money i will save to other important things... i will keep your advise in mind... thanks for the response...
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
8 Jul 08
If you are able to get out of the other loan completely and don't loan more money than you need for paying of the other loan then it might be a good idea getting a less high rent on it. I have never done something like this but I know people who have. Just make sure you read the fine print and don't end up loaning more then you are intended too.
1 person likes this
@cyberfluf (4996)
• Netherlands
9 Jul 08
That's even better, you're right. And a lovely thing of your father to do. This will save you a lot on interest and it's nicer to communicate with someone you know and love then with organisations you don't know and are just in there to earn a lot of money from you. All the best!
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
10 Jul 08
Yes, it is very nice of him... although it took a lot of guts to ask him for the loan... but i am just glad that i did it... so there is no pressure for me to pay him immediately... as long as i will pay him in the future...
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
9 Jul 08
I actually decided not to get the loan... since i was able to borrow some money from my father... and that is like the best thing because it is interest free... and i can pay him back on an installment basis... thaks for the response...
1 person likes this
@livvy092002 (1032)
• Philippines
19 May 08
I know many people who does just like that. It makes sense because like in your situation, it is right that you may save from the interest payments by 2%. So if a loan is made available to you which has a lower interest rate, you really have the option to avail it and pay off your higher interest rate loans. Much better if you pay loans from your income, in that way you really erased portions of your debts and try not to incur additional loans as much as possible. :-)
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
This sort of thing is very common in the US and European country... but not in my country... credit card use is fairly new... and i am glad that you pointed out the positive site of doing this... thanks for the response...
• United States
25 Jun 08
Or you could utilize government grant money instead of loans. I'm planning on using http://financialfreedomexpress.com I'll tell ya how it goes once I eventually start using it.
1 person likes this
@gr8life (6251)
• Malaysia
24 Jun 08
Hello aseretdd, I used many credit cards before but decided to withdraw all after getting married. My husband doesn't like me to have any as he knows pretty well how shopaholic I was *laughs* But, I have a friend who just did like what you are thinking to do. He has credit cards that due for payment and he couldn't came up with even the minimum payment for all the cards. He decided to apply loan to settle off his debt and just paying the only loan in future. It costs him less than all his minimum payments but it takes him years to settle it off. Here too, the credit card issuers come up with a flexi plan like transferring all the balance to one card and you just need to settle the balance of one of your cards with additional interest charge. For this one, I am not too sure whether it is good or not.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
24 Jun 08
The good thing about my credit card is that it is owned by one of the biggest insurance company in my country... so having it entitles me to a lot of insurance benefits... even for my family... i thought of having it closed... but decided not to... since i can always use it for emergencies...
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
24 Jun 08
I decided not to pursue that loan anymore... but i asked my father to lend me some money... to pay off some of my credit card debts... that is the best thing because that loan will not incur any interest... and i think i will refrain from using my credit card until such a time that the debt is almost paid off... i only have one credit card... so that is a agood thing... thanks for the response...
1 person likes this
@gr8life (6251)
• Malaysia
24 Jun 08
Hello aseretdd, That's good for you. In fact, if we don't use the card carefully, it is hard to refrain ourselves from the tempting of using the card *smiles* I had a hard time too when I used two or three cards in the same month. The banks involved were happy, I guess. I know that I can't have a card. It will be a disaster for me. I spent too much money to pay back and when I think of it now, isn't it good if I don't even spend at all. I might be a millionaire by now...
1 person likes this
@lovenluck (1068)
• India
19 May 08
Well there is no harm in doing it ,you have been thinking about it i have been practicing it for some time now I use one of mine credit to pay the other and again I use the first one to pay the second ,i just rotate the funds and for 6 months i have been using the banks money and I have not paid i single percent interest, cool for me ,just rotating funds.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 May 08
Okay... so you are a veteran in consolidating your debts... have you encountered any problems on this?... or has it eased your problem in paying of your credit card debts?... i am totally new at this so i desperately need advise... thanks for the response...
@stjmen (86)
• Australia
8 Jun 08
This is not really a safe practice. Eventually you will have used the limit of both credit cards as you slowly increase the amount of debt you have outstanding. If you are borrowing money, whether on a loan or a redit card, you eventually have to pay back the debt. In regards to the consolidation loan, if you are planning on borrowing the money, clearing the credit card and then cancelling the credit card, then it is a good plan and will indeed save you alot of money. If you plan to keep the credit card just for "emergencies" then it will not be long before you find you have two sets of debt and are further behind than you were previously.
1 person likes this
@checapricorn (16061)
• United States
19 May 08
I know it's not a good idea but I have actually tried that. I needed the money very much and at the same time, I wanted to clear out the other loan. It was hard but I survived, after that, I promised not to have 2 loans at a time. For you, I guess the best is agree with your partner and decide what is best, in that way, you are there to support with each other since, it was open, I mean he knows your transactions!
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
My husband knows all about my transactions... and i am quite responsible when i use my credit card... like i just use it to buy groceries and pay the bills... but right now... they got piled up... and the interest is eating away a lot of the payment i make... so if i pay up all my credit card debt... and close it... that might ease up our financial problem... since i will be able to save 2% interest... thanks for the response...
• United States
19 May 08
make sure that interest rate isn't variable,or you could end up paying more than you started with. some banks only keep it low for 6 months.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
I will surely ask about that... since i don't want to end up in more financial trouble... banks have a way of hiding other charges... unless one asks straight away... thanks for the response...
@psyche49f (2502)
• Philippines
19 May 08
It depends...if that other loan to pay off an old loan offers a better deal, then by all means, it is worth it. My daughter did that...she paid off her credit card through a loan from our local cooperative, which we found out does not slap horrendous penalties and hidden charges. So now, my daughter has since then closed her credit card line by paying it off; she's paying the cooperative instead, which computes interests on a diminishing balance, no hidden charges, and what you pay is returned through a patronage refund and the interest on savings is even higher. I have also done it, still through a loan from the coop and I had better peace of mind because the coop HELPS people, instead of sucking dry our pocket, the way credit card companies do.
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
I used to work in a school where we were all members of a coop... and just like the one you describe her... they gave loans at a very low interest rate with no hidden charges or penalties... but right now... i am not a member of any... so i can only avail of a bank loan... for sure i will ask all the necessary questions like if there are any charges or penalties... and if there are a lot... then i don't think i will avail of the loan... thanks for the response...
@amirev777 (4117)
• India
19 May 08
hi! i dnt think its a good idea to take a loan to pay off another loan coz u get trapped in a vicious circle frm where u find it difficult to come out of-this results in enormous continuos stress.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
This is why i haven't yet decided if i will take a loan to pay off my credit card debt... i thought of this vicious cycle... and still finding out a way not to be trapped in it... thanks for the response...
@julyteen (13252)
• Davao, Philippines
20 May 08
if you calculate the total interest you will be paying is lesser than paying your credit card much better if you loan from the bank for paying your credit card. sometimes we must be practical so that we can save money although we consider it as part of our expenses because the amount you are going to save can be used in other needs.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
21 May 08
I am really trying to think hard before i decide on this pursuing the loan... and a lot of those who responded said that there is a need to be responsible and wise and that they have already done such a thing... but right now... i am still undecided about this... thanks for the response...
@nice030481 (1109)
• Philippines
19 May 08
i did it once and it helps a lot, but i cant help using my credit card, coz we need to buy groceries, milk, diapers, etc. now my i have to pay another and i kept on thinking if i will balance transfer it again, so that i will less the finance charge of 3.5%.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
That is what i fear... i might be tempted to use my credit card again once i get the clean slate... so i plan to close it... i don't want more debts and interest to pay in the future... thanks for the response...
@neildc (17239)
• Lapu-Lapu City, Philippines
19 May 08
I have also a big problem with the bank regarding my credit card dues. The bank already passed the collection duty of my account to collection agents, mostly law firms. Just this afternoon, a personel from a financing firm came to our office and offering another loan, to settle my bank obligations. I didn't avail of their service, their offer. Simply because, I hate to pay the bank with another loan, still exist. Maybe, I pay the bank when I win the lotto.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
Well, i also dream of winning the lotto... but that is quite impossible since i rarely buy a ticket... good thing you did not avail of that loan... that might put you in more financial troubles... thanks for the response...
• China
9 Jul 08
Lots people do that!But i dont like that.I believe i should make sure my desire is under control.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
10 Jul 08
I actually decided not to go through with it... since i was able to borrow some money from my father without interest... so i was able to pay off some of my credit card debt... and there is no pressure for me to pay my father immediately... thanks for the response... welcome to mylot and i hope you enjoy your stay here...
@subha12 (18441)
• India
19 May 08
i think it is not so much good idea. in this case you are gain taking another loan. may be this new one you will take more time to pay back, this is recursive process I guess.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
In the new load... i have the option to pay it in 1 to 3 years... and the interest is quite low compared to the credit card... if i take that loan... than i would use to money to pay off all my credit card debts and then close it so that i won't be tempted to ever use it again...
@Neriz69 (1093)
• Philippines
19 May 08
I did that and it went fine for as long as you will not use your credit card again until the loan is fully paid. If you transfer your credit card debt to another and then continue to use your card then it defeats the purpose. It will get you more financial trouble.
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
I have been thinking about that too... and if ever i get this loan to pay off my credit card debt... i will be closing my credit card so that i won't be tempted to us it ever again... i do not want to get into more financial trouble... thanks for the response...
• United States
19 May 08
There's nothing wrong with that. It's called consolidating your debt and it the interest is lower you're saving a LOT of money. People do that all the time, it's the same thing as refinancing your house. I don't know why anyone would advise you against it, unless they don't know what they're talking about. Plus, with the lower interest you'll get it paid off more quickly.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 May 08
For Asian cultures... refinancing is not that common... could you imaging that not that many people in my country have a credit card... so at this point all suggestions are welcome... i have never done this consolidating of debt so i don't know what the future my hold if i push through with it... thanks for the response...
@ayessa (1583)
• Philippines
19 May 08
I think it can help you in a way. What i do to my credit card debt specially those who almost reached my limit is I balance tranfer it to another credit card and ask the other card company to make the payment in an installment basis in that way I can save money and it really worked quiet good to me since I can easily budget my finances well enough than to let debts just had interest.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 May 08
I didn't even know that that sort of thing is possible... but i cannot do what you are doing right now since i only have one credit card and i don't plan to get another one... i am glad that it is working out fine for your... thanks for the response...