Is It Your Opinion That Directors of Kiddie Movies Are Kids Themselves?
By pyewacket
@pyewacket (43903)
United States
September 4, 2008 8:56pm CST
Okay I had started a discussion asking if fellow MyLotters would admit though while being a sophisticated "adult" if they watch kids movies.
Then I thought of another angle to kiddie movies and shows in general...and even could extend to children's books as well.
Now obviously all children oriented movies and books are written by adults...maybe the rare exception might be Christopher Paolini who began his "Eragon" series while still in high school...crap...could you write a book like that while in high school??
Anyway, the thought occurred to me, that directors, screenwriters of movies, or authors of children orientated stories just must have the child within themselves otherwise how could they direct or write such stories?
For instance, while he has written/produced and/or directed very "heavy duty" movies, such as Schindler's List, Steven Spielberg is probably more remembered for his more children's orientated viewpoint of things, that is seeing from a children's viewpoint as we find in that great classic of his E.T.....to my mind if your not bawling your brains out with this movie you're not human.
Another great writer/director...George Lucas...While maybe not exactly a children's story he thought up the basis of what would be Star Wars while as a young teenager with a severe health problem that left him pretty much bedridden.
Beatrix Potter (whom I adore even now) grew up in strict, straight-laced standards, stricter than most Victorian households, yet she not only created spectacular art work but created her famous series of children's books beginning with Peter Rabbit over a hundred years ago...who knows? Maybe to escape the oppressiveness of her family upbringing...J.M. Barrie may have written Peter Pan to forget the personal tragedies in his own life and to do that wrote a children's book.
Zooming up...J.K. Rowling got the brainstorm for probably one of the most successful series of our modern time, that is Harry Potter and she did so while a single mother, living on the end of poverty, receiving welfare and once even considered committing suicide due to severe depression.
Another great author I think is Roald Dahl who wrote Matilda and later became a charming movie.
Then of course, there's director Andrew Adamson, who has brought the Chronicles of Narnia series alive and in my mind in spectacular fashion--he was also responsible for the Shrek movies
So I can't help thinking....do you think that anyone of these directors, screenwriters, animators (of cartoons) or authors who focus on children's orientated stories and bring them alive have kept the child within themselves and see things from a child's perspective? Have any of you ventured into writing children's stories? While I like to think of myself as a writer, have done some short stories and working on novels and like to think I have the child within...I seem to have a snag at the idea of writing a children's book...though just maybe one of my novels in the works might qualify..LOL
6 people like this
21 responses
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
7 Sep 08
I think most creative people have a spark of insanity....I know I'm not Normal...
1 person likes this
@polachicago (18716)
• United States
5 Sep 08
Aren't we all children?
We are free to dream when we are small. We have way to much responsibilities when we are grown up adults. Dreaming like little children is the best way to do.
Writing can be very easy escape from real life situation and stress.
Also, when you write, you can create whatever you want and create life for any character. I love cartoons and children stories. I cry when I watch movies for kids.
I have my never finished book about time traveling. I kept promising to myself to finish it soon.....
At least I know who will do all drawing for my book...
2 people like this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I do love to write myself...isn't it fantastic how one can create a whole "world"--one can be director, screenwriter, costume and scenic designer and play all the "roles"--when I do write I often talk what I'm writing out loud....the only ones to hear me are my cats but then they are used to their mom's odd behavior..LOL--I need to get back to writing myself..I had promised to write a bit in my book every single night, but admit to getting involved with other things...mmm...maybe I'll do some tonight....{Pyewacket leaves to go back to her book....}
1 person likes this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I don't care how mature a kid is , there isn't a kid out there who could direct films, kiddie or adult. True they can and have written the basics for the screenplay. Heaven knows they act in these films but to direct a film you need to be an adult. I agree that the director needs to have the viewpoint of a child to get the film to come out right. But he/she has to have the maturity to steer the ship, to have the right answers for both the producers and the cast.There are some who will remember Spielberg as the director of E.T. but there are more who remember him for Saving Private Ryan and Schindler's List.So he isn't just a kiddie film director.
1 person likes this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
19 Sep 08
I think there is a bias against " kiddie" films at the Academy . And I think there were members that didn't want to nominate And vote for Steven to win until Schindler's List.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
19 Sep 08
actually only a few days ago I did hear on the late, late news about this kid, think he's only twelve that has directed a film...wish I could find the article to match the news item
Yes more people will remember Spielberg for his more adult and serious films....a shame when you think of it, as his many kid-type movies were just as spectacular..in fact with the tons of movies he did direct, he didn't get his Oscar until Schindler's List
1 person likes this
@myahw20 (1115)
• Canada
5 Sep 08
Hehe. Well I am aware that some children's books are already written by kids themselves which is good. They know exactly what they want to say what message they want to convey. They know how to converse and reach into children their own age. However as for directing movies I have some doubts about it. We have to be realistic. In order to direct there are also a lot of technical aspects. That is why I was thinking maybe it can be a joined effort with a professional director and a child.It is after all very important to know the point of view of your viewers.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I don't know...I kind of think with director's maybe they just try to remember what it was like to be a kid. That would be awesome though if one day a child really DOES direct a movie though, wouldn't it?
1 person likes this
@tamarafireheart (15384)
•
5 Sep 08
Hi pye,
All these stories that have been written for children has to be written by people who are children within themselves, no child could write it like they did, it made the stories so great, especial when a film is made through the eyes of a child.
Tamara
2 people like this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
7 Sep 08
I actually just heard a story last night though about this eleven year old girl would did write a book, and not only was it published, but got to be on the NY Times Bestseller list! But that's a rarity....I really do think adults who write children's books or direct movies do have to see as a child sees.
@goddessjes (788)
• Philippines
5 Sep 08
hi.
my point of view, i think it's tougher writing a children's book or writing for a children's movie. one has to be extra creative and playful with the imagination. since children is the target market, they have to make these young earthlings stay put in front of the screen by creating something that will hold their attention.
plus it's not an easy job creating a storyline that is funny, visual, realistic and at the same time, with moral or lesson.
sometimes i laugh at myself for finding some movies as cheesy. but when i realize that am an adult, i tell myself, it's not for me, it's for kids. then i'd recall the movies i enjoyed when i was young...and really, i find them very cheesy. but i feel good, cuz at least it's a fact that i was really a kid cuz i enjoyed those films. and back then, those movies were blockbuster films for me. ehehe.
and let's face it, we enjoy movies for kids. sometimes adults are even more excited whenever there's a new flick in town.
it is, i think, a compliment if we say that directors or movie makers for children are definitely oversized kids. they have to be kids and young at heart to create very effective films that will touch the heart, humor and interest of children...and adults.
2 people like this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
19 Sep 08
I think a lot of children's movies though in the long run are a lot more "sophisticated" today than say some of the older movies, don't you? Of course having all the special effects available creates a really great visual treat
@rogue13xmen13 (14403)
• United States
5 Sep 08
Most of the directors who direct these children's films are children at heart, definitely. I am a child at heart, and when it comes to films from my favorite comic book series, I am picky, and I am hoping that the film is a lot like the comic books. So far, I have only seen few films that are just like the comic book. I love writing graphic novels and watching animated shows on Toon Disney (to those of you with DirecTV, turn to channel 292, and you will see Iron Man, X-Men, Spider-Man, The Incredible Hulk, and a few other animated shows from your 1990's past on this awesome channel). I have always been into heroes and folklore.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
19 Sep 08
Awww--not that's not fair..I don't have DirecTV Nuts I don't even have cable anymore. Waahhh...sure miss the Disney channel..
1 person likes this
@seabeauty (1480)
• United States
6 Sep 08
I have to admit I like the American Girl movie or movies, Narnia, The never ending story and goonies type movies.
I don't like cartoons. Sometimes I watch Spongebob with my 5 year old but that is the only one I can tolerate.
Cartoons or cartoon movies I can't stand. Don't like the loudness and the constant rapid movement of the characters the show or movie. oh especially Power Rangers. I feel like I they are all on a sugar rush and so are its creators lol.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
9 Feb 09
I like the Goonies type movie also...wasn't that Speilberg that directed that movie...think he's real big in being a kid at heart, especially his famous E.T. movie
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
5 Feb 09
Sometimes it seems that way, doesn't it? I'd say more than likely the ppl that make the childrens movies are really in touch with their inner child...perhaps they even have kids around to bounce idea's off. I know in the case of the Harry Potter writer, she used to tell her kids the stories as a bedtime story.
[b]~~AT PEACE WITHIN~~
**STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS**[/b]
@blackbriar (9076)
• United States
18 Sep 08
The directors would have to be kids at heart to come up with the children's movies like they have. I love them all.
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
5 Sep 08
hi pyewacket yes I do think that the directors, and screenwriters of E T and other s like the lion and the witch and the wardrobe are in touch with their inner child. They wou ld have to be to touch our inner children like they do. Also a lotof the animators really are just in their early twenties and have a lot of kid in them at heart. a friend of mines son is working at this and hes just a big overgrown kid with lots of imagination and will be named in credits one of these days. I think I have some of the kid at heart in me two as I have written seveal picture books as yet unpublished of course.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
19 Sep 08
You really should consider getting those picture books for kids published...why not? I wouldn't mind reading them myself...LOL..for the kid in me
@Bluepatch (2476)
• Trinidad And Tobago
5 Sep 08
Not really, it could be just something they are good at.
You should also remember that all of these writers and directors don't work by themselves.
They have a team of people who are there to come up with ideas and other kinds of help.
No, I just think they might be good at that the same way other people are good at other things.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
19 Sep 08
Mmm..that might be true for directors having help but not for the writers who write children's type stories..they usually wing it on their own.
@duxzpercival (4)
• Philippines
5 Sep 08
I think the kids would be good directors as well....they could come up with new ideas suitable on their ages.....remember that they do have theirown worlds that goes with their unending fantasies.....but they should be guided.....
1 person likes this
@bdankanich (36)
• United States
5 Sep 08
Honestly,
I think that the writers/directors/producers of most of the recent children's movies are just out to sell merchandise.
It used to be that Hollywood created great children's films and the popularity of those films resulted in successful merchandising which typically happened after the film was a blockbuster hit. But now days, I feel that movies are lacking in quality and that they are nothing more than two hour commercials created to sell all the merchandise for the movie, which typically goes on sale before the move is even out.
Hollywood has even resorted to resurrecting classic cartoons and TV shows, throw in a bunch of special effects, and then flood the stores with merchandise months before the film is released. It's all a ploy to make money. And kill the childhood memories of many adults.
@worldwise1 (14885)
• United States
5 Sep 08
I believe, pyewacket, that it is essential that we have a connection to our inner child. I don't think I could have overcome some of my personal obstacles in life had I not maintained the child-like qualities that I am famous for among those who know me. All of the famous people you mentioned have at least one thing in common: They were all once children! Childhood is the place where the seed which determines the direction in which our lives will ultimately lead are planted. Some people have an ability to nurture and grow that seed, and they wind up becoming known for the fruits they bear. Others, through neglect or disinterest, never bring their fruits to bear. I guess what I'm trying to say is that there is a child inside each and every one of us, and whether or not we choose to express it openly is up to us.
@rjblueyes (215)
• United States
5 Sep 08
This is one of the reasons I had kids! So I could be a kid myself without looking like a total weirdo. I can go to kid movies, read kid books, and play with some of the coolest toys they never had when I was a kid. I think inside almost everyone is a child. Some more than others, but that little kid is still there within us.
@rekcart83 (149)
• Philippines
5 Sep 08
IMO they're don't have to be kid themselves. I mean they've already experience being a kid once and so they have an idea on what kids might like. There's also their studies and research on what today's kids are. And together with their talent they are able to create films and books that appeals to a lot of children.
@Sam334 (125)
• Singapore
6 Sep 08
Published works intended for children, are common in the world, as they are the new generation that would eventually have to take over the control of the world.
To educate and entertain them in a good way causes authors to shift their style. Personally, it's all about target audience, but do keep in mind that childrens, whom do not have much to worry over, have much unused brain which are then used to wander, and thoughts come about.
Kids definitely have a creative mind, therefore works that are directed to the children are constantly improving and released, since they get bored after they know the story once or twice.
By mentioning their creative mind, I should also inform you that there are children authors, and I was one of them, who wrote three short stories which are then published.
An author who publish his works for children may not necessary have a child in them, but they definitely have kept the children in their mind, in order to produce successful works for the children.