Potty Training Isn't Working..

United States
June 24, 2008 3:27pm CST
I've been trying to potty train my 2 year old for about a month or so. He's not really picking it up well. He has gone on the potty a couple times, accidentally. I tell him to sit on it many times a day, but he will just cry because he'd rather go play, and the whole time he sits there all he says is "get up?". Sometimes the moment I let him up will be when he pees all over the floor. If I catch him mid-stream I will bring him to the potty and make him sit, but then he'll just hold it and wait until he's let up before finishing it somewhere in another area of the house. It's frustrating. Sometimes I feel like giving up, but I think that would be worse right now. I think I have to just keep pushing and eventually he will get it. Did anyone else have such problems when they began potty training?
4 people like this
20 responses
@Gemmygirl1 (2867)
• Australia
25 Jun 08
Ok, you really need to stop pushing, the more you push the more he'll not want to do it. If you continue to push you may scare him away from the potty completely & it'll take even longer. Obviously he just isn't ready to begin & he's trying to tell you that so you need to leave it for a little bit & let him take an interest in it, in his own time. If you insist on forcing him to go with it, perhaps leave the potty alone & put him on the toilet. My daughter has no interest in her potty & if she's nappy-less she'll just hold on until she's got a nappy on again. However, she will happily sit on the big toilet & has gone a couple of times. Also, from what i have heard, little boys are harder than little girls so if 2 is too young for my daughter then there's a good chance it's even more too young for your son, you're just not listening to him :) Don't stress about it & again, don't force it or you'll keep him from wanting to go at all on his own. He'll take an interest in it when he's ready & you should just sit back & wait for that time to come!
• United States
25 Jun 08
We tried to potty train our little girl starting around two years old, because it seemed the right time cause she didn't want to wear diapers anymore. But turns out she did not want to use the potty chair. She was very happy to use the big person's toilet though. And never got the hang of the potty chair. Maybe things are different for a boy. Maybe he doesn't like the idea of having to sit down. I'm not sure he's tall enough to stand up but he may think that is what he is supposed to be doing, especially if he has seen his older brothers standing up to use the potty to pee. Kids role model each other. Here are some useful links from the experts you might be able to use. Best of luck with your child. http://www.pampers.com/en_US/tools/page/potty_charts.do http://www.pampers.com/en_US/ltpt/home/ltpthome.html http://www.pull-ups.com/NA/melissajoanhart_journal.aspx
• United States
25 Jun 08
Beauty- Actually he's never seen any of the boys go, and I taught all my boys by sitting down first. They learn to stand later. I started by going with him and showing him how I do it, but have since moved the potty to the living room for convenience, as the bathroom is on the other side of the kitchen, and the kitchen is gated off to him for safety reasons.
• United States
25 Jun 08
I'm not actually pushing. I just re-read what I wrote, and where I said "keep pushing" I sort of meant that as keep chugging, you know, not really pushing him. My other kids were 3 and a half before they were trained, and they still weren't "showing an interest" although they did pick it up much quicker than this.
@Barbietre (1438)
• United States
24 Jun 08
Boys are harder to train and to be honest I think 2 is too early. I do not think your son really understands what is going on. Also some children do not have as much control of their spincher muscles... For bowel movements, as early as others. My son was not mentally ready until he was about 3 and a half because one day when my mother was watching him she decided he should be trained so she had a marathon type training day. Well he was so scared after that day he would not even look at one. But when I sensed he was ready I offered him a reward and he only had one accident after that ( because I was on the phone and when he said he had to go). And to me if a child has more than one or two accidents then they are not really trained, and any parents who claim they are trained are only fooling themselves. A child HAS to understand what they are doing. Not to be crude, but he should be noticing that his dad uses "the big potty" and want to copy him, that is a BIG motivator. Social cues are very important.
• United States
24 Jun 08
He's pretty smart for a 2 year old. I think he can understand the concept. I've trained 3 other kids, but none as early as him. When we began he seemed to get the concept and actually asked to go a few times, but has since done what I explained above.
• United States
25 Jun 08
I've seen those. Yuck!!
@Barbietre (1438)
• United States
25 Jun 08
They all have their own timetable. I hate when parents try to push them when they are not ready. I Know what my mother did was a big setback. His younger brother trained earlier than he did because I waited until he was ready. The joke is my Mom said I was trained at 18 months. But did you now in those days the high chairs had a potty seat on it..gross, all they did was "catch" it.
• Canada
25 Jun 08
I did the same thing to my son when he was about the same age as your son and I learned the hard way that he will go when he is ready to. DO NOT force him to go. he will go when he is ready and not a minute sooner. If you keep forcing him he will push against your attempts. My son is almost 6 and isn't fully potty trained now. My friends daughter decided one day at about 3 yrs old that she wanted to use the potty and guess what she had maybe one accident. So learn from my mistake and do not force him Hugs and best of luck
• United States
25 Jun 08
None of my other kids ever showed an interest in going. I started them all after they'd turned 3 and had almost the same struggles as I do now, only the other kids only struggled for a week or 2 before they got it. Then we struggled for a few months with number 2, but that is rather normal.
@littleone3 (2063)
24 Jun 08
I am finding the same thing happening with my two year old. He gets the idea what the potty is for but would rather wee on the floor then sit on it. He is at the stage when he will come and tell me if he needs a nappy change as he knows when he has pooed. But i am not too concerned as he is my fifth child and all my other children did it in their own time. I just leave the potty were he can see it so he knows its there if he feels like using it. I did that with all my children and the day did come when they decided that they wanted to use the potty. But there was a few accidents but that is something to be expected. I believe it is best to allow the child to do it in their own time as all children are different and develop at a different rate.
• United States
24 Jun 08
I agree, and that's pretty much how I did it with my older children. However this one is my 4th and my 5th is 5 months old. That means 2 pkgs of diapers each week! Hence the reason we started so early.
@jashley1 (746)
• United States
24 Jun 08
Hey, you're doing a great job! Try not to get frustrated - although I know this can be a long and drawn out process - but try to remain patient. I think the important thing to remember is to not "force" him to sit on the potty, but rather word it in an encouraging way so he thinks it's his choice. I found that when potty training my kids - they wanted to be independent and found it much more enticing to go when they got to decide when they wanted to go. I'd say things like "Mommy needs to go potty like a big girl, do you need to go too?" and then my daughter would be like "hmm yes!" and sit on there while I sat on there. Sometimes I'd let her sit on the portable one in the living room while watching tv just to get a feel of when she needed to go and then once she went I'd give her lots of praise and hugs and kisses. Just try to monitor his drinking and encourage him to just "sit" on it every few hours or according to his bladder needs...you know him best. Try to have your husband (if applicable) take him with him so they can go together. Try putting cheerios in the potty and then having him try to hit the cheerios when peeing..kind of a fun game and teaching him how to aim at the same time. I've trained two girls, and my son is now 7 months old so it may be different with him. If he resists all together try taking a break and then encouraging him to go again in a week or so. He has plenty of time! Hope this helps and stay encouraged...he will get it!
• United States
24 Jun 08
I've trained 2 boys and 1 girl, this is the 3rd boy I'm training, but the others weren't quite this difficult, they were also older. I have the potty in the living room with us for convenience, because the bathroom is on the other side of the kitchen, which is blocked off for safety reasons to him. We take a few breaks, I put diapers on him at bedtime of course, and when we go out. Sunday he had a diaper all day. I'm afraid that's only making him go backwards due to confusion. I will just keep chugging and eventually he will get it right. Thanks for your response. Have a great day.
@zhuuraan (961)
• United States
25 Jun 08
Haha cheerios! Thta's funny! lol I like that one and it's cute too! haha might have to pass that idea around a bit lol
@mclendon (308)
• United States
24 Jun 08
Rewards work best for potty training IMO. There are pullups around now that allow them to feel wet when they are wet. You could use those or training underwear and plastic pants so he can tell when he's wet. Then tell him you would like him to use the potty and that he will get a sticker (or some other small reward) when he uses it. You could give him a star on a chart and when he racks up a certain number of stars he earns a bigger reward, like an ice cream or something. The potty training should be a positive experience and not a negative one. When he goes in his pants, if you can get him to clean up or help clean up that will reinforce that going in the pants is more trouble and a negative thing. Don't fuss a lot or give him a lot of attention when he messes up,(little talking while cleaning up). The attention, even if negative, may reinforce the behavior. Instead, praise like crazy when he uses the potty and you give him a reward. You may have to just tell him and remind him about the reward potential for a few days in a row before he decides to use the potty. But try to get him to make the right choice himself and praise, praise, praise!
• United States
24 Jun 08
Of course I already do praise him when he does go on the potty, the few times that he has, and knowing that his accidents are just that, I don't do too much over them accept bring him to the potty. He's only 2 and won't understand the idea of rewards. His vocabulary and comprehension aren't quite that good yet. He's practically still a baby. Has this method worked with your kids? How old were they when they were trained?
@mclendon (308)
• United States
26 Jun 08
Yes, my son was potty-trained at age 2. I used a little potty chair and put a sticker on the back of it every time he used it. He was very excited to get a sticker. After the first few he wanted to put the sticker on himself. I think your two year old would understand a small reward for a "job" well done. My daughter was harder to train, but was pretty well trained by about 2 1/2. Pretty much the same method. With her, I would take her to the potty about 15 to 30 minutes after a meal and try to get her to try it. She had more accidents than my son, but still was well trained by 3.
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
25 Jun 08
There is a book out there by A child's author Mercer Meyer that in my opinion is great for helping get kids going on potty training. It is called "The New Potty (Look-Look)" May be if you can get your son to look at the book while he is on the potty it might help after you have read it to him. Just let him look at the book while he is on the potty. Amazon has it for $3.25 You can check out the style of books at http://www.littlecritter.com/index.html I just love these books so do my grown grandkids.
@moneyandgc (3428)
• United States
25 Jun 08
After readig your discussion it sounds as if your so is just not ready. I didn't potty train my children until they were 3 years old. I had my first son and second son in diapers at the same time. My older son trained and then their baby sister was born. So I still had 2 in diapers for a short time, they are now 9 and 7. My youngest daughter turned 2 in May. We are not even attempting to put her on the toilet yet. All of my children we easily trained. I don't think it is very fair that you are forcing him to train before he is ready. It is not his fault you don't want 2 kids in diapers.
@irishidid (8687)
• United States
25 Jun 08
From what I'm reading he has no concept of what he's expected to do and is not ready. Start taking him into the bathroom when you go or with your husband. He's got to relate the idea of peeing with sitting on the potty.
@chitchat (179)
• United States
25 Jun 08
It sounds like your son isn't ready for potty training yet. I wouldn't push him either b/c that will just make the situation worse. It could make him feel like he's a disappointment to you, that there's something wrong with him, it could make him feel ashamed of himself. There is nothing wrong with taking a break from potty training for a couple of weeks or so. Then when you take it up again with him, he might be more ready to take this next big step in growing up. It will make him feel like you understand him and he won't feel like a disappointment to you. There's no rush. He's only two. Every kid is different and if he's not ready there's really nothing you can do but wait for him to be.
@GreenMoo (11834)
25 Jun 08
Maybe your son just isn't ready for it yet? I don't think it would do any harm to give up for a while and return to it later. The alternative is that he gets stressed by the whole thing and that could be worse in the long term. If it makes you feel any better, I'm still dealing with wet patches too! My little son wants to be like Dad and wee standing up, so he holds himself and wees down his leg. On the one hand I have to feel impressed that he's got the idea, on the other I'm fed up of having to empty his shoes LoL
@spalladino (17891)
• United States
24 Jun 08
I've raised four kids and I had a hard time with my son, too, so I did give up. The reason was because going to the potty was becoming something that he saw as something negative, something that he did not want to do. Instead I left the potty chair in the living room and let him play with it whenever he was in the mood to and, eventually, he started showing an interest in being a "big boy" and using the potty. My philosophy is this: As long as the kid isn't still in diapers when he starts school, it doesn't matter exactly when he started using the potty. I had the same attitude about the bottle and none of my kids wore diapers or took a bottle to school.
• United States
24 Jun 08
I had that attitude with my older 3 children as well as far as the diapers went. They were all trained after they'd already turned 3. However I also have a 5 month old in diapers, and can't really afford to continue purchasing 2 pkgs a week, which is why I got this one started on the potty so early.
• United States
25 Jun 08
I also have a two year old...I have a girl. She only goes potty when she wants to. I give her a sticker every time she goes. So now she associates the potty with the sticker. It works pretty good. But her pediatrician told me that most kids aren't completely potty trained until they're almost 4 yrs old. So don't be in a big rush, your doing great. I know that it can be frustrating, but thet're only little once! Good Luck!
• United States
25 Jun 08
My sister had the same problem with her daughter. She is three now and she still wears diapers sometimes. She will go to the potty most of the time then others she won't.She was terrified of the toilet for a long time . She just would not sit on it. So don't worry all kids go through it differently
@subha12 (18441)
• India
25 Jun 08
it is so. but children do not understnad all these. so you have to baer with him. also just give him little reawards if he do not have accidents. it may work.
@carlaabt (3504)
• United States
25 Jun 08
My son was really easy to potty trained. I gave him stickers on his sticker chart, each time he used the potty, flushed, and washed his hands. I had a circle for each place that a sticker went, and then when he got to the tenth sticker in each place, I had the circle done boldly, so he understood where the stickers had to reach before he got his special prize, since he didn't grasp the concept of numbers yet. He was consistently peeing in the potty all the time about a 5 or 6 weeks before he was able to consistently poo in it, though. One thing that he really liked, was using the big potty, instead of his potty chair. He will use the potty chair if he really needs to go, and can't make it to the bathroom, but he prefers to use the big potty, with one of those little seats on it. It makes him feel more grown up!
@youdontsay (3497)
• United States
25 Jun 08
I've been told that boys don't potty train as early or as easily as girls. I wouldn't push it. If he associates the potty with unpleasantness it will just prolong the whole process. I'd pay attention to when he is urinating and set up a schedule to go to the potty, just to try, on that schedule. My daughter has a son and he learned to urinate standing up and trying to hit a Cheerio that she would put in the bottom of his pot. Of course, there were misses, but it was fun for him and he learned to control his urination. Just make sure the pot is where it is easy to clean up around it! Maybe his daddy needs to do some of that training by going at the same time in the same way. [Well, he probably won't need a Cheerio!]
@mary463 (145)
• India
25 Jun 08
My elder son now 5 years,when I started to train him potty,he himself use the potty like he was waiting for that one.And there was no problem with the potty use,whenever he want the potty he use it with my help.But my youngest now 1and half year old I am struggling with him to train the potty when he was 1 year.Now also he cried when I try to train him and all the time he use floors for that function.Sometimes in bathroom he use fo r the function.I fed with him for that training like you.Now I trained in the same way that grown up people doing t avoid floor cleaning.
@rane0328 (129)
• United States
25 Jun 08
I have two kids and my first was a pain to potty train, when u sit him on the potty try giving him a toy to play with, sometimes it will take their mind off of holding it and they will go and when he does potty make a big deal about it and give him some candy or something to reward him, skittles were my sons favorite, after one week my son was potty trained. and good luck!! :)
• United States
25 Jun 08
My son had a problem pooping on the potty. We had quite a few messes before he would finally do it. Don't give up...it will happen when he is ready. Don't push too hard, just let it happen on his time. Good luck!