Abortion or adoption?
By kwenge
@kwenge (2487)
Kenya
September 15, 2008 3:28am CST
Hallo people, I know this topic is touchy but I want to hear your views......Depending on the situation you are in, what will you prefer, giving your baby for adoption or abortion?
14 responses
@ronaldinu (12422)
• Malta
19 Sep 08
I would go for adoption without any doubt. Abortion is never a solution. Two wrongs don't make a right. If I have an unplanned pregnancy, I would give my baby to adoption if I am not capable of taking care of him myself. I would never approve of killing an unborn child.
1 person likes this
@rakittera (802)
• Philippines
15 Sep 08
I would love to keep my baby, if it was me. But if the situation calls for a choice between adoption and abortion only, I would definitely choose adoption. I could not bear the thought of taking a life. It is a mortal sin and I would not be able to look at myself in the mirror knowing that I did something like take an innocent life.
@mimpi1911 (25464)
• India
15 Sep 08
This is a sensitive topic and I think it depends entirely on the individual and circumstances she is into. Me personally, think that adoption is a better choice if and when the pregnancy term is quite mature. But then that requires a lot of support and guts in our society if it is our of wedlock. In our society, this is largely condemned and even though abortion of mature pregnancy is not legal most would go for that.
People doing both must be having their own reasons and I would like them to have elders' opinion before any decision taken.
Thanks.
1 person likes this
@signum (545)
• Australia
22 Sep 08
That's a hard one. I am adopted and I have also had an abortion.
I would not give a child up for adoption because you never know if the people you give the child to will be responsible and loving.
My mother (the one who adopted me) loved the idea of having a baby but she was unable to get pregnant due to an operation. She adopted me and did all the right things till I was no longer cute and little. Once I became a toddler she did not want to look after or raise me. She would have been a good mother had I never got any older.
There were so many things that she did wrong after I turned 3. I think her not being able to fall pregnant was nature's way of saying "i don't think you will make a good mother so we will take that from you".
Being adopted, i've always wondered who my natural mother was and if she's alive etc, but never had the courage to start a proper search for her.
In regards to abortion, I really didn't know what else I could have done. The guy I was with at the time made it perfectly clear that if I did not abort, that I would get no help from him financially or emotionally, and that I could get out of his house.
At the time I had no one I could turn to for advice or another place to stay, and i was far too broke to be able to afford to raise a child.
Everyone had their own opinion.
@kwenge (2487)
• Kenya
23 Sep 08
hey signum, am really touched by your openness and the advice you are giving, not many people can confess that they have done an abortion and I think thats why they live with it forever, it is good to talk about it openly so that you ddont feel bad inside. As I said depending on the situation, I see where you are coming from. i can see the reason you would hate to give your baby for adoption.
Thanks for your response.
1 person likes this
@signum (545)
• Australia
23 Sep 08
Thank You. I must admit that it is easier to be open and honest online simply because no one knows me personally and I don't have to deal with people being nasty or forcing their opinions on me face to face.
There are only a few people in the "real" world who know about all of this, and I probably won't be telling many more as it's no one's business but mine.
If I choose to share it with people then that is up to me, and I would hope that the people in life that I have told can keep it to themselves. :-)
@jammyt (2818)
• Philippines
15 Sep 08
I would have to choose adoption --- at least I know that my child is alive and kicking. I cannot bear the thought of aborting a child. That is a mortal sin. Having my baby adopted gives me the slightest chance to see my child even from afar.
1 person likes this
@mrsgoodygoody00 (895)
• United States
25 Sep 08
I'm expecting my first baby, and ever since I found out I was pregnant, I've been so excited to be a mom! I do not believe in abortion of any kind. I don't care what the situation is. I think people who kill babies are sick, cruel, and very disgusting. It is so unfair that the babies never even get a chance at life. If you don't want your baby, please don't kill it. Give it to someone who really wants it. I always wonder what is so great about you that you would kill your own baby? It's just so sick. I don't understand it at all. I just can't think of any reason that would be good enough to kill an innocent baby.
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
25 Sep 08
I always wonder what is so great about you that you would kill your own baby? It's just so sick. I don't understand it at all
Why would you assume that its about the mother? and why assume that its about the child being in the world...Sometimes its about OTHERS involved AND about the pregnancy itself....You dont understand it, I get that, but be thankful that you don't because some of us DO understand it for various reasons obviously and I know that I personally would NEVER wish even on my worst enemy what we went through and WHY we had to change our minds and abort..
@GloomCookieLex (6073)
• United States
25 Sep 08
Nor do all women think a rice-sized fetus is baby in the first place.
@summum (13)
• Canada
8 Oct 08
hi
we are talking about the baby but you? nobody can give you advise because nobody knows your reason. I dont work for any organism or work again or for a cause i just for no reason feel i would love to help. If you want to talk, yes a complete stranger maybe its easier so i cant and i wont juge you. This is my email if you want i cant give you my phone number by email. gendronmelanie@hotmail.com
just to let you know someone is there for you. no jugement.
@sudiptacallingu (10879)
• India
15 Sep 08
Hi dear, when you say depending on the situation, I take it as a situation from which the woman cannot come out unscathed physically, mentally or financially…no matter how much she tries. Being a woman yourself, you will appreciate it that no woman would willingly abort her child. Now, first and foremost let us see till how long is abortion permissible. I think its till 24 weeks of pregnancy, after that the mother’s life is at risk. It’s a debatable issue whether a foetus … 24 weeks old can feel anything or ‘life’ as we know it (consciousness, awareness) comes into it. I have of course never seen an aborted foetus, but as of now, my view is that if situation demands so, I would abort the foetus…I would not think of it as ‘my baby’, rather I would view it as an unwanted liability which (being a woman) I am being forced to carry single-handedly, as a consequence of an act which was shared equally with me by a man.
If however, I am being able to somehow manage the situation and carry on with the pregnancy and see my baby, I don’t think I would be able to give it up for adoption.
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
24 Sep 08
Adoption is NOT an option for me....ever....and if I were preg, and there were no health issues to concern myself with I would have the baby..For me to abort again it would have to be a major life messing situation like it was last time and hopefully I'd never have to go through that again....Any other reason (FOR ME) just isnt a valid one..OH except if I were raped and got preg, then I would abort without even thinking twice..
@Croquetilla (1797)
• Spain
15 Sep 08
hello , i think that this depend to each person i think that i cant abortion but, i not have this situation becuase i like have my second baby:D
Some my friends had abortion and i try understand your situation and try was with she in this bad moments.
i cant abortion but i can understand that other person make this
@GloomCookieLex (6073)
• United States
16 Sep 08
Abortion. Every time and anytime. Not only do I never want kids and find pregnancy to be absolutely revolting, but I'm morally against the adoption system. Not only do I not trust our genetics to another generation, but I refuse to be a supplier for some bigoted couple who will only adopt a day-old white baby. I think it's sick that there are orphaned and abandoned children of all ages trapped in the system of agencies, foster homes, over-worked social workers and underfunded living centers, yet at the same time there are mile-long waiting lists of people who want babies.
@ANTIQUELADY (36440)
• United States
15 Sep 08
neither one, would keep my baby & raise it & love it. too much of that goes on in the world in my opinion.
@xcammiex (272)
• United States
26 Sep 08
Having gone through an adoption of sorts, I can honestly say I would rather have 10 abortions before even entertaining the thought of adoption again. Adoption = a life time of suffering. Having spoken to many adoptees, I'd rather my child didn't have to go through a lifetime of suffering either. Thus, abortion is a far better choice in my eyes.
That being said, I don't think the two are comparable. Abortion = carrying to term v.s not carrying to term while Adoption = parenting or not parenting. Two very different choices, IMO.
@vivapinay (231)
• Philippines
24 Sep 08
This is very difficult to answer. I think it really depends on the circumstances we are in. Being a Roman Catholic, I still believe that going into abortion is really a no no. But then again, I dont want to judge other people who goes for abortion. Maybe I am just fortunate enough that I did not get pregnant when I was young. But if example, I got pregnant at 18 - maybe I will have another views.