Why should you respond their discussions?
By klaudine
@klaudine (3650)
Indonesia
September 8, 2008 12:05pm CST
I mean those people who doesn't even bother to look back to the discussion they have started. You tried so hard to think about the answer, and when you came with the brilliant comment that should have been rewarded as the best response, they never gave you feedback and don't even bother to see the answer.
I thought about it all night, remembering some members who never gave feedback to my response I wonder why I kept answering their discussion. Why do they have so many discussions while they actually never have time to look back on what they've made before. It makes me sad sometimes when I cared so much with this people and tried to share my experience with the hope that I could help, I didn't even get a thanks from them.
So why should I respond their discussions? Why do I even bother to see the discussion or giving them [+]? Why should I even care what would they say because they don't care about our opinion? As I have said many times, money is the bonus for the good discussions here in myLot, the important thing is the good discussion itself.
Do you feel what I feel about this kind of thing?
9 people like this
20 responses
@sutanhartanto (4122)
• Indonesia
8 Sep 08
yeah, i understand what you feel, klaudine. it also happens to me several time. the worst part is sometimes they 'accidentally' starting nice discussions, so i keep responding the discussions. and because the topics are interesting, i occupy my knowledge, feeling, memory, information i ever got, and my whole mental power (lebayyyy ) to create thoughtful and meaningful response; only to find that the response, along with other 20 responses are left 'unresponded'. it's like somebody call you; he talk to you much and when you are answering, he just hangs up. how annoying it is!
anyway, if that's happen to me, i will just take it as my karma LOL, cos in my early time in mylot, i used to acted like them :D
3 people like this
@sutanhartanto (4122)
• Indonesia
8 Sep 08
sorry for the poor grammar scattered in my response
1 person likes this
@marlena18042 (636)
• United States
8 Sep 08
Hello Klaudine. I can understand where you are coming form. I often wonder if the advice that I've given is being read or taken into consideration by the ones that do not respond back at all. I guess I will never know. I know for myself, I do not respond back to everyone that responds to my discussions because Some of the responses have no need for me to. But, I always end up responding to some,and I definitely read eveyone of them.
There are going to be some people on here that wont care what people write because they are only in it for the money, but on the other hand, there are going to be others that are truely out to get some advice from others!
Sometimes we just wont know, but keep giving you good, honest, responses because I'm sure you will be helping someone!
It is a shame that everyone isn't thinking the same way you are!
Happy Mylotting Klaudine!
3 people like this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Yes I know your reason. Some respond are just a one or two line posts which you never found it meaningful for the discussion, that is why you chose not to answer nor giving feedback at it. But at least you read them all... At least they knew that you read it.
Sometimes I just kept coming back to the discussion I had responded just wondering if the topic starter would come back and gave the respondents some clue whether she/he really read our comments to them. But eventually, I found out that they never showed up again after submit the discussion.
Thank you marlena, and happy Mylotting too :)
1 person likes this
@Amagnimo (635)
• India
8 Sep 08
You really have a point in your question! I do feel the same way, but since I am practising to take everything positively, I will try and feed you in with all the good things I can think of. Of course, you are right in your way, but such a thing usually happens with newbies. I so many times expected BRs or atleast those [+] but then hardly even the people look at [+]. I believe I haven't entered those discussions which are hot and active people had replied. Most of the times I have replied to questions which have less responses.
However, the good points :
1. It increases your post count + money.
2. There are members who would read your posts and there are members who would give you a [+]. I have always rated the question, atleast most of the times. And if I have got time to read the next persons answers, I would have rated it too, but I don't get it, why don't people rate me... Well, I did figure that out - I never joined discussions so actively or in active discussions. My replies were mostly to newbies, and hardly ever the new ones know anything.
3. Another good thing is every time you try to think good and big, your potential increases, and you are gonna write better - I bet you would have written your last response the best (unless you were in a mood swing! lol :D)
4. There's always a scope that your good answers will attract good friends - valuable - who would want to read you more.
5. Being descriptive is one of the goals of mylot. So why not complete it.
I personally have one more - when I type on mylot, I everytime seem to be practising typing, and my speed has increased here itself!
Lol... so Klaudine, don't give up, and don't worry - apart from all those thoughts of yours, there are these too, that is, if you can accept them!
Good luck and Happy mylotting, Klaudine! :)
2 people like this
@Amagnimo (635)
• India
9 Sep 08
Thanks so very much. Its very good that this response helped. Well, I never thought you to be a newbie - cause I usually even respond to those all people who are agitated at some kind of attitude of people over anything - lol, and it was easy to smell from your topic! lol. Well, but then, how long have you been here, you have really been fast!!
Thanks 'gain...! :) Happy Mylotting!
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
WOW AMAGNIMO
I believe you are a very positive person. I saw it from you very enthusiastic response that you don't really mind if your response didn't receive feedback. Good attitude, maybe I shouldn't give you any feedback to since you don't mind, do you? LOL. Just kidding, Amagnimo... I like it when someone gave me the positive comment, because I am not a positive person. I always see things from the negative side, so your comment is opening a new understanding from me to see this discussion.
Thank you very much and happy mylotting..
and bytheyway, you said that you usually answer for the newbies? So now you think I am a newbie here? How dare you!! just kidding..
1 person likes this
@yparson (581)
• United States
8 Sep 08
I sorta agree with you as well. I do the best I can to respond to my replies. Mylot is a discussion site, but i also feel you don't have to continue with the discussion forever unless you want to. Remember, everyone doesn't think like you so therefore, best response is your opinion not theirs. Shake it off, not everyone is kind and thoughtful as yourself. Just keep doing what you're doing and all will be alright. :)
2 people like this
@Beaver72 (446)
•
8 Sep 08
I think because your post count doesn't go up when you reply to your own discussion some new members think they wont earn from it so wont reply to your reply when infact you get awarded very nicely when you reply to your own discussions, i earned 62 cents in one day by doing this. I think they do go to read replies but dont reply for the reason above. Shame really because so many discussions get abandoned when there could be some debating going on
3 people like this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Yeah... sometimes people just care about the post count and doesn't care about having a real discussion here. You are right, they doesn't know that answering their own discussion would be very helpful in the earning. I know it because I gave feedback to my own discussion and I got somewhat bigger earning than just answering other people's discussion or just making a good discussion.
It's good to know that someone here also have the same thoughts about this. There could be a good discussion, but too bad, the topic itself has been abandoned by the owner.
1 person likes this
@tianli (311)
• China
9 Sep 08
hi,klaudine. Don't care about that.Do you find you have got a friendship with me by our discussions and responses .We can share our moods with each other and give the views to different problems.I think except for me ,there are many new friends on mylot,right ?? Forget this disagreeable experience and go on happy mylotting.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Hi tianli! You exactly know that I wasn't talking about you, right? You always care to answer my response and we're doing so great with the other discussions. I am very thankful that you do that to me, so that I can become a little bit positive for now :)
And you are exactly right, because of small things like that, it doesn't mean I have to be mourning on a very fun place like myLot, right? Happy myLotting too, tianli, and have a very nice day :)
@tianli (311)
• China
9 Sep 08
Hi , my friend ,in fact I don't understand what the meaning of "+" "-" "!". And what is the best response ?? Is it if you start a new discussion , you can choose a response that you think is the best ???right?? but how to do that??
Thanks for your answer.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
I think you could be right, subha12, but how do you know that they read you post or not if they didn't give any reaction of what you said? And I think giving feedback as a respond is not a bad thing either, it is not only the sign that you still care about your old topics, but also shows the respondent that you give them appreciation or respect for their opinion.
@sharra1 (6340)
• Australia
9 Sep 08
I understand how you feel. I mean when you put a lot of thought into a reply to a post and you get no response you do feel as though you are being ignored and wonder why you bothered.
I have never actually noticed if the same people do it all the time. Maybe I should be paying more attention. I know I always reply to people who answer my discussions.
I am puzzled though about the post count not going up. It seems to only go up when you do your first reply to a new discussion. If you post more than once in a discussion in response to someone else's post then your count does not go up and if you reply to people who answer your discussions then it does not go up.
I do not know if this means that you are not being paid for posts when the count does not change but if it does maybe that is why they do not bother. Maybe they are just trying to make money and are not really interested in the discussions. If so then it is a shame.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
I am so happy to know that you always answer people who replied your discussion. It means that not only you are here and give a d4mn with the discussion, but also you give respect and appreciation to other people. Good attitude, sharra1!
And I saw there is a question here. Yes it is true that your post count wouldn't go up when you are answering other people's response, but it is counted in the earning. So don't worry, your hard work is being paid by myLot :) And that's what people who never reply the discussion doesn't know. They thought the earning is counted only by how many posts counted. They never know that they are paid for being active.
Remember here, that in myLot what is counted is the activity, not posts (even the post could be the parameter of how active you are :))
Thank you for being here in this discussion. Have a nice day, sharra1.
Happy MyLotting :)
@dizzblnd (3073)
• United States
10 Sep 08
I thought about posting this very discussion last night. I saw a few people who would start 5 or 6 survey type discussions and only reply to the 1st responder when there were only 3 or 4 people total that responded. To me, that is arrogant, immature, and greedy.
Only handful of the people on my friends list don't respond to my replies, but they will respond to others.. that bites too.
Thank you for taking the time to read my mind and post this
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
10 Sep 08
arrogant, immature and greedy. WOW. I've never seen someone uses these three words in one sentence, and I believe that would be very bad. Don't be mad dizzblnd, because many of us experienced the same as you did. I mean, there are many myLotters also thinks the same and feel the same like you. You're welcome and I am very happy that you feel good with this discussion. And thank you very much for your participation here :)
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
9 Sep 08
Hi there!
Well, I don't feel that way.. I don't expect anything from anyone here. Either from my friends that they would always comment back on my responses to their discussions. Neither, I don't think that its a responsibility of the topic holder to comment back on the responses they receive.
Commenting back on responses is actually ones preference. Some make it a habit to respond back and some don't. It is also written in the mylot guidelines that we don't have to thank everyone who responded to our discussions. Usually, when you've build up a bond, thats where interaction starts and how the exxhanging of views goes where it would make or lead to a more exchange of views.
There are also alot of things going on here, so many duscussions that are coming in and so users are busy trying to find interesting topics that they can respond to, to help them earn. The fact that commenting on responses doesn't help us to earn, more likely users don't comment back.
I suggest just keep your focus on responding to discussions here. Don't be bothered if you were not commented back. You will only feel bad and unhappy about it. Besides, we can't force everyone to do the same as we do.
Cheer up. Ciao!
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Well that's a new different point of view. It is good for you not to bother that much about people. You would live a very happy life i guess :) And well, the fact is that we would still being paid for answering comments on our discussion. In fact, I prove it my myself. I responded to all comments coming in my discussion and I did it a whole day, and I got plenty from them. But still, I am happy to get new point of view in the discussion. Thank you very much for joining this discussion. Good luck and have a nice day :)
@sweethomecatring (1563)
• India
9 Sep 08
I feel that every right thinking person like you has the same feelings. But friend why most people are here at my lot to tell about their self what type of people they are. First they cry and request please please help me and respond this discussion I am in need. When they get lot of answer they forget to comment back. It really pains me when a advisory response is given but it is not commented. It also happens when you made a detailed discussion and it seldom get responded it also hurt. How you see it. Please comment and have nice day.
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
I saw here that you have 2 questions. One is why they bother making a "please please help me.." discussions and doesn't even bother to look back for people's advises, and the second one is that why even the most detailed and possible a good discussion ended up with only small amount of responses.
Well.. the second question is a little bit out of the topic but I know your feeling. Sometimes I made a topic, which for me, is a good topic that can make a good discussion, but instead of being the 'top discussion today' it ended up in the 'no responses' section. There are lots of possibilities. First, is that your topic is not interesting for the majority of people here, and the most possible reason is that your good topic is drowned by the very massive one-line-topic(which is also annoyed me so much)
And the "please please please help me.. " topic... well, as another mylotter fellow has mentioned before, they made such topics just to make people respond to them. They don't bother to reply because replying to the responses would not make the post count going up. They thought they wouldn't get paid for that. And for some people who cares about money more than about the discussion wouldn't bother to do that.
that's my comment, and you too, have a nice day :)
@stalin420 (19)
• India
9 Sep 08
I response their dicussion because i like to discuss about any matter it really gives me pleasure.And it is a sort of time pass.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Yes, thank you Stalin for being here in the discussion. So you have your own reason why you should answer their discussion and I think, from what you've told me you don't think it is a necessity for them to answer your response or not because you don't really care about the feedback. Is that what you mean? I am so sorry if there is a misunderstanding here, because I don't really understand your answer which for me is a little bit different from the others
@trisha_nava82 (1379)
• United States
9 Sep 08
Here's my reason for not responding to most of my discussions that I start. Because I do try to respond to most of the discussions that I start. But when someone responds to my discussion the reason that I may not respond to it is because I feel that there are sometimes they say something that I should not respond to or I just don't know what to say back. Then I also just don't want to say thank you for responding. I mean I do read what people say in my discussion, but like I said I don't know what to say in response back. So, but I do understand where you are coming from because I do post to some peoples discussion, but never get a response back. Especially on ones that I put a lot of thought into. But I think the matter here is that don't worry about it. Some people have a lot of reasons as to why they won't respond to your post. It may be the same reason as mine.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Well.. that happens too, LOL. I am so sorry, I didn't mean to offend you, trisha. I hope you don't feel that way. I understand your reason, I didn't know that something like what you said could happen here in myLot. I mean, you're right, sometimes someone just said something that really don't need to be responded, and there is no use you post a thank you comment on them because the thank you comment is not allowed here in myLot. Yes you are right and I agree with you, there must be many reasons why people don't give feedback. And I would try to do what you suggest not to be worry about people giving feedback or not. And thank you very much for participating here, Trisha. Have a nice day and happy myLotting :)
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Thank you very much for not taking this discussion personally. I also agree with you that some people who said nothing than just a 'thank you' is quite annoying. I mean, they could say something meaningful to respond our comment, and not just a simple thank you without any sense. I also understand the point you're giving me. I am so happy that we could share our experience here in this discussion, I hope you still enjoy this :) Happy myLotting :)
@trisha_nava82 (1379)
• United States
9 Sep 08
I'm not offended at all, but I can definitely understand where you are coming from. But you know what sometimes I truely get aggrivated when, people respond to your what you have posted in just a thank you and thats all. Nothing more before the thank you. But I am not offended, I completely agree with you all together.
1 person likes this
@janaktank (28)
• India
9 Sep 08
as i think that my reesponds will help them
also give guidence to them
janak
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Yes, I think you've giving me a good reason why we should keep responding on people's discussion, Janaktank. Thank you very much for you being here in my discussion, I believe you would like to help me with my discussion, right?
Have a nice day, Janaktank, and happy myLotting :)
@rogue13xmen13 (14402)
• United States
9 Sep 08
People on mylot should respond to others responses when they start a discussion, out of respect at least.
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
That was one of many other reasons why we should giving our respondents feedback of things that they have given to us. Giving respect and appreciation of people's opinion is not only would make people happy, but by giving other people some respect will make people give some respect to us as well :)
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
9 Sep 08
hi klaudine look here, I do care very much about all the
mylot friends who respond to my discussions and I do try
to answer them whenever I have time, but sometimes things'outside the net intrude and must be taken care of'
first in spite of everything on the net. My son,our breadwinner
'has been out of work for almost a month, and we got a three'
day notification on our rent, now these things take precedence'over evey thing else, we are in an emergency
situation and I think myfriends will understand that and I will get back as soon as I can. okay?
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Well seeing on your big post count, i believe that you are trying so hard to do that. And I don't blame you because I know that real life is more important. The thing is as long as you've tried to answer, even it would take long time to do that, people wouldn't complaining. At least they know that they are appreciated. People just need some appreciation (and money) here in myLot. Thank you very much for your participation in my discussion. I hope you can solve the emergency problem in your life real soon :).
Good luck Hatley!
@dawnald (85146)
• Shingle Springs, California
5 Jan 09
I feel the same way too and what totally surprises me is that some of these people get a LOT of responses to their discussions. You would think that they would not.
@SynthEtika (40)
•
9 Sep 08
Hello there Klaudine...
I do simpatize with what you are saying. We try so hard to lend a hand trying to make a difference and sometimes we get no response from the very same people we are trying passing advices too. All is not lost though, as even if they don't respond they probably will read the comment, if they don't, other people will so our words are not gone with the wind. If our words won't help them, maybe they will help somebody else.
I hope this won't stop you myloting, keep it up and take care...
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
Thank you for the moral support SynthEtika.
You get the point. And agree with you, that even the person to whom we direct the comment didn't read our opinions, other people would still do. And they could be the one that appreciate our opinion by still giving us [+] or maybe giving comments under our responses. That would be very nice, of course.
I am so glad you are joining this discussion, I hope you're having a nice day. Happy myLotting, SynthEtika :)
@belk89 (1103)
• Philippines
8 Sep 08
If i were on the same situation i would not respond to the discussion at all. Why would i waste my time typing my answer when they dont even care or doesnt even bother to say thank you. A person who doesnt know what gratitude is... deserved to be ignored. I wont waste my time thinking what will be the best way i can help someone who doesnt even bother to say a word over my response.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
WOW.. easy belk89, don't be so angry. There are lots of other mylotters have given some points to us why they doesn't reply to us. Well, yeah, I still think that some of them doesn't show the gratitude, but some of them just post for money. They didn't know that if they answer our response properly they would even earn much more than just making discussions. They don't know that we need some responses too, just to know that they still care to the topics.
So please don't be mad, myLot is a fun place to be in. Let's have fun here, having some discussion with many mylotters, not all of them neglect the discussions, I don't you can still have some discussion with all of us here :)
Cool now, belk89? Okay then, have a nice day, and happy fun myLotting :)
@platinum601 (276)
• United States
8 Sep 08
Alot of times i really do care but i dont respond back. If you dont respond back that doesnt mean you really could careless. You should have to put in thought b4 making disscussion i agree with that point in which you have.
1 person likes this
@klaudine (3650)
• Indonesia
9 Sep 08
That's nice, platinum. I am glad to know that you're still care even if you don't give your respondents any comments. I know that sometimes you think that it is not necessary to do that, but a little thank you would be very nice for your respondents, so at least they would feel really appreciated on what they've been writing all this time. I know that you think it would waste your time, but if you realize, people would never know that you care to the comments if you don't show that you are care.
Thank you for sharing me this, and I hope you're having a nice day :) happy mylotting platinum601